NHL15 Ratings for the Flames

[tfong]

I really dislike how nhl ratings are so close together that the overall is almost meaningless.

 

[CraigsList]

Raymond (99) - Backlund (99) - Hudler (99)
Glencross (99) - Monahan (99) - Colborne (99)
Bouma (99) - Stajan (99) - Jones (99)
Bollig (99) - Knight (99) - McGrattan (99)
Byron (99)

Giordano (99) - Brodie (99)
Smid (99) - Wideman (99)
Russell (99) - Engelland (99)
Wotherspoon (99)

Hiller (99)
Ramo (99)

Man, that lineup should get us McDavid.

 

[BrodieGoat]

I'll be so pissed if Poirier is a ****ing 2.5 red stars

 

[BrodieGoat]

Anyone want to do prospect ratings?

 

[CraigsList]

Anyone want to do prospect ratings?

Ratings at the beginning of the game? Hmm... The first ones I will name off of my head:

Granlund - 73
Reinhart - 76
Poirier - 69
Klimchuk - 67
Ortio - 74
Knight - 71
Wotherspoon - 73

 

[BrodieGoat]

Ratings at the beginning of the game? Hmm... The first ones I will name off of my head:

Granlund - 73
Reinhart - 76
Poirier - 69
Klimchuk - 67
Ortio - 74
Knight - 71
Wotherspoon - 73

what about potential?

 

[Yung Rotini]

Anyone want to do prospect ratings?

Granlund- 72 (3.5Y/4R)
Reinhart- 78 (3.5Y)
Baertschi- 78 (4.5R/4.5Y)
Poirier- 67 (4Y)
Klimchuk- 65 (4Y)
Ortio- 75 (3.5Y)
Knight- 74 (3.5Y/4R)
Wotherspoon- 72 (4Y)
Gaudreau- 76 (4.5Y)
Jankowski- 57 (4R/4.5R)
Gillies- 62 (4Y)
Sieloff- 67 (3.5Y)
Bennett- 70 (4.5Y)

R= Red
Y= Yellow
G= Green

 

[CraigsList]

what about potential?

Not very good at the potential guessing. Being quite honest, which color is the better one?

 

[InfinityIggy]

Not very good at the potential guessing. Being quite honest, which color is the better one?

Green = Good Chance of hitting potential.
Yellow = Average Chance of hitting potential.
Red = Low Chance of hitting potential.

 

[CraigsList]

Green = Good Chance of hitting potential.
Yellow = Average Chance of hitting potential.
Red = Low Chance of hitting potential.

Awesome! Thanks . I will quote my post now.

 

[CraigsList]

Ratings at the beginning of the game? Hmm... The first ones I will name off of my head:

Granlund - 73
Reinhart - 76
Poirier - 69
Klimchuk - 67
Ortio - 74
Knight - 71
Wotherspoon - 73

Potential
Granlund - 4Y
Reinhart - 4Y
Poirier - 3.5G
Klimchuk - 4Y
Ortio - 3G
Knight -3R
Wotherspoon 4Y

 

[BrodieGoat]

Potential
Granlund - 4Y
Reinhart - 4Y
Poirier - 3.5G
Klimchuk - 4Y
Ortio - 3G
Knight -3R
Wotherspoon 4Y

I would do:

Granlund 4.5R
Reinhart 3.5Y
Poirier 4Y
Klimchuk4Y
Ortio 4.5R
Knight 3G
Wotherspoon 4Y
Arnold 3.5Y
Baertschi 4.5Y
Kulak 4R
Sieloff 4Y or 3.5G

 

[Lunatik]

This is how HF should rank prospects.

Rank them 1-10 and use stoplight colours!!

