Stizzle
Registered User
- Feb 3, 2012
- 13,209
- 23,193
Since we are almost done the forum consensus prospect voting, and it's been slow here the last few days, it seems like a decent time for everyone to post there personal prospect ranking for the summer. Here is a link to the past two we have done...
Summer 2015
http://hfboards.mandatory.com/showthread.php?t=1935733&highlight=
Winter 2016
http://hfboards.mandatory.com/showthread.php?t=2013057&highlight=
-------------------------------------------
My personal rankings:
1- Travis Sanheim (LHD, 2014 1st rd)
2- Ivan Provorov (LHD, 2015 1st rd)
3- Phil Myers (RHD, 2015 undrafted FA)
It looks like most people want to see him have a repeat year before putting him in the upper echelon. I'm already sold. A 6'5 right-handed defenseman that can do everything. His numbers may even drop this year with the massive amount of talent Rouyn-Noranda is losing up front. We'll have to watch and see, but I'd bet his overall play keeps improving.
4- German Rubtsov (C, 2016 1st rd)
I've been watching some of his games that are on YouTube. His skating is better than I was expecting. Other than that, he seems exactly as advertised. A skilled, workhorse center, that plays in all situations.
5- Travis Konecny (RW, 2015 1st rd)
I love the guy but the injuries worry me some. It's a factor on why I'm willing to rank him lower than anyone else will. It also speaks to how highly I think of Myers and Rubtsov. Plus big, skilled 2-way centers and RHD are just flat out at a premium.
6- Samuel Morin (LHD, 2013 1st rd)
7- Pascal Laberge (RW, 2016 2nd rd)
A real coup by Hextall to trade back a few spots in the 1st, and land this pick for doing so in the early 2nd.
8- Oskar Lindblom (LW, 2014 5th rd)
9- Wade Allison (RW, 2016 2nd rd)
I'm not exactly sure what we have here with him, but it's mighty intriguing. A power forward with skill who finished the year in dominant fashion.
10- Mikhail Vorobyov (C, 2015 4th rd)
1st line center for Russia at the World Juniors this year? Yes, please.
11- Mark Friedman (RHD, 2014 3rd round)
12- Nicolas Aube-Kubel (LW, 2014 2nd round)
13- Radel Fazleev (C, 2014 6th round)
It was a true joy watching him work from bottom of the roster to big time minutes during the World Juniors last year.
14- Linus Hogberg (LHD, 2016 5th rd)
Hextall says he's there sleeper pick and I believe him. Good size and skating, one of the very youngest players in the entire draft, and scored even while playing on a really bad team.
15- David Kase (LW, 2015 5th)
I originally ranked Kase a hair higher, but dropped him because it looks like he might be stuck playing crap minutes again in the top Czech league.
16- Robert Hagg (LHD, 2013 2nd rd)
Kerry Huffman to the rescue? Hagg just hasn't shown much improvement since being drafted. I'm not writing him off. It's a huge red flag, though.
17- Cole Bardreau (C, 2015 College FA)
18- Carsen Twarynski (LW, 2016 3rd rd)
19- Taylor Leier (LW, 2012 4th rd)
17, 18, and 19 is pretty much a toss up for me. They all have there pros and cons.
Twarynski has size, athleticism, tenacity, and the most upside of the 3.
Leier can do everything pretty well. He's just small and I don't know where he ideally fits in the lineup of a true contender.
Bardreau has a lot of attributes you like to see in a smart, pain in the ass, 4th line center.
20- Mark Alt (RHD, aquired via trade from Carolina, 2010 2nd rd)
This last spot could have gone to any number of guys, but I have a soft spot for big, athletic RHD.
*Roman Lyubimov - I chose not to include for consideration because of age, experience level, and my own lack of knowledge.
_______________
Goaltenders:
1- Anthony Stolarz (2012 2nd rd)
A high upside project that showed big strides last season.
2- Carter Hart (2016 2nd rd)
3- Felix Sandstrom (2015 3rd rd)
For two teenagers, Hart & Sandstrom seem polished as ****. Hart just turned 18 last week.
4- Matej Tomek (2015 3rd rd)
This kid isn't dead. People are forgetting what a highly regarded prospect he was before the draft.
5- Alex Lyon (2016 College FA)
6- Merrick Madsen (2013, 6th rd)
A pretty killer year from him. An interesting player who is lost in the shuffle of a stacked group of prospects in net.
