Most Valuable Montreal Canadiens Players #3 NEW VERSION

[dkd]

Part 1

1) Carey Price
2) PK Subban


Please vote for the 3rd most valuable Canadien in terms of value and importance for the team.

Click to read more...

 

[capebretoncanadien]

Pacioretty even though you spelled it wrong.

 

[777]

Pacioretty for me, then Plekanec or Markov

 

[Adam91]

Pleks for me. The guy does so much with so little support from his line mates. Don't think he's played with a top 6 winger since Kovalev or perhaps Cammallerri during one his hot stretches.

 

[M.C.G. 31]

So tight between Plekanec and Pacioretty, but I gotta lean towards Pacioretty. REALLY close.

 

[HatTricK09]

Damnit. Voted Pacioretty but I missed Plekanec

 

[dkd]

Voted Plex although MAXPAC is up there too.

 

[DAChampion]

It's a tough call between Plekanec and Pacioretty. I'm going to abstain and wait till the next round.

 

[ZARTONK]

<--------- This guy

Pacioretty's great, but he only has offence, Plekanec does everything for this team, he's more valuable IMO.

 

[snakeye]

Plekanec. So much more versatile.

 

[Blind Gardien]

Pacioretty for me, then Plekanec or Markov

Same here. Pacioretty and Pleks are pretty close. Somebody has to score all the goals. Although Pleks has quite a few too and has so much more of a complete game... maybe I'm changing my own mind a little. Anyway, it's one of those two. Then Markov.

 

[Picaroon]

Are we talking market value or team value? If it's market it has to be Galchenyuk. For the team, I'm going with Pleks.

 

[Habskrieg]

I like Pacio. But to me, Plex is a way better and valuable player. Plex is played nearly on everything, PK, PP,even strength... He plays a very solid 2 way game and still puts up good numbers considering he's only had one constant winger. He's very underrated.

 

[Lafleurs Guy]

Max.

 

[Ohashi_Jouzu*]

Max is a "better" (read: "higher calibre) player, but Plekanec is more valuable... except perhaps in future contract dollar terms.

 

[Disappearing Semin]

Same here. Pacioretty and Pleks are pretty close. Somebody has to score all the goals. Although Pleks has quite a few too and has so much more of a complete game... maybe I'm changing my own mind a little. Anyway, it's one of those two. Then Markov.

You mean its one of those two, then the other one, then Markov right?

 

[vokiel]

Pleks! Harder to replace than Pacioretty IMHO, specially if you deal DD away.

 

[WatchfulElm]

To the OP, please give more details about what you want us to vote for.

Are you talking about the value to the team NOW? Or on the long term? This will change how Galchenyuk is ranked.

Are you talking about the value on the trade market? If you are, then should we consider their contract situation and age? This would change how Markov is ranked.

Are you talking about which players has more value for us, the fans, or for the management? This will make a big difference between DD being #9 or #19, for example.

Without those indications, this poll won't have much value. Good idea, otherwise.

 

[hogtownhabsfan*]

I'm assuming that EVERYTHING is considered.

Pacioretty is the clear #3 for me, dude is our only legitimate goal scorer.

 

[777]

How does Galchenyuk have any votes?

 

[NateTheGr8]

for the future? Probably Galchenyuk, but at this moment Paccioretty is. (I know hes still young)

 

[zzoo]

If you give a choice to 29 GMs to pick a player between those 3: Pax, Plek and Galchenyuk. I think more than 20 GMs will choose the latter.

 

[the]

If you give a choice to 29 GMs to pick a player between those 3: Pax, Plek and Galchenyuk. I think more than 20 GMs will choose the latter.

Exactly, I love Plekanec and Pacioretty but I wouldn't trade Galchenyuk before them.

 

[hogtownhabsfan*]

Exactly, I love Plekanec and Pacioretty but I wouldn't trade Galchenyuk before them.

That's tough, but it would be hard to take Galchenyuks potential over what Pacioretty is doing now. Dude is 5th in the league in goals per game, and just turned 25.

 

[Habs 4 Life]

Pacioretty no doubt. Galchenyuk ain't there yet