I'm really not that impressed by Chia's record.
He won a cup based on great draft picks by his predecessor and signing Chara.
He's never really drafted anyone good since other than Seguin, who he traded away for practically nothing. He spent tons of money locking up replaceable players (Paille/Kelly etc) at the expense of losing valuable guys like Boychuck for nothing.
Chia has made some bad moves, some really good moves. Got Rask for Raycroft, Ference + Kobasew for UFA Brad Stuart and Wayne Primeau, Wideman for Boyes, McQuaid for a 5th, Soderberg for Toivonen, Boychuk for Hendricks, got Recchi AND a 2nd for basically nothing (Karsums + Lashoff), pulled of the Kessel deal, got Seidenberg AND Bartkowski for Bitz, Weller + 2nd,
bad trades would be Sobotka for basically nothing, Wheeler + Stuart for Peverley and Valabik, Seguin for Eriksson + Smith +, arguably the Kaberle deal, arguably the Boychuk trade...
He hasn't done much recently but if you look at that tally...
OUT:
Phil Kessel
Andrew Raycroft
Brad Stuart
Wayne Primeau
Brad Boyes
Hannu Toivonen
Matt Hendricks
Karsums
Lashoff
Bitz
Weller
2nd
5th
IN:
Tukka Rask
Dennis Seidenberg
Matt Bartkowski
Andrew Ference
Chuck Kobasew
Mark Recchi
Dennis Wideman
Carl Soderberg
Johnny Boychuk
Adam McQuaid
1st (Seguin)
1st (Hamilton)
2nd (Knight)
He essentially acquired an above average D-Corps:
Seidenberg - Hamilton
Ference - Boychuk
Bartkowski - Wideman
McQuaid
along with some forwards who played a big part in their playoff runs, AND Tukka! And the only NHLers he gave up are Kessel, Stuart, Boyes and Hendricks. Kelly for a 2nd was a good deal for them too.
Signed Chara, Savard, Wheeler, Ryder, locked up Thomas, Bergeron, Chara, Rask, Krejci, etc long-term.
Drafted Lucic, Marchand, Kessel, Hutchinson, Seguin, Spooner, Hamilton, Pastrnak.. he's been a good GM.