Proposal: Oilers Trades ....

[oil10]

Okay so my last post was very lopsided for the Oilers .... so here are other trade ideas. Hope these ones are a bit fair. (but no guarantees)

#1
EDM: Hamilton, Ferland, McElhinney, 2019 1st round pick (CAR)

CAR: Draisaitl, Manning, Talbot

#2
EDM: Lewis

LA: Lucic, 2019 1st round pick (EDM), B prospect (Currie/Gambardella)

#3
EDM: Brown, Kapanen

TO: Larsson, Yamamoto

#4
EDM: Dzingel, Smith

OTT: Spooner, Rieder, 2019 3rd round pick, 2020 4th round pick

#5
EDM: Parayko, 2019 2nd round pick

STL: Puljujärvi, Benning, 2019 1st round pick (CAR)

Click to read more...

 

[The Nuge]

Hard no from our side to 1 and 3. Hard no from Ottawa and St Louis to 4 and 5.

The LA trade is probably fine value wise

 

[Tkachukecheese]

The Ottawa one made me laugh.... Really hard.

 

[Makar Goes Fast]

you would attach your first round pick this year for Lucic?

would die if that turned into 1st overall. HF would explode. would enjoy very much.

 

[MinJaBen]

Carolina would take the 1st pick of yours. I doubt your management would do that, though.

 

[TFHockey]

No chance Drai goes for that.

St. Louis wouldn't make that last trade either.

Oilers are on record stating they won't trade their 1st.. certainly not to dump Lucic.

 

[ChaoticOrange]

I wouldn’t give up our first to dump Lucic. Retain half and someone would take him.

Zero interest in moving Draisaitl.

Ottawa/Blues deals are poor for them.

 

[ElPrimeTime]

Hard no from our side to 1 and 3. Hard no from Ottawa and St Louis to 4 and 5.

The LA trade is probably fine value wise

This right here, is spot on.

 

[ConnorMcMullet]

Oilers say no to the 1st 3.

Ottawa/St.Louis trades awful for them.

 

[Chan790]

Carolina has no use for Manning and Drai is the sort of luxury purchase we'd love...but hate the price tag of.

Not sure the Canes will move their 1st under any condition since they're not solidly in the playoff qualifying. DW really values lottery picks and has said so.

Hope we are bringing back McElhinney in 2019-20. He's literally the only Canes goalie I definitely want to see return next year. Mrazek isn't good enough to be an NHL starter (and not as good as McEl) and it is coming to decision time on Nedeljkovic...it's why I would like to see him getting games to see what we have. Mrazek is the one to move right now.

Think this is a pass for us and for Edmonton.

 

[The Moose is Loose]

Agree with what everyone has said.

Very easily would say no to the first 3, other teams wouldn't say yes to the last 2.

 

[Crown Royal]

Pass from LA unless Edmonton retains at least 50%. Way too much term left on Lucic at $6 mil/yr.

 

[oilers84]

To anh
Lucic
Benson
Spooner
2nd 2019

To edm
Rakell
Kesler

To nj
Seks

To edm
Wood

To car
Rieder
Rattie

To edm
Ferland

To buf
Rnh

To edm
Thompson
Luukkonen

To cal
Russell

To edm
Lazar
Gawdin

To clb
Klefbom
Talbot
Gambardella

To edm
Werenski
Vehvilainen

To nyi
1st 2020
Kassian

To edm
Bellows
Martin

To stl
Larsson

To edm
Parayko

To phi
Manning
4th

To edm
Myers

To wpg
2nd 2020
Benning

To edm
Myers

Next year lines

Rakell McDavid Ferland
Wood dria Thompson
Khaira Kesler Puljujarvi
Martin Brodziak Chiasson
Cave

Werenski Parayko
Nurse Myers
Gravel Myers
Petrovic

Koskinen
Starrett

 

[fudgeeo]

Hard no from our side to 1 and 3. Hard no from Ottawa and St Louis to 4 and 5.

