Would love to vote Naslund, who at his peak was a much better player, but, thinking about it, I'd bet Bondra's more likely to make it into the Hall of Fame someday (I'm not saying he'll make it, but it wouldn’t be totally outlandish if he did—he was arguably better than Ciccarelli, at least in the regular season).
Between the two lockouts, Bondra scored more goals than anyone not named Jagr (he had more than Selanne, Sakic, Shanahan, and Sundin during that span, and in fewer games to boot). And I'd love to know how many non-HOFers have 6 top-ten finishes in goals… doubt there are too many. His assist totals were low, but realistically, who was there to pass to on those Caps teams back in the late '90s? There was Bondra, then Oates or Pivonka at center and… the legendary Steve Konowalchuk?
Naslund had a few years where he was a middling first-liner on a miserable team, then four truly elite years (2000-'04) then four sad post-lockout years as a liability who got way too much ice time and wouldn't play defense or venture anywhere near high-traffic areas. I've always been a Naslund fan, but I'm not sure that's enough to outweigh nearly a decade of elite play from Bondra.