I guarantee you not a single one of our 'best in the NHL defensive prospect pool' becomes the player Letang is. I would be shocked to be wrong on this. I also doubt that more than one of the top five picks in the draft equal him, and you can not predict right now which one.
Just wanted to voice my support for you, Jaded, since I have been preaching this message for a long time. I am very high on the DEPTH of our prospect pool, but while a lot of people have been metaphorically polishing the knobs of guys like Joe Morrow & others, and stated (incorrectly, IMO) that we have "the best group of defensive prospects in the NHL", I have maintained the following:
While we DO have tremendous depth and guys with great upside, I do not see a single one of them who (at least currently, if not ever) projects as a true & legit #1 Dman, besides Letang. Yes, I am
extremely excited about guys like Harrington, Maatta, Pouliot, Dumoulin and others, but I see these guys more as 2s or 3s or 4s, as opposed to a true #1. (And Maatta as the only one who has a somewhat distant chance of being the one with the potential to become that player).
All of these guys can be fantastic complementary pieces, but the D corps has to be built around one true #1 Dman, and Letang is the only guy who fits that bill. Fine, so he may not be Shea Weber, Zdeno Chara or Nick Lidstrom, but he's damn good and he's the closest thing we've got to any of those guys. And there are LOTS of teams in the league who would kill to have this guy (and if the time ever comes when we actually have a better replacement, now we've got this guy locked up and can actually trade him to such teams). So let's stop being greedy for a minute and appreciate the fact that we've got one of the top 4 or 5 or 6 best Dmen in the NHL. (And also remember that while the grass may appear greener on the other side, it isn't always the truth)