Proposal: MTL - ARI

[alasania94]

Montreal: David Reinbacher

Arizona: Dylan Guenther

Montreal has a log jam at D… they leverage this to add a top 6 goal scoring winger

Arizona adds a top pair RD to anchor their top pair with Simashev

Click to read more...

 

[Mrfenn92]

Habs just drafted reinbacher

 

[CAUFIELD]

RD vs Winger

Simple

No thanks

 

[Baksfamous112]

Reinbacher isn’t moving. No chance

 

[habsfan44]

Montreal: David Reinbacher

Arizona: Dylan Guenther

Montreal has a log jam at D… they leverage this to add a top 6 goal scoring winger

Arizona adds a top pair RD to anchor their top pair with Simashev

The log jam is at left D and if we were trading Reinbacher it would be for a potential number one center not a top six goal scoring winger .

 

[stevo61]

Yeah... Dont get this for Montreal. They need Reinbacher to hit and balance that D

 

[montreal]

Montreal: David Reinbacher

Arizona: Dylan Guenther

Montreal has a log jam at D… they leverage this to add a top 6 goal scoring winger

Arizona adds a top pair RD to anchor their top pair with Simashev

I liked Guenther when he was teammates with Guhle so I would be interested but no way do I see the Habs doing this as it would be a bad look.

 

[Junohockeyfan]

No, Habs need Reinbacher more than a winger.

 

[Play]

Montreal: David Reinbacher

Arizona: Dylan Guenther

Montreal has a log jam at D… they leverage this to add a top 6 goal scoring winger

Arizona adds a top pair RD to anchor their top pair with Simashev

I doubt Habs trade Reinbacher

 

[pth2]

The Habs chose Reinbacher because RD is a key position, and chose him ahead of highly rated wingers, I doubt they want to reverse that decision this early.

If you really want to poach a RD out of Montreal, Barron or Mailloux would be better targets (though they obviously are worth less)

 

[montreal]

No, Habs need Reinbacher more than a winger.

depends on who that winger is.

 

[Junohockeyfan]

depends on who that winger is.

Guenther

 

[montreal]

The Habs chose Reinbacher because RD is a key position, and chose him ahead of highly rated wingers, I doubt they want to reverse that decision this early.

If you really want to poach a RD out of Montreal, Barron or Mailloux would be better targets (though they obviously are worth less)

You can't trade Mailloux, he likely won't return the value and he could be their best prospect as he's got a very impressive mix of size and skill.

 

[McJedi]

I’d be an easy no from the Habs point of view. Value favors Arizona.

 

[vokiel]

Not a chance before Reinbacher shows his skill set on North American ice. It's an unwritten rule, you don't trade someone you just drafted, unless he's a problem. Doing so would just open a can of worms for the player.

 

[82Ninety42011]

Montreal: David Reinbacher

Arizona: Dylan Guenther

Montreal has a log jam at D… they leverage this to add a top 6 goal scoring winger

Arizona adds a top pair RD to anchor their top pair with Simashev

Honestly who would you rather have Guenther or Matvei Michtov? That's who Habs passed on to take Reinbacher they're not trading him now for Guenther.

 

[Bouboumaster]

Value aside, while Habs are loaded with LHD prospects, we only had Mailloux that was kinda good that plays RHD

Reinbacher, hopefully, will play 1rst or second pair at RHD

We need him, more than we need a winger of similar talent (is he? That's another debate)

 

[HuGo Sham]

I’d be an easy no from the Habs point of view. Value favors Arizona.

if this guys says it, you know it's really bad for Montreal

 

[Jared Dunn]

Honestly who would you rather have Guenther or Matvei Michtov? That's who Habs passed on to take Reinbacher they're not trading him now for Guenther.

Yup, already took Reinbacher over better forward prospects than Guenther so they're committed unless blown away

 

[Junohockeyfan]

Does Arizona need RHD? Is there a deal around Justin Barron?

 

[MajorWeber]

Log jam of D is LHD. RHD is still weak and after drafting Reinbacher over talented wingers, they aren't doing that deal.

 

[Nevins]

The question is why do you want to trade Dylan Guenther already?

 

[mouser]

Don’t see why Montreal would want to do this, they need more time to let Reinbcher matriculate.

 

[Groo]

The question is why do you want to trade Dylan Guenther already?

OP looks to be a Habs fan

 

[HabsAddict]

We do need a top 6 RW but not at the cost of Rein

I would do Barron and a late 1st for a RW. But not our first.

I would also put Habs top 6-8 1st in play for a top young center already in the NHL.