Round 3 voting

Who would win each matchup?


  • Total voters
    11
  • Poll closed .

hockeynorth

Registered User
Aug 31, 2017
12,595
6,386
Matchup A:

:habs

Gabriel Landeskog (5.6M) - Nathan MacKinnon (6.3M) - Kevin Labanc (4.7M)
Evander Kane (7M) - Trevor Zegras (0.93M) - Alex Tuch (4.8M)
Tomas Nosek (1.25M) - Mikael Backlund (5.4M) - Ryan Hartman (1.9M)
Joe Thornton (0.70M) - Derek Stepan (6.5M) - Kaapo Kakko (0.93M)

Zach Werenski (5M) - Alec Martinez (4M)
Mikhail Sergachev (4.8M) - Zach Whitecloud (0.73M)
Dmitry Kulikov (1.2M) - Erik Johnson (6M)

Tristan Jarry (3.5M)
Cam Talbot (3.7M)


vs


:stars

Zach Hyman (2.250) - Mika Zibanejad (5.350) - Mark Stone (9.500)
Jason Robertson (0.795) - Ryan Getzlaf (8.250) - Timo Meier (6.000)
Robby Fabbri (2.950) - Adam Henrique (5.825) - Filip Zadina (0.894)
Tobias Rieder (0.700) - Riley Sheahan (0.700) - Travis Boyd (0.700)

Ivan Provorov (6.750) - Matt Dumba (6.000)
Ryan Lindgren (0.925) - Erik Karlsson (11.500)
William Lagesson (0.725) - Tucker Poolman (0.775)

Anton Khudobin (3.333)
Jake Oettinger (0.925)


Matchup B:



:bruins

Evgeni Dadonov - Evgeni Malkin - Bryan Rust
Brandon Saad
- Jonathan Toews - Jordan Kyrou
Nick Paul
- Adam Lowry - Tyler Motte
Liam Foudy
- Nic Dowd - Cal Clutterbuck

Jakob Chychrun - Ryan Ellis
TJ Brodie - Sean Walker
Mikey Anderson
- Jamie Drysdale

Jacob Markstrom
Adin Hill


vs


:avs

Filip Forsberg - Patrice Bergeron - Jesper Bratt
Clayton Keller - Joe Pavelski - Denis Gurianov
Jared McCann - Gabriel Vilardi - Dylan Cozens
Eric Robinson - Carl Soderberg - Tyson Jost

Devon Toews - Cale Makar
Brenden Dillon - Kevin Shattenkirk
Mike Reilly - Will Borgen

Darcy Kuemper
James Reimer
 

ConnorMcMullet

#12 Colby Cave
Jun 10, 2017
10,295
18,037
Boston is as good or better than Colorado everywhere except for top-pairing (Toews-Makar vs Chychrun-Ellis) and even then it's close.

Don't be fooled by @m0pe's cute avatar.
 

Llamamoto

Nice Bison. Kind Bison. Yep.
Sep 5, 2018
8,855
12,207
Why is everyone voting Montreal over Dallas? Ignore the Mackinnon factor for a second, and remember that Stone has been the better player this year.

Hyman - Zibanejad - Stone > Landeskog - MacKinnon - Labanc (It's close, but Zibanejad >> Landeskog and Hyman >> Labanc)
Robertson - Getzlaf - Meier > Kane - Zegras - Tuch
Fabbri - Henrique - Zadina > Nosek - Backlund - Hartman (Backlund is the best player here but Henrique is also a very solid 3C. Fabbri (50+ pt pace) and Zadina (40+ point pace) play together as well). Nosek - Hartman are iffy.
His 4th line is better, however.

Provorov - Dumba > Werenski - Martinez
Lindgren - Karlsson < Sergachev - Whitecloud
Lagesson - Poolman = Kulikov - Johnson

Jarry = Khudobin
Talbot = Oettinger.


Overall the teams are close, but my top-9 has a significant advantage throughout. I also have a very responsible top-line in terms of defensive play, and Rieder and Sheahan are both proven PKers.
 

m0pe

Registered User
Feb 24, 2020
4,285
4,712
Boston is as good or better than Colorado everywhere except for top-pairing (Toews-Makar vs Chychrun-Ellis) and even then it's close.

Don't be fooled by @m0pe's cute avatar.

Mullet admits my 1st pair is better but does not specify one area he is better than me (he says better OR as good). We therefore assume "as good" for all lines.

Meaning the top pair difference wins it for me. Vote right. Vote m0pe.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hockeynorth

ConnorMcMullet

#12 Colby Cave
Jun 10, 2017
10,295
18,037
Mullet admits my 1st pair is better but does not specify one area he is better than me (he says better OR as good). We therefore assume "as good" for all lines.

Meaning the top pair difference wins it for me. Vote right. Vote m0pe.
Does your avatar represent your center group?

Bergeron, Pavelski, Vilardi, and Soderberg are sloooow.
 

Gecklund

Registered User
Jul 17, 2012
25,333
11,950
California
Is the guy with a toast/broke Malkin and a Toews who doesn't even play really judging my elite two-way center core.

Bad look.
M0pe should know how bad Malkin is. He has him on his fantasy team. Therefore he’s right.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad