Proposal: Oil/Pens/Flames

[Sparky93]

How long do the Oilers have to try and clone Klefbom?

I wouldn’t bother, once the Hall clone is ready, they can trade it for another Klefbom!

 

[ChaoticOrange]

Easy there Sparky, this ain’t Tinder. Hard no. Both deals are atrocious.

 

[Sparky93]

Easy there Sparky, this ain’t Tinder. Hard no. Both deals are atrocious.

Lol!!

 

[ChaoticOrange]

Original proposal was Klefbom + Puljujarvi or Klefbom, Yamamoto + 10th OA

They’re both terrible though the Klefbom and Puljujarvi one is less terrible.

Not even close to realistic. Flames do pretty well though which is unsurprising.

 

[Homesick]

Oiler In: Letang($7.25 millio)
Oilers Out: Klefbom, Puljujarvi or Klefbom, Yamamoto + 10th OA($5.095 million)

Pens In: Hamilton, Puljujarvi or (Yamamoto + 10th OA) + Frolik($10.975 million)
Pens Out: Letang + Kessel($14.05 million)

Flames In: Kessel + Klefbom($10.97 million)
Flames Out: Hamilton + Frolik($10.05 million)

Oilers pass without hesitation

 

[Empoleon8771]

The penguins definitely don't get bent here. They do okay on this trade

Yes they do, they downgrade dramatically and on defense to just get Puljujarvi or Yamamoto and the 10th pick. Kessel to Frolik is a monumental downgrade. At best, Hamilton isn't any better than a struggling Letang.

 

[THall4]

Oiler In: Letang($7.25 millio)
Oilers Out: Klefbom, Puljujarvi or Klefbom, Yamamoto + 10th OA($5.095 million)

Pens In: Hamilton, Puljujarvi or (Yamamoto + 10th OA) + Frolik($10.975 million)
Pens Out: Letang + Kessel($14.05 million)

Flames In: Kessel + Klefbom($10.97 million)
Flames Out: Hamilton + Frolik($10.05 million)

Oilers definitely reject that.

 

[Toby Flenderson]

This kind of trade is unnecessary. And both the Pens and Oil give up too much.

Pens need a better goal scorer coming back than Frolik if we trade Kessel. I think a trade with the Canes for something around Skinner + makes sense for both clubs.

 

[CraigsList]

Wow OP, Edmonton gets bent over hard.

 

[McSuper]

Oiler In: Letang($7.25 millio)
Oilers Out: Klefbom, Puljujarvi or Klefbom, Yamamoto + 10th OA($5.095 million)

Pens In: Hamilton, Puljujarvi or (Yamamoto + 10th OA) + Frolik($10.975 million)
Pens Out: Letang + Kessel($14.05 million)

Flames In: Kessel + Klefbom($10.97 million)
Flames Out: Hamilton + Frolik($10.05 million)

So Edmonton who has no cap space to spare gives up a bargain contract in Klefbom and 2 ELC contracts . Not to mention no team is giving up those assets for an often injured Letang .
Counter offer
Lucic , Klefbom and 10th OA for Kessel + Letang .
Break down
Lucic for Letang
10oa + Klefbom for Kessel

 

[McSuper]

So Edmonton who has no cap space to spare gives up a bargain contract in Klefbom and 2 ELC contracts . Not to mention no team is giving up those assets for an often injured Letang .
Counter offer
Lucic , Klefbom and 10th OA for Kessel + Letang .
Break down
Lucic for Letang
10oa + Klefbom for Kessel

This is to show how far the value is off to the OP not to make a trade proposal for Pens fans . So hoping it doesn't offend Pens fans

 

[wej20]

So Edmonton who has no cap space to spare gives up a bargain contract in Klefbom and 2 ELC contracts . Not to mention no team is giving up those assets for an often injured Letang .
Counter offer
Lucic , Klefbom and 10th OA for Kessel + Letang .
Break down
Lucic for Letang
10oa + Klefbom for Kessel

Letang's worth way more than Lucic. Plodding 30 point wingers paid 6 million aren't worth much.