 

[FlamesFan18]

How I would rank them
Glencross (84) - Backlund(83) - Hudler (84)
Raymond (82) - Monahan(82 4Y) - Colborne (80 3.5Y)
Gaudreau (81 4Y) - Stajan (83) - Jones (79)
Bollig (78) - Bouma (78 3Y) - McGrattan (69)
Baertschi (81 4Y) Byron (81 3Y) M. Reinhart (77 3.5Y) Granlund (79 3.5Y) Knight (73 3Y) Bennett (77 4Y)

Giordano (89) - Brodie (83 4Y)
Russell (82) - Wideman (83)
Smid (80) - Engelland (80)

Hiller (85)
Ramo (83)

 

[Yung Rotini]

How I would rank them
Glencross (84) - Backlund(83) - Hudler (84)
Raymond (82) - Monahan(82 4Y) - Colborne (80 3.5Y)
Gaudreau (81 4Y) - Stajan (83) - Jones (79)
Bollig (78) - Bouma (78 3Y) - McGrattan (69)
Baertschi (81 4Y) Byron (81 3Y) M. Reinhart (77 3.5Y) Granlund (79 3.5Y) Knight (73 3Y) Bennett (77 4Y)

Giordano (89) - Brodie (83 4Y)
Russell (82) - Wideman (83)
Smid (80) - Engelland (80)

Hiller (85)
Ramo (83)

No 4.5 star players? I don't see how Monahan, Bennett, Gaudreau and Baertschi are 4 yellow.

 

[Mr Lebowski]

Granlund 4 Y
Reinhart 4 Y
Poirier 4 G
Klimchuk 4 G
Ortio 4 Y
Knight 3.5G
Wotherspoon 4Y
Arnold 3.5Y
Baertschi 4.5Y
Kulak 4R
Sieloff 4Y or 3.5Y
McDonald 4 Y
Smith 3.5 R
Hickey 3Y
Gillies 4.5 Y
Jankowski 4 R
Bennett 4.5 G
Monahan 4.5 Y

 

[FlamesFan18]

No 4.5 star players? I don't see how Monahan, Bennett, Gaudreau and Baertschi are 4 yellow.

Well I guess id have to slightly agree.

Monahan - 4G
Bennett - 4.5Y
Gaudreau - 4.5R
Baertschi - 4Y

better?

 

[Pirate King Luffy]

Well I guess id have to slightly agree.

Monahan - 4G
Bennett - 4.5Y
Gaudreau - 4.5R
Baertschi - 4Y

better?

Monahan will still be a 4.5 yellow. He was that at the beginning of the year. He had a great season so they just won't bump him down to 4y.

 

[MC Ride]

Realistic, since EA Vancouver hates the Flames every year

Glencross (83 TWF) - Backlund (82 TWF) - Hudler (83 PLY)
Raymond (82 SNP) - Monahan (78 TWF) - Colborne (76 PWF)
Gaudreau (68 PLY) - Stajan (81 TWF) - Jones (76 PWF)
Baertschi (77 SNP) - Bouma (72 GRN) - McGrattan (71 ENF)
Byron (72 TWF)

Giordano (85 TWD) - Brodie (81 OFD)
Russell (78 OFD) - Wideman (82 OFD)
Smid (80 DFD) - Engelland (77 DFD)

Ramo (80 BTF)
Hiller (84 BTF)

 

[MC Ride]

Gillies 4.5 Y
Jankowski 4 R

Won't be in the game :'(

 

[CraigsList]

Just like another poster said, they better give Poirier a better potential rating. I was pissed when Klimchuk became 85 OA (as the seasons went on) and Poirier was still still 69.

 

[Bosnian Beast]

Did anyone else edit Poirier's potential in NHL 14? IIRC, he was 2 or 2.5 red stars, so I would edit him to 4 yellow stars but leave his overall. The best I have seen him was 85 overall, the worst I have seen was in my most recent Be a GM where he was 77 overall.

 

[Unkki]

Glencross 83 - Backlund 83 - Hudler 83
Gaudreau 77 - Monahan 80 - Colborne 79
Raymond 83 - Stajan 81 - Jones 80
Bollig 76 - Bouma 76 - Byron 77
McGrattan 73 Bärtschi 78

Giordano 87 - Brodie 83
Smid 81 - Wideman 82
Russell 80 - Engelland 78

Rämö 82
Hiller 83

 

[Yung Rotini]

Monahan will still be a 4.5 yellow. He was that at the beginning of the year. He had a great season so they just won't bump him down to 4y.

This. I don't see them bumping Sven down yet either tbh

 

[CraigsList]

Thanks to Anglesmith, the NHL 15 ratings are up.