Wow...good topic. May take awhile to respond though. My list is very Red Wing heavy.
Pete Mahavolich - Very friendly. Met him when he was winding his hockey career down as the player/coach of my hometown Toledo Goaldiggers. I didnt realize at the time just how great of a person I was meeting.
Steve Yzerman - Believe the hype. I have had the luxury of meeting him 3 times, and he has been the same each time. Friendly, talkative, makes you feel like he really wants to talk to you. True gentlemen.
Sergei Fedorov - Just sort of "blah". Not overly friendly, but not abrasive by any means either.
Gordie Howe - One of the most personable men I have ever met. I have actually met Gordie dozens of times, and he is simply a kind and gentle person to everybody he comes into contact with.
Ted Lindsay - Met Terrible Ted twice, and he was very cordial both times.
Kris Draper - Nice guy. Very cordial, but not someone who leaves a lasting impression.
Martin Lapointe - Real quick meeting with him, but he was friendly enough.
Slava Fetisov - Nice guy
Joe Kocur - Nice guy
Bob Rouse - Nice guy
Kirk Maltby - Nice guy (how ironic)
Chris Osgood - Really enjoyed meeting him. Actually got to spend about a half hour with him at a hockey camp once. He comes off as shy, but he really didnt seem like that when I met him. Nice guy.
Adam Graves - Met him and Tim Taylor in a Chicago Mall one night. Quick encounters, but both guys seemed suprised that I recognized them. Both friendly guys.
Tim Taylor - see above
Daniel Alfredsson - I literally bumped into him in the hotel gift shop of the Westin Hotel in Toronto. It was about 2am in the morning, and my wife and I were just coming back in from a night on the town. He was very friendly and took 3 pictures with us. My wife, of course, had no idea who he was, and I think he found that very funny. Good encounter.
Nicklas Lidstrom - Had about a 5 second encounter with Nick. No autograph...no dialogue...just a QUICK picture. I guess he was friendly enough. LOL
Darren McCarty - SUPER NICE GUY! Kinda holds a special place in my heart becuase I have a 9 month old son who recently got to meet Darren as well. Darrens band, Grinder, were doing a signing in Toledo and I took my son. I didnt really want to bother Darren with him much, but Darren actually ASKED if he could hold my son. I really thought that was great. He took a few pictures with us, and made out the autograph to my son. He really, really made me feel like he was honored to meet US. And that is truly what makes a lasting impression to me. He was just great...thats all I can say.
Those were all the GOOD guys. Here are the bad guys.
Mike Vernon - True story here. I actually met him the exact day he was traded from the Wings to San Jose. So, I will cut him some slack. But he was just a total dick. Didnt talk, didnt make eye contact...nothing. I understand it was a bad day for him, but he could have put forth a better effort.
Alexei Zhamonov - Was having lunch with my sister in Chicago, and Zhamnonv walks in. I am not a huge fan of his, so I dont make big deal of it. As I am walking out of the restaurant I walk by and tell him that I am glad to meet him. I didnt ask for an autograph, I didnt ask him to pose for any pictures. I simply extended my hand and said that it was a pleasure to meet him. I got nothing. He didnt even look up at me. Pretty much a dick thing to do.
Ray Sheppard - BIGGEST ASS I HAVE EVER MET. Enough said.