jfhabs
Registered User
- May 21, 2015
- 4,764
- 2,252
Value is dynamic, not because a team picks top 10 that said player retains the exact same value years later. Different draft classes, different progression etc. It's not that I don't like these guys, but I wouldn't trade a 8-10 selection in the upcoming draft because I don't believe they project as top of the line up players right now. Still 2 very good prospects.I mean...if you go into a negotiation to try to acquire a guy like Kasper/Danielson and don't view them as worthy of the Top-10 picks that the actual Detroit team in question literally spent on them...you're just never going to find a proper "value" exchange. lol. If you don't like those particular prospects so much, then just don't try to pry them out of a team's hands i guess. Because whether you like them or not, Detroit obviously values them as recent Top-10 Pick Centers and part of the future core of their team down the middle. Whether that pans out...who knows...but that's the value here.
As far as Matheson goes...i feel like he's simultaneously both underrated and overrated. I like him. He's fun to watch. He's fast and can be physical and he's got some puck moving and offensive ability when you let him run. He can log a ton of minutes.
But...he's also a little bit erratic. He's the opposite of a "stabilizing presence" that most playoff teams would be looking to add to their mix. The "value" that he adds to the Habs Powerplay is also not exactly relevant to most Playoff Teams with deeper bluelines, who almost certainly have a better PPQB somewhere in their midst already. So Matheson's Powerplay value to the Habs is greater than his Powerplay value to a deeper Playoff Team. That's something you just have to reconcile in any prospective deal. And why the Habs probably just keep him, because he's worth more to them than the "buyer" teams.
As far as Matheson, not a perfect player, but if he was better defensively we'd be talking about a prime defender here so of course he has his flaws. His defensive game is not bad tho, he's just not a rock. He's pacing for 58+ points /82 games since joining Montreal, he's arguably an upgrade offensively over some of the options currently on playoffs teams... He doesn't play with McDavid, Matthews, etc