The LA trade is probably fine value wise

pretty much sums it up

 

[YP44]

Even with first I say no from an LA POV.

Lewis should be worth a 2nd alone.

 

[HolyGhost]

offers are funny

 

[Boom Boom Apathy]

Okay so my last post was very lopsided for the Oilers .... so here are other trade ideas. Hope these ones are a bit fair. (but no guarantees)

#1
EDM: Hamilton, Ferland, McElhinney, 2019 1st round pick (CAR)

CAR: Draisaitl, Manning, Talbot

Ferland is a UFA at seasons end.
McElhinney will be a 36 year old UFA at season's end.
Hamilton, the most valuable piece, is only signed for 2 more seasons.
1st round pick could be mid round.

Even with Manning as a dump and Talbot as a reclamation project, this seems bad value for Edmonton.

 

[Boom Boom Apathy]

To car
Rieder
Rattie

To edm
Ferland

Canes already had Rattie once and have no interest in getting him again. Rieder isn't good so don't want him either. Would rather just keep Ferland and let him walk for nothing than take that offer.

Why would Edm even want a rental like Ferland? You are penciling him into next year's line-up, yet he's a UFA at the end of this year.

 

[Sniper99]

Okay so my last post was very lopsided for the Oilers .... so here are other trade ideas. Hope these ones are a bit fair. (but no guarantees)

#2
EDM: Lewis

LA: Lucic, 2019 1st round pick (EDM), B prospect (Currie/Gambardella)

(CAR)

You've got some explaining to do with this one. I see you found Chiarelli's trade ideas in the garbage can.

You dont move what will be a high 1st along with Lucic to get Lewis in return. My God.

 

[Ctrain2k]

Canes already had Rattie once and have no interest in getting him again. Rieder isn't good so don't want him either. Would rather just keep Ferland and let him walk for nothing than take that offer.

Why would Edm even want a rental like Ferland? You are penciling him into next year's line-up, yet he's a UFA at the end of this year.

Wouldn’t be a rental would try and resign.

 

[Boom Boom Apathy]

Wouldn’t be a rental would try and resign.

I get that, but what's the chances of that happening? Probably pretty slim.

Anyhow, Rieder and Rattie doesn't even get the Canes talking so the point is moot.

 

[Ctrain2k]

I get that, but what's the chances of that happening? Probably pretty slim.

Anyhow, Rieder and Rattie doesn't even get the Canes talking so the point is moot.

Yeah if we did trade for him it there would probably have to be an extension in place.

 

[Boom Boom Apathy]

Yeah if we did trade for him it there would probably have to be an extension in place.

Which won't happen IMO. It's pretty evident he wants to go to UFA and I don't blame him 1 bit. This is his best, and maybe only, chance to hit it big.

 

[ManofSteel55]

The only trades Edmonton is going to be able to complete at the deadline are guys like Talbot, Kassian, Petrovic, and maybe Reider, and Benning (and if we're really lucky, Manning) for mid to late round picks. We don't have much in terms of desireable pieces to play with here, except for the guys we aren't planning to move at all.

 

[AmadiosAmigos]

To anh
Lucic
Benson
Spooner
2nd 2019

To edm
Rakell
Kesler

To nj
Seks

To edm
Wood

To car
Rieder
Rattie

To edm
Ferland

To buf
Rnh

To edm
Thompson
Luukkonen

To cal
Russell

To edm
Lazar
Gawdin

To clb
Klefbom
Talbot
Gambardella

To edm
Werenski
Vehvilainen

To nyi
1st 2020
Kassian

To edm
Bellows
Martin

To stl
Larsson

To edm
Parayko

To phi
Manning
4th

To edm
Myers

To wpg
2nd 2020
Benning

To edm
Myers

Next year lines

Rakell McDavid Ferland
Wood dria Thompson
Khaira Kesler Puljujarvi
Martin Brodziak Chiasson
Cave

Werenski Parayko
Nurse Myers
Gravel Myers
Petrovic

Koskinen
Starrett

Always nice to be a dreamer, I just dont see many if any of these trades happening ever