Rank 25 Goalies of the 90's

[LeafErikson]

Hasek, Roy, Belfour, Brodeur, Richter, Barasso, Joseph, Potvin, VanBiesbrouck, Hrudy, McLean, Fuhr, Vernon, Kidd, Kolzig, Hextall, Moog, Rhodes, Tugnutt, Irbe, Thibeault, Ranford, Carey, Osgood, Burke, Puppa.
Mine...

1. Hasek
2. Roy
3. Brodeur
4. Belfour
5. Richter
6. Joseph
7. Barasso
8. Vernon
9. VanBiesbrouck
10. Ranford
11. Osgood
12. Potvin
13. Irbe
14. Hrudy
15. Hextall
16. McLean
17. Fuhr
18. Thibeault
19. Tugnutt
20. Moog
21. Kidd
22. Puppa
23. Burke
24. Rhodes
25. Carey




I'm sure there's someone I maybe missed here, or you guys will disagree. Make up your own lists, because I'm interested to see what 25 goalies you think of, from the 90's.

Fixed.

Click to read more...

 

[Pfft]

Osgood definitely deserves to be there over a backup who rarely played in Roloson.

 

[ck26]

"Goalies of the '90's" = ignoring what they did during the 80's and 00's. I'm assuming that Rhudy = Kelly Hrudey, the Kings goalie for a bunch of years. I also took Roloson off and replaced him with Chris Osgood, another Cup winner.

1. Dominik Hasek
2 Martin Brodeur
3 Ed Belfour
4 Patrick Roy
5. John Vanbiesbrouck - his run with the Panthers in '96 was awesome
6. Mike Richter
7. Chris Osgood - won a Cup, which most of these clowns never did
8. Mike Vernon
9. Curtis Joseph
10. Tom Barasso
11. Arturs Irbe
12. Jim Carey - won a Vezina
13. Felix Potvin
14. Ron Hextall
15. Kirk McLean
16. Grant Fuhr
17. Andy Moog
18. Jocelyn Thibeault
19. Bill Ranford
20. Kelly Hrudey
21. Ron Tugnutt
22. Trevor Kidd
23. Damian Rhodes
24. Stephane Fiset
25. Glenn Healy

 

[arrbez]

For making me giggle every time, Daren Puppa needs to be on this list.

 

[Andrew Knoll]

You've got Roloson there which is laughable, sorry, Hextall is a bit low, Osgood should be there for sure, I'll take Barasso, who never gets his due, over Richter ... and I'd have to think about having Fuhr so low although his best years were certainly in the 80s.

 

[LeafErikson]

I did the list off the top of my head. And for whatever reason, I forgot Osgood.

 

[reckoning]

Giggles aside, Puppa deserves to be there. Had some solid years with Buffalo and IMO deserved the Vezina in `96 with Tampa over Carey. You could make a case for Sean Burke as well.

 

[LeafErikson]

"Goalies of the '90's" = ignoring what they did during the 80's and 00's. I'm assuming that Rhudy = Kelly Hrudey, the Kings goalie for a bunch of years. I also took Roloson off and replaced him with Chris Osgood, another Cup winner.

Ranford so low? Conne Smythe, Stanley Cup...behind Thibeault, Carey, Irbe, and McLean?

 

[LeafErikson]

Giggles aside, Puppa deserves to be there. Had some solid years with Buffalo and IMO deserved the Vezina in `96 with Tampa over Carey. You could make a case for Sean Burke as well.

Ah fek, Burke. Puppa does deserve to be there, definitely over Healy anyway. Gonna edit my list.

 

[LeafErikson]

I guess maybe I should explain my rankings. Stanley Cups, or major awards have gotten some on this list, just for that. Ranford is ahead of some, that may have a better wins/loss record in the regular season through the 90's, but he has a Conne Smythe, and a Cup to his name. Others are ahead based on playoff performance, and regular season performance. And others, the top of the list, are obvious.

 

[Blackhawkswincup]

1-Belfour
2-Hasek
3-Roy
4-Martin Brodeur
5-John Vanbiesbrouck
6-Mike Richter
7-Curtis Joseph
8-Mike Vernon
9-Chris Osgood
10-Kirk Mclean
11-Artrus Irbe
12-Tom Barasso
13-Felix Potvin
14-Ron Hextall
16-Grant Fuhr
17-Andy Moog
18-Jon Casey
19-Bill Ranford
20-Darren Puppa
21-Olaf Kolzig
22-Ron Tugutt
23-Tommy Salo
24-Guy Hebert
25-Nikolai Khabibulin

 

[TANK200]

Guy Hebert was very good during the 1990s. I'd say he should be top 10 for sure, but I guess he isn't good enough to even make it onto most people's lists. Poor guy.

 

[pnep]

# | Goalie | "HHOF Monitor" PTS (1990-00)
1|Dominik "The Dominator" Hasek |2151,00
2|Patrick "St Patrick" Roy |1345,50
3|Ed "The Eagle" Belfour |1250,00
4|Martin "Marty" Brodeur |853,00
5|Tom "Tomcat" Barrasso |592,00
6|Mike "Vernie" Vernon |483,00
7|Chris "Ozzy" Osgood |476,50
8|Kirk "Captain Kirk" Mclean |437,00
9|Curtis "Cujo" Joseph |426,50
10|John "Beezer" Vanbiesbrouck |398,00
11|Olaf "Godzilla" Kolzig |381,50
12|Mike "Iron Mike" Richter |341,50
13|Jim "Net Protective" Carey |320,00
14|Roman "Mr. Empire" Turek |228,00
15|Grant "Coco" Fuhr |221,50
16|Ron "Hexy" Hextall |215,50
17|Felix "The Cat" Potvin |215,00
18|Andy "Peaches" Moog |212,00
19|Jon "The Human Snow Angel" Casey |197,50
20|Bill "Billy The Kid" Ranford |189,50
21|Kelly "Hollywood" Hrudey |168,00
22|Ron "Tugger" Tugnutt |144,50
23|Ken "Wreggs" Wregget |141,50
24|Byron "Lord Byron" Dafoe |135,00
25|Arturs "Archie" Irbe |133,00

 

[WingsFan95]

The Beezer, even with what Roy did for the Canadiens and Avalanche, even with Hasek's UNTOUCHABLE back to back Harts & LBP.

I just think a goalie who took the Panthers ( NHL's Arizona Cardinals ) to the Stanley Cup Final is just otherworldly.

 

[Blackhawkswincup]

The Beezer, even with what Roy did for the Canadiens and Avalanche, even with Hasek's UNTOUCHABLE back to back Harts & LBP.

I just think a goalie who took the Panthers ( NHL's Arizona Cardinals ) to the Stanley Cup Final is just otherworldly.

How are they the NHL's equivalent to the Arizona Cardinals?

The Panthers have been to playoffs several times and gone to the championship game. And they have only been around for about 15 years now. And most seasons they are competitive.

If your looking for the NHL Arizona Cardinals. Look no further then the Coyotes/Jets!

 

[amnesiac*]

Bob Essensa!

 

[WingsFan95]

How are they the NHL's equivalent to the Arizona Cardinals?

The Panthers have been to playoffs several times and gone to the championship game. And they have only been around for about 15 years now. And most seasons they are competitive.

If your looking for the NHL Arizona Cardinals. Look no further then the Coyotes/Jets!

Yeah but all those playoff appearances were with The Beezer.

I mean, had the Arizona Cardinals had Warner back in the 90s who knows where they'd be right now.

Jets/Cayotes is a pitiful franchise yes, but they did at one point make 7 straight playoff appearances.

The Panthers have the current longest playoff drought and they're really on the move.