Marc-Andre Fleury's having the type of season I'd hoped from him since he was taken 1st overall. However (and here it is...), I'm still waiting to see him carry this over to the post season. If he can be lights out in the playoffs -- not just decent, not just solid, but actually play as well as he currently is -- then he's got my vote.
Comeau's an obvious choice, even though he wasn't a Pen last year. But the Pens version of Comeau is so much better than the one that's been skating around the ice the past few seasons. Such a bargain signing.
I think Letang's also had a much more consistent season, at both ends of the rink. He still has his issues, and I'm still not sure he's ever going to be money on the PP, but he's playing at a level that's well worth his price tag.