No Stanley Cup for Canada

Status
Not open for further replies.

Bigshooter

Registered User
Jun 9, 2017
6
0
Gary Bettman who is the commissioner of the National Hockey League (NHL) was brought in 30 years ago with one agenda, and that was to grow the game of hockey in the USA. In Canada the game of hockey is like a religion, with winters lasting 6 months all there is, is hockey. Fans are passionate and it's the number one sport. Football and baseball come second and third. Unfortunately for fans in Canada, no Canadian NHL team has won the Stanley Cup for 25 years since the Montreal Canadians have won.

This thesis will explain why no Canadian team will win the Stanley Cup until at least 2050.

Gary Batman's job is to grow the game in the USA, there are currently 23 NHL teams in the USA and 7 in Canada with a new team joining for the upcoming season in the Las Vegas Golden Knights, to make that 24 American teams.

With expansion more and more teams have started in American cities, Ice hockey teams in Florida, Panthers and Lightning, in the desert with Phoenix,, other warm places such as Dallas, LA, Anaheim, San Jose, these are warm climate cities who now have ice rinks. The people there don't really care about hockey, they are more interested in football, basketball and baseball, yet they have ice hockey teams. Why, because Gary Bettman wants them there, because that's his #1 mission, grow the game in the USA. The NHL is a billion dollar industry and with the USA population being 100 times larger then the Canadian population the potential for money revenue is greater in the USA even though the interest is not there.

Now with the weaning attendance in places like Florida and Phoenix, how do you attract more fans? By having winning teams, nobody is going to go see a loser team if they don't really want to see a game in the first place. So you have to create attraction, excitement, what better way then by winning, making the playoffs and winning the ultimate trophy, the Stanley Cup. Now in Canada people will watch hockey no matter what. In Toronto people will pay $500 per seat for a team that has not won a Stanley Cup in 50 years, yet every night the arena is sold out. You don't need to win, people will still come, they have for 50 years.

In 1993 we had the chance to see the Montreal Canadians and the Toronto Maple Leafs play in the final for the Stanley Cup, now this would have been a huge loss of revenue in the USA as why would the Americans care about two Canadian teams, Wayne Gretzky was still fresh in LA, the game was being grown in the LA market, with celebrities, Hollywood, billions of dollars on the line.

So what happened, in the last 5 minutes of the game between LA and Toronto, Wayne Gretzky high sticked a Toronto player Doug Gilmour in the face, there was a cut, there was blood, in the rules that's a 5 minute automatic penalty, but guess what it was never called, the game ended up going into overtime and Gretzky scored the overtime winner and LA magically went on into the finals to play for the Cup. This would also be the last year a Canadian team won the Stanley Cup.

Now you might say how can the NHL control the outcome of games, simple answer, the referees work for the NHL, they control the penalties, goals called back, they are the judges of the games. They can influence a game in any direction they choose. Take the 1999 Stanley Cup finals between Dallas and Buffalo, all season that year the rule was if any part of an offensive player is in the blue ice of the goalie crease when the puck goes into the net, the goal will be disallowed for obstruction of the goalie. 26 goals were called back in 1999 playoffs because someone's skate was in the crease, even if it was just a skate lace in the crease, no goal. Yet the famous Stanley Cup winning goal scored by Brett Hull from Dallas that year clearly shows his whole leg in the crease while he is shoveling the puck into the net to win the cup. The goal should have been disallowed as per the rules, yet it stood and Dallas won the cup. The Stars coincidentally just moved to Dallas from Minnesota 5 years earlier and nobody was watching their games in hot Dallas, so what better way to attract new fans then by winning the Stanley Cup. And who decided that, the NHL, through their referees who let the goal stand that should have been disallowed.

Canada has had 4 of their 7 teams in the Stanley Cup finals in the last 20 years yet none of them have won the cup

2004 Calgary vs Tampa, yep Tampa won
2006 Edmonton vs Carolina, yep Carolina won
2007 Ottawa vs Anaheim, yep Anaheim won
2011 Vancouver vs Boston , yep Boston won

In 2015-2016 season, no Canadian team even made the playoffs.

The game still has a lot of growing in the USA, and Gary will make sure those teams are winning the Stanley Cups south of the border with Canada. And he has his referees to make sure it happens.

Incidentally I predict that Las Vegas will be in the Stanley Cup finals in the next 4 years, I know it's the desert, who cares about ice and hockey, is there even an arena in Las Vegas? But imagine the excitement of a Stanley Cup final right there in Vegas, all the celebrities can fly down from Hollywood, you have the casinos and the main event, just like when they hold the boxing matches there.

I can just see the dollar signs spinning in Gary Bettman's eyes. Way to go Gary 25 years with no Cup in Canada and 25 more to go. Sorry Canadian citizens and fans, after all the NHL is a billion dollar business, it's all about the money, but keep cheering maybe this year Ottawa might have a shot (not) they will be out.
 

Shockmaster

Registered User
Sep 11, 2012
16,010
3,380
Has the OP considered that quite possibly Canadian teams have had inept management for the better part of 25 years?
 

