I can't do the X's and O's but I can give you a more detailed description of Phil's methodology than most of the public fluff.
If you want to picture Housley's system functioning properly, envision the following:
- Guhle recovers the puck in the left slot, even with one opposing forward, with Risto engaged at his post
- He immediately skates past his man, trapping two opposing forwards behind the play
This is the foundation of Phil's scheme. By empowering his defensemen to take on forecheckers 1v1, skate the puck into the zone, and activate as forwards if they're the first in the offensive zone, he creates a ton of difficult decisions for opposing defenses. For example, Ryan Johansen was super good at zone entries last season, because his check kept having to step off him at the blueline to account for the unmarked defensemen barreling towards them.
This system has failed to materialize in Buffalo because the Sabres don't have the end to end skating to support it. It doesn't just need good defensemen, it needs a really high level of precision on the breakout, and
any lack of mobility better be compensated by crisp passing. Hell, Shea Weber couldn't even keep up.
Now, this analysis is limited to transition. Over the summer, people were trying to link Housley's system to a fluid, 5 man offensive rotation where defensemen are free to activate below the goal line and into the slot. However, this contradicted one of the gripes about Phil coming over from Nashville, that his power play was very static and featured a lot of low quality shots from the point.
Per the attached, our shot map is indicative of the vanilla offensive zone scheming that Nashville fans bemoaned. Virtually all of the attempts are coming from F/D interplay along the wall, with nothing to suggest defensemen are even creeping into the slot. This also hints at some lazy positioning as well, with supporting forwards too far away for rebounds or puck retrieval.
I'll be generous and give Phil an incomplete here given how shot-to-hell the transition game was. It's hard to get quality possessions when you can't exit the zone.
The hope moving forward now that we know Phil is here and probably ain't changing is some combination of:
- 18% Dahlin
- A big growth year from Guhle
- Nelson being a quality system guy and not CN Gragnani
- O'Reilly for *insert top pairing D*
- Botterill getting more Justin Schultz than Nathan Beaulieu with his marginal moves
...sigh