7- Ivan Fedotov (2015 7th rd)
Summer 2015
http://hfboards.mandatory.com/showthread.php?t=1935733&highlight=
Winter 2016
http://hfboards.mandatory.com/showthread.php?t=2013057&highlight=
-------------------------------------------
My personal rankings:
1- Travis Sanheim (LHD, 2014 1st rd)
2- Ivan Provorov (LHD, 2015 1st rd)
3- Phil Myers (RHD, 2015 undrafted FA)
It looks like most people want to see him have a repeat year before putting him in the upper echelon. I'm already sold. A 6'5 right-handed defenseman that can do everything. His numbers may even drop this year with the massive amount of talent Rouyn-Noranda is losing up front. We'll have to watch and see, but I'd bet his overall play keeps improving.
4- German Rubtsov (C, 2016 1st rd)
I've been watching some of his games that are on YouTube. His skating is better than I was expecting. Other than that, he seems exactly as advertised. A skilled, workhorse center, that plays in all situations.
5- Travis Konecny (RW, 2015 1st rd)
I love the guy but the injuries worry me some. It's a factor on why I'm willing to rank him lower than anyone else will. It also speaks to how highly I think of Myers and Rubtsov. Plus big, skilled 2-way centers and RHD are just flat out at a premium.
6- Samuel Morin (LHD, 2013 1st rd)
7- Pascal Laberge (RW, 2016 2nd rd)
A real coup by Hextall to trade back a few spots in the 1st, and land this pick for doing so in the early 2nd.
8- Oskar Lindblom (LW, 2014 5th rd)
9- Wade Allison (RW, 2016 2nd rd)
I'm not exactly sure what we have here with him, but it's mighty intriguing. A power forward with skill who finished the year in dominant fashion.
10- Mikhail Vorobyov (C, 2015 4th rd)
1st line center for Russia at the World Juniors this year? Yes, please.
11- Mark Friedman (RHD, 2014 3rd round)
12- Nicolas Aube-Kubel (LW, 2014 2nd round)
13- Radel Fazleev (C, 2014 6th round)
It was a true joy watching him work from bottom of the roster to big time minutes during the World Juniors last year.
14- Linus Hogberg (LHD, 2016 5th rd)
Hextall says he's there sleeper pick and I believe him. Good size and skating, one of the very youngest players in the entire draft, and scored even while playing on a really bad team.
15- David Kase (LW, 2015 5th)
I originally ranked Kase a hair higher, but dropped him because it looks like he might be stuck playing crap minutes again in the top Czech league.
16- Robert Hagg (LHD, 2013 2nd rd)
Kerry Huffman to the rescue? Hagg just hasn't shown much improvement since being drafted. I'm not writing him off. It's a huge red flag, though.
17- Cole Bardreau (C, 2015 College FA)
18- Carsen Twarynski (LW, 2016 3rd rd)
19- Taylor Leier (LW, 2012 4th rd)
17, 18, and 19 is pretty much a toss up for me. They all have there pros and cons.
Twarynski has size, athleticism, tenacity, and the most upside of the 3.
Leier can do everything pretty well. He's just small and I don't know where he ideally fits in the lineup of a true contender.
Bardreau has a lot of attributes you like to see in a smart, pain in the ass, 4th line center.
20- Mark Alt (RHD, aquired via trade from Carolina, 2010 2nd rd)
This last spot could have gone to any number of guys, but I have a soft spot for big, athletic RHD.
*Roman Lyubimov - I chose not to include for consideration because of age, experience level, and my own lack of knowledge.
_______________
Goaltenders:
1- Anthony Stolarz (2012 2nd rd)
A high upside project that showed big strides last season.
2- Carter Hart (2016 2nd rd)
3- Felix Sandstrom (2015 3rd rd)
For two teenagers, Hart & Sandstrom seem polished as ****. Hart just turned 18 last week.
4- Matej Tomek (2015 3rd rd)
This kid isn't dead. People are forgetting what a highly regarded prospect he was before the draft.
5- Alex Lyon (2016 College FA)
6- Merrick Madsen (2013, 6th rd)
A pretty killer year from him. An interesting player who is lost in the shuffle of a stacked group of prospects in net.
7- Ivan Fedotov (2015 7th rd)