Proposal: Pens-oilers-canes

[jay caufield forhead]

pens give up letang, sheary
pens get faulk, Skinner

oilers give up 10 oa, JP
oilers get Letang, sheary

canes give up Faulk, skinner
canes get 10 oa JP

Click to read more...

 

[Empoleon8771]

Holy hell the Penguins end up like bandits in this trade. Wow. The Canes get slaughtered in this.

 

[Cardiac Jerks]

Easy no from Carolina.

 

[Hulkacaniac]

Oilers get hurt the worst. Return is crap and they add a bunch of salary.

 

[OnanTheBarbarian]

So how does Edmonton afford those salaries exactly? Letang is a good player, but too risky to bet what could be a blue chip prospect, and Puljujarvi on. Sheary I would take, but for a much more modest return.

 

[TFHockey]

Try again. Make sure the other teams benefit from the trade, not just one who makes out like a bandit.
Easy no from Edmonton.

 

[DingDongCharlie]

Sheary is maybe worth a mid-late second, I personally wouldn't even give 40th ov for him. It really is a top 10 pick and Puljujarvi for a oft-injuried defenceman, meaning this is horrible for Edmonton

 

[EDMOILERS9729]

The pens take this and f***ing run. Edmonton spits in your face tells you to f*** off.

 

[Yarbles02]

Really not interested in letang with that salary. Huge pass.

 

[Dr Quincy]

pens give up letang, sheary
pens get faulk, Skinner

oilers give up 10 oa, JP
oilers get Letang, sheary

canes give up Faulk, skinner
canes get 10 oa JP

Don't see a reason for PITT to be in the deal. If I'm EDM and I'd rather have Faulk + Skinner than Letang + Sheary.

Not saying EDM would do that deal, but I think that has greater value than what they get in yours. Thus I can only conclude that PITT is in the deal because you are a Pens fan and you want Faulk and Skinner.