 

[zar]

Oiler In: Letang($7.25 millio)
Oilers Out: Klefbom, Puljujarvi or Klefbom, Yamamoto + 10th OA($5.095 million)

Pens In: Hamilton, Puljujarvi or (Yamamoto + 10th OA) + Frolik($10.975 million)
Pens Out: Letang + Kessel($14.05 million)

Flames In: Kessel + Klefbom($10.97 million)
Flames Out: Hamilton + Frolik($10.05 million)

Wow... just wow!

No... NO ****ING WAY!

 

[Volica]

Letang's worth way more than Lucic. Plodding 30 point wingers paid 6 million aren't worth much.

Some might say, they have negative value.

 

[The Red Mile]

LOL I wish. Sparky at least try and make a proposal that is remotely fair for all sides. This is really bad for Edmonton.

 

[CraigsList]

They’re both terrible though the Klefbom and Puljujarvi one is less terrible.

Not even close to realistic. Flames do pretty well though which is unsurprising.

It's pretty surprising. We're usually the ones that get boned in 3 way trades.

 

[ManofSteel55]

This is horrid. Letang, at his cap hit, performance this year, and usual 40 games missed due to injury, is not worth what is being suggested here. Calgary wins big time here overall though.

 

[Empoleon8771]

Some might say, they have negative value.

Letang certainly doesn't have negative value, that's absurd.

This is horrid. Letang, at his cap hit, performance this year, and usual 40 games missed due to injury, is not worth what is being suggested here. Calgary wins big time here overall though.

Letang has missed 40 games due to injury twice in his career. Once due to a stroke and once due to a herniated disk in his neck.

 

[Potty John]

I don’t see any team doing this trade in all honesty.

 

[CraigsList]

I don’t see any team doing this trade in all honesty.

How do we not?

Hamilton > Klefbom
Frolik <<< Kessel

 

[Sparky93]

LOL I wish. Sparky at least try and make a proposal that is remotely fair for all sides. This is really bad for Edmonton.

I really don’t think it is. Over the last 3 years Letang has played 13 more games than Klefbom and accumulated 81 more points. He’s a bonified #1, who’s a big part of the leadership core that just won back to back cups and he rarely finishes outside the top 10 in defensive scoring. He’d be an excellent mentor and partner for not only Nurse but an entire young team. Puljujarvi hasn’t what the Oilers expected and Yamamoto is still a huge wildcard. To expect to get a defenseman the caliber of Letang, with out including a top prospect is absolutely absurd.

 

[Potty John]

How do we not?

Hamilton > Klefbom
Frolik <<< Kessel

I see the appeal to accepting the deal, but I really don’t want to move Hamilton unless I know Brodie can get back to his old self with Gio.

 

[Ragdoll]

I really don’t think it is. Over the last 3 years Letang has played 13 more games than Klefbom and accumulated 81 more points. He’s a bonified #1, who’s a big part of the leadership core that just won back to back cups and he rarely finishes outside the top 10 in defensive scoring. He’d be an excellent mentor and partner for not only Nurse but an entire young team. Puljujarvi hasn’t what the Oilers expected and Yamamoto is still a huge wildcard. To expect to get a defenseman the caliber of Letang, with out including a top prospect is absolutely absurd.

If the Oilers are sending out Klefbom + 10th oa + yamamoto and all they got was Letang? That’s a fail at the end of the day. We add salary and get an older and still injury prone defenceman. No doubt Letang scores more points but that’s a steep price. Pretty sure the Oilers could get better with that package.

 

[Bryanbryoil]

Oilers are getting bent hard.

Like, no dinner, no lube, and no cab ride home hard.

Not even a single tissue to attempt to clean up with either.

 

[t0nedeff]

lmao I wonder if the OP is a Flames fan they somehow downgrade a little on D while turning Frolik into a 90 pt forward.