RiceCooker

"We Got Some Looks"
Mar 6, 2007
8,188
38
Home !!
statler-and-waldorf-balcony-its-a-conspiracy-i-tell-you-the-fix-is-in.jpg
 

KingsFan7824

Registered User
Dec 4, 2003
19,375
7,463
Visit site
Canada has had 4 of their 7 teams in the Stanley Cup finals in the last 20 years yet none of them have won the cup

2004 Calgary vs Tampa, yep Tampa won
2006 Edmonton vs Carolina, yep Carolina won
2007 Ottawa vs Anaheim, yep Anaheim won
2011 Vancouver vs Boston , yep Boston won

Why even bother letting so many Canadian teams get so close? Probably plausible deniability right? Did Bettman also break up the Oilers dynasty because of money?
 

x Tame Impala

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Aug 24, 2011
27,512
11,906
It's a shame that there's a significant enough minority of Canadians who really believe this stuff. This whole "It's our game, we're the real fans" mantra is really disappointing, especially when it coincides with putting down fanbases from non-traditional hockey markets
 

BB88

Registered User
Jan 19, 2015
40,864
20,471
Toronto, Edmonton, Winnipeg.

We will soon have 3 elite Canadien teams.
 

Dustin

Registered User
Sep 24, 2014
5,001
1,346
"LA magically went on into the finals to play for the Cup"

You mean after hosting Toronto in a game seven and winning. I'm a Leaf fan and I hate that play as much as anyone but let's not forget that the Leafs had another game too close it out and they could not, despite Clark's heroics.

It was a bad call and made worse by the fact that Gretzky basically owned us that series but in no way did that determine the outcome of the series. The Leafs had plenty of opportunity during that game and in the next game to win. They just didn't have enough luck to get it done.
 

Bigshooter

Registered User
Jun 9, 2017
6
0
"LA magically went on into the finals to play for the Cup"

You mean after hosting Toronto in a game seven and winning. I'm a Leaf fan and I hate that play as much as anyone but let's not forget that the Leafs had another game too close it out and they could not, despite Clark's heroics.

It was a bad call and made worse by the fact that Gretzky basically owned us that series but in no way did that determine the outcome of the series. The Leafs had plenty of opportunity during that game and in the next game to win. They just didn't have enough luck to get it done.

They used to say that about the Cubs and Bartman too, there was also a game seven in that series that the Cubs blew, but all the blame for 20 years was on Bartman.

In Toronto, Leafs Nation will always blame Karry Frasor for the non call in game 6
 

Ziggy Stardust

Master Debater
Jul 25, 2002
63,178
34,297
Parts Unknown
They used to say that about the Cubs and Bartman too, there was also a game seven in that series that the Cubs blew, but all the blame for 20 years was on Bartman.

In Toronto, Leafs Nation will always blame Karry Frasor for the non call in game 6

I guess you don't believe in accountability? Gretzky made the Leafs look like amateurs. Suck it up you crybabies.
 

Bigshooter

Registered User
Jun 9, 2017
6
0
Why even bother letting so many Canadian teams get so close? Probably plausible deniability right? Did Bettman also break up the Oilers dynasty because of money?


Don't kid yourself, the NHL is a billion dollar corporation, it's a business, if they aren't making money there is no NHL.
 

Hockeyholic

Registered User
Apr 20, 2017
16,370
9,912
Condo My Dad Bought Me
Edmonton: Kevin Lowe, Craig MacTavish, Dallas Eakins, Daryl Katz, Scott Howson, Kelly Buchburger.

Montreal: Rejeaun Houle, Pierre Gauthier, Marc Bergevin, Michel Therrien, Jacque Martin.

Toronto: MLSE, Brian Burke, Richard Peddle, Ron Wilson, Pete Horichek, Randy Carlyle, Dave Nonis.

Calgary: Ken King, Darryl Sutter, Brent Sutter, Mike Keenan, Brian Burke.

Ottawa: Craig Hartsburg, Cory Clouston, Dave Cameron, Eugene Melnyk.

Vancouver: Mike Keenan, John Tortorella, Jim Benning, Trevor Linden, Willie Desjardins.

Winnipeg: Stuck with Pavelic far too long. Have Paul Maurice as head coach.
 
Last edited:

Rubber Biscuit

Registered User
Sep 9, 2010
13,752
8,277
Long Island
That's an awful lot of words to make such a simple, stupid point.

Of course, there's no way the Canadian teams just haven't been good. No, must be some grand conspiracy.
 

DS7

Registered User
Oct 9, 2013
1,928
2,329
Vancouver, BC
McDavid, Laine, Matthews are going to dominate the NHL for Canada. give it a few years, and god willing, Dahlin/Svechnikov/Veleno as well (please hockey gods :()
 

tarheelhockey

Offside Review Specialist
Feb 12, 2010
85,220
138,653
Bojangles Parking Lot
Gary Bettman who is the commissioner of the National Hockey League (NHL) was brought in 30 years ago with one agenda, and that was to grow the game of hockey in the USA.

I reject the premise. Bettman's primary job duty is to make money for the owners. If the way to do that is to grow the game in the USA, so be it. If the way to do that is to grow the game in Canada, so be it.

Bettman couldn't care less whether an American team wins the Cup, as long as the event makes money.
 

Bigshooter

Registered User
Jun 9, 2017
6
0
I reject the premise. Bettman's primary job duty is to make money for the owners. If the way to do that is to grow the game in the USA, so be it. If the way to do that is to grow the game in Canada, so be it.

Bettman couldn't care less whether an American team wins the Cup, as long as the event makes money.

Economics 101, if 10% of 330 million watch in the USA = billions more then
10% of 35 million watch in Canada = way less revenue
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad