I doubt anyone thinks your assessment is remotely close. Smith will never score 25 goals again. That's complete delusion. He'll be lucky to crack 15 again. He's too slow, lazy and stupid. A player that has more unsportsmanlike conduct penalties than goals on the season is worthless. Smith is useless.
EDIT: Holy ****, I didn't know he was -29 on the season until I just looked up his stats. LOL. Its actually comical how terrible he is.
Wait, what was my assessment? I said he
USUALLY score 15-25 goals and it might be factually true as he did it twice (16 & 25 goals the last 2 seasons) and came close twice (14 goals in 2011-12 and 13 goals in 2013-14)
The seasons where he didn't was :
- 2010-11 : rookie year, played 55 games
- 2012-13 : lockout year, played 48 games (team was also ultra-defensive due to offensive players (Karlsson, Spezza, Michalek) injuries)
- 2014-15 : injury-plagued year, played 37 games (not the first and last player to struggle when injuries hit)
- 2017-18 : the team sucked year, played 61 games (so far)
If healthy and on a decent/good team, I could totally see him close in on 15 goals again. If he was 5 years older maybe I'd doubt it but he is still 29 y/o (30 soon). I've seen countless and countless times NHL players rebound from bad seasons. IMO, he needs a change of scenery and will hopefully be traded this summer and the financially poor Sens will be replacing him by a cheaper and younger player, making "salary space" for the future.
Zack Smith has great size and strength, is very good on face-offs (5 seasons over 51.8%, out of 8 seasons. 7 if you don't count his injury-plagued year where he only played 37 games), is usually an excellent penalty killer (most SHG on the Sens since 201-11 with 12 SHG), the team had pretty good PK years with Smith as a fixture. He is usually good defensively as evidenced by his advanced stats (check the link). He is also physical and can throw some good hits. I'm pretty sure many NHL players would tell you that he is hard to play against.
Zack Smith - Full Stats, Line Combos and Game Logs
He has gotten very few PP time over the years, 0:50 PP TOI/GP since 2010-11 (519 games) so most of his production comes at ES or PK. Only 214 forwards have more ESP since 2010-11 and Zack smith is just a bottom-6 forward
But it comes with no surprise, you were saying how terrible he was since day 1 and particularly in 2014-15 and what happened then? He followed that by scoring 25 goals the following year and 16 the year after.
Note : So Smith has been the only Sens player terrible defensively this year? Hockey is a team sport, the whole team has been broken defensively this season. Karlsson is -25, Hoffman and Duchene are -21, Ceci is -24, Harpur is -20, Dzingel is -16 and even Pageau is -11
Oduya is +2 and Dumont is +1. I guess with Stone they were the only ones good defensively?
Reality is almost everybody has been "terrible" when they came back from Sweden in November.