Value of: Ryan Murray and Josh Anderson to Montreal

[callan819]

Montreal could use another LHD capable of playing top 4 mins and have been craving a legit power forward for quite sometime.

Not only that, but Columbus could be looking at shedding some salary this offseason and have already been rumoured to be shopping Anderson and with Murray’s injury history, I could see them potentially being open to the idea.

thinking Mete would have to go if we got Murray since we would also have chiarot and Romanov on the left side, but would obviously have to add more.

Thoughts?

Click to read more...

 

[RationalExpectations]

Already another thread with exact same proposal.

Value of: - These CBJ Players

 

[Kellen]

Why would Columbus be looking to shed salary? They have tons of space ....

 

[Unbiased Fan]

Caufiield for both? No idea what would make sense for both teams. 2nd and Brook for Andersson. Murray for 1st 2021 lottery protected? Maybe Pohling, Brook and 2021 1st for Both?

 

[Baksfamous112]

Caufiield for both? No idea what would make sense for both teams. 2nd and Brook for Andersson. Murray for 1st 2021 lottery protected? Maybe Pohling, Brook and 2021 1st for Both?

- Absolutely not

- Yes

- Laughable

- Terrible

 

[Porter Stoutheart]

Those seem like risky players for Montreal, no? They are attractive if the price is right enough to offset the injury risk factor, but should Montreal really be in a position to take the risk? Or should Columbus sell relatively low on these players just due to recent health issues? I wouldn't be trading 1sts or recent top picks from a rebuilding team for them anyway. And Columbus has no incentive to give them up for less. Seems like a stalemate to me.

 

[Unbiased Fan]

- Absolutely not

- Yes

- Laughable

- Terrible

Terrible for who?

 

[Baksfamous112]

Terrible for who?

Montreal

 

[Unbiased Fan]

Montreal

You don’t think Murray is worth a 1st? LHD who can play top pair.

 

[Baksfamous112]

You don’t think Murray is worth a 1st? LHD who can play top pair.

When he’s healthy. He’s not worth a first to Montreal.

 

[CB Joe]

Montreal 1st will be high. No way they should trade that.

 

[Mickey Marner]

You don’t think Murray is worth a 1st? LHD who can play top pair.

He's a UFA in 2021, who hasn't played top pair with any sort of regularity, let alone played it well and is injured ~40% of the time. Of course he isn't worth a 1st.

 

[Unbiased Fan]

He's a UFA in 2021, who hasn't played top pair with any sort of regularity, let alone played it well and is injured ~40% of the time. Of course he isn't worth a 1st.

Okay I wasn’t aware he’s a pending UFA. But he played very well when healthy.

 

[ViD]

Has got to be Domi

 

[ole ole]

Has got to be Domi

Not a chance.

 

[Grand Admiral Thrawn]

Ces joueurs là ne m'intéressent pas!

Looking for players that A) can help the Habs and B) can help them for more than 40 games a season.

 

[Junohockeyfan]

Josh Anderson has to be the most controversial player. He played and produced like a 4th liner but will be paid like a top-6 forward based on past merits.

Opposing fans will propose crap deals based on his down season. CBJ fans will ask for unrealistic returns by ignoring his past season. There is little middle ground.

the best offer might be Joel Armia

 

[Barnaby]

So Montreal’s plan is to sell their soul for an off chance at the 2nd wildcard spot?

 

[smack66]

So Montreal’s plan is to sell their soul for an off chance at the 2nd wildcard spot?

Montreal has a plan? news to me.

 

[Viqsi]

The Jackets basically have one significant hole to be filled through trades. Montreal has the capability to do so, but I don't know if they have the desire.

 

[Burke the Legend]

Has got to be Domi

I would do that Domi for Murray & Anderson.

 

[Jay haller]

Do either of those guys speak French?

 

[CoachWithNoTeam]

It’s very difficult to get a read on the value of both of these players. Murray is easily one of Columbus’s 3 best defensemen, when healthy. Only Werenski and Jones are likely better defensemen. Anderson is one of their best wings, with only Atkinson, Nyquist, and Bjorkstrand as the players that we could argue are better. Any trade of either of them right now that isn’t for a top 6 forward feels like selling low.

 

[Legend123]

I would do that Domi for Murray & Anderson.

Nope

 

[The Moose is Loose]

Montreal

every trade is terrible for montreal according to you.

Geez it couldn't be that you overrate every single one of your players now could it?