Of course not. And certainly some tv revenue is better than none. Not really a point of controversy. Could anemic numbers impact the upcoming new media deal? It's already a weak, fragmented media environment, ad revenues will continue to decline, and having a weird ad hoc tournament that appeals mainly to secondary markets like Tampa or St Louis doesn't do the NHL much good.
My preference is simply for a regular resumption of play in fall 2020, not two disrupted partial seasons. Maybe that's too optimistic.
Your preference has no impact on what the NHL and NHLPA want to do. The NHL is a business and the NHL players have a job.
The players right now are looking at a HUGE loss in escrow that they will pay back to the league, and are facing a HUGE drop in salary cap going forward since their salaries are tied directly to league revenue, they are only guaranteed 50% of the revenue. They are looking at severe across the board salary loss as the league revenue plummets.
The league resuming the playoffs will help limit that damage as they will at least get some of the TV revenue incoming. Unfortunately for the league, it's been a gate driven revenue league, so they are still taking a SEVERE hit.
Add in the fact, that it's expected that there will be a 2nd wave come fall/winter, it's possible that if you don't get a functional procedure in place now when the better weather limits the severity of the illness and it's level of contagiousness, you may run into bigger problems when those things aren't in your favor and you find your procedures aren't good enough and end up having to stop after starting.
Doing this now will likely allow them to adjust better on the fly and have a more robust procedure to start next season successfully as well when the time comes.
Both the league AND the players for the most part, want to do this... who are WE to tell them they can't? Players want to work just like I want to work. Not all players are the super rich Sidney Crosby's of the league.
Also not surprising Staal is one of those against it since he's made his money and is more about family at this point than playing hockey. Most of his peers though want to play, and so they will.