Rinne is the sole reason the Blackhawks rarely established a forecheck on their dumps. He was otherworldly in controlling the play on dumps.
I'll take Rinne making the first pass over Subban, Josi, Ellis, and Ekhom every single time. IMO your top 4 is the best transition D in the NHL.
I probably worded my post poorly.
I'm not trying to say he is a poor decision-maker, but no goalie makes the correct decision with the puck every time. The more times we are forcing Rinne to play the puck (rather than being able to just set it up for a defender), the greater the chances that a poor decision is made. My experience watching Rinne is that his pure strength playing the puck isn't good enough to overcome a bad decision and his bad decisions have a greater chance of leading to turnovers than a goalie like Bishop who can just wire the puck consistently.
I'd rather force Rinne to beat our forecheck than any of the top 4 D man. They are just objectively better at transitioning the puck than Rinne, so putting the puck in Rinne's control as much as possible is a good thing for the Blues.
Edit: I just read your most recent post and agree with you 100%. I'm not looking for the Blues to dump it behind the net. I'm looking for soft dumps toward the corners with a forechecker coming with speed. I want to see Rinne forced to decide between wandering laterally to play the puck ahead of the goal line or conceding possession to our forechecker/watching his D man take a brutal hit.