Please vote for the HHoF worthy goalies

[Say Hey Kid]

Please vote for the HHoF worthy goalies. They all have 361+ wins.

Click to read more...

 

[banks]

Not many on this list. Quick, Price, MAF.

 

[Say Hey Kid]

We need more votes.

 

[Albatros]

Fleury and maybe Cujo now that the bar is so low. Don't get it any lower though.

 

[HolyHagelin]

I only voted for Quick and MAF. Hard to argue against those guys.

Rinne and Beezer both seem close to me, they have the highs for sure but not the consistency.

Price has enough apologists. I refuse to vote for him because 1 great season is not enough, and he was never in the conversation as the best guy outside of that one year. People still act like he had some Brodeur level career when really he was just a guy who maintained his best hot streak for one whole season. Tired of hearing about this overrated chump.

 

[Bouboumaster]

Price has enough apologists. I refuse to vote for him because 1 great season is not enough, and he was never in the conversation as the best guy outside of that one year. People still act like he had some Brodeur level career when really he was just a guy who maintained his best hot streak for one whole season. Tired of hearing about this overrated chump.

Price was voted like 4 years un a Row by the players as the best goalie in the World, but ok lol

Still, he's better than Lundqvist

 

[ViD]

Bob gets in with 2 Vezinas and SCF appearance

Not first ballot though

 

[Johnny Tomala]

Only Fleury and Price.

 

[Miro4Norris]

Rinne, Fleury, Price, Quickie

 

[Madap]

I only voted for Quick and MAF. Hard to argue against those guys.

Rinne and Beezer both seem close to me, they have the highs for sure but not the consistency.

Price has enough apologists. I refuse to vote for him because 1 great season is not enough, and he was never in the conversation as the best guy outside of that one year. People still act like he had some Brodeur level career when really he was just a guy who maintained his best hot streak for one whole season. Tired of hearing about this overrated chump.

Now this is certainly a take…. Price was consistently a top goalie and played in front of really bad or mediocre Montreal teams. This coming from a leaf fan.

 

[Adele Dazeem]

Price never won anything, so hall of great for him.

 

[David Suzuki]

Price never won anything, so hall of great for him.

was the best player on the best team of all time in the 2014 olympics

 

[Pukboy5kroner]

Price never won anything, so hall of great for him.

Didn't he win a trophy only a few goalies have won?

 

[Evergreen]

Fleury, Quick and Price.

 

[tarheelhockey]

he was never in the conversation as the best guy outside of that one year.

He was in that conversation for several years.

 

[wetcoast]

Goalies are too team dependant so I'm not voting will defer to people who know more about them.

 

[majormajor]

To get in the Hall you apparently need to play your career on a juggernaut or play for the Montreal Canadiens. One or the other (both is impossible).

So Fleury, Quick, and Price.

(In actuality I think CuJo and Bob have equally good claims).

Fleury was a net negative for the Pens in the playoffs for years so that should disqualify him.

 

[b in vancouver]

You forgot Rask.

 

[Neutrinos]

Fleury & Quick vs Cujo & Beezer

Fleury (age 22-38)
96 GA%, 86.2 GSAA
Best season: 78 GA%, 20.8 GSAA
Number of seasons below 90 GA%: 3
Number of seasons above 20 GSAA: 2

Quick (age 23 - 32)
95 GA%, 58.5 GSAA
Best season: 83 GA%, 28.1 GSAA
Number of seasons below 90 GA%: 1
Number of seasons above 20 GSAA: 1

Joseph (age 22-38)
93 GA%, 185.6 GSAA
Best season: 77 GA%, 57.4 GSAA
Number of seasons below 90 GA%: 6
Number of seasons above 20 GSAA: 4

Vanbiesbrouck (age 22-37)
93 GA%, 161.3 GSAA
Best season: 72 GA%, 55.6 GSAA
Number of seasons below 90 GA%: 5
Number of seasons above 20 GSAA: 5

 

[Voight]

I only voted for Quick and MAF. Hard to argue against those guys.

Rinne and Beezer both seem close to me, they have the highs for sure but not the consistency.

Price has enough apologists. I refuse to vote for him because 1 great season is not enough, and he was never in the conversation as the best guy outside of that one year. People still act like he had some Brodeur level career when really he was just a guy who maintained his best hot streak for one whole season. Tired of hearing about this overrated chump.

FWIW Rinne has more Vezina nominations than Price does.

IMO Beezer is worthy of induction but the Daley incident significantly hurts his chances. Including his Vezina win he has nine top ten Vezina finishes plus his notable playoff run in 1996.

 

[FrozenJagrt]

To get in the Hall you apparently need to play your career on a juggernaut or play for the Montreal Canadiens. One or the other (both is impossible).

So Fleury, Quick, and Price.

(In actuality I think CuJo and Bob have equally good claims).

Fleury was a net negative for the Pens in the playoffs for years so that should disqualify him.

I don't see what Cujo's claim is. He had a couple pretty good years, but never won a thing. Never even made a post season all star team to my recollection.

Career high SV% of 0.915 and a career high in wins of 36. Not particularly impressive. More comparable to Frederik Andersen than Sergei Bobrovsky.

 

[HFpapi]

Fleury leading the poll?

Why oh why do people want to put people in the HOF for being mediocre but for a very, very, long time?

The dude almost single handedly got the Pens kicked out of the playoffs multiple times and had to be replaced by his backup in the playoffs in what should have been the prime of his career.

He was never anything better than an average goalie he just happens to have stuck around for a real long time so his career win totals are high. His Vezina came in a season where he played 36 games.

Stop watering down the HOF with extended mediocrity. If you were never top 5 at your position for multiple years please stay away.

He's the Patrick Marleau of goalies.

 

[pegcity]

Not enough love for the number one cop on the force and Rinne.

 

[majormajor]

Fleury leading the poll?

Why oh why do people want to put people in the HOF for being mediocre but for a very, very, long time?

The dude almost single handedly got the Pens kicked out of the playoffs multiple times and had to be replaced by his backup in the playoffs in what should have been the prime of his career.

He was never anything better than an average goalie he just happens to have stuck around for a real long time so his career win totals are high. His Vezina came in a season where he played 36 games.

Stop watering down the HOF with extended mediocrity. If you were never top 5 at your position for multiple years please stay away.

He's the Patrick Marleau of goalies.

Patrick Marleau was a good player who was sometimes just okay.

Fleury was sometimes good, sometimes dogshit. Mostly dogshit for the Penguins.

Nice personality and played on great teams, so he'll get in, but it ain't right.

 

[I am not exposed]

Fleury leading the poll?

Why oh why do people want to put people in the HOF for being mediocre but for a very, very, long time?

The dude almost single handedly got the Pens kicked out of the playoffs multiple times and had to be replaced by his backup in the playoffs in what should have been the prime of his career.

He was never anything better than an average goalie he just happens to have stuck around for a real long time so his career win totals are high. His Vezina came in a season where he played 36 games.

Stop watering down the HOF with extended mediocrity. If you were never top 5 at your position for multiple years please stay away.

He's the Patrick Marleau of goalies.

My sentiments as well.