Most Valuable Habs - #1

[kingdok]

Who would you say is, considered around the league, the most valuable player on the Habs?

EDIT: For clarity's sake: The league is in trouble! Every teams disolves and a new league appears with 30 new owners. There's a draft with all the players available. Who, among former habs (current players or prospects) gets picked first ?

I'd go with PK personally

Click to read more...

 

[dkd]

I made this exact pole for top 10 most valuable Habs a couple months ago.

Edit: there you go.. http://hfboards.mandatory.com/showthread.php?t=1592727&highlight=

 

[kingdok]

I made this exact pole for top 10 most valuable Habs a couple months ago.

I actually looked before if it has been made lately and couldn't find anything. What did you title it?

 

[dkd]

I actually looked before if it has been made lately and couldn't find anything. What did you title it?

Editted my last post with link.

 

[kingdok]

Editted my last post with link.

Well, with Gionta, Gorges, Bouillon and Budaj all gone, it's gonna shake things up!

 

[dkd]

Well, with Gionta, Gorges, Bouillon and Budaj all gone, it's gonna shake things up!

Reopen thread and add Malhotra and Tanagradi

 

[CH25]

Where's DD ?

 

[De Montreal]

ALL things considered, I gotta go with the Scherminator

 

[JLP]

Where's DD ?

Our #1C isn't one of the top-10 choices

Voted PK.

 

[TRG]

The most valuable guy on the ice is Price. We're nothing without him. Overall, it's Subban I think.

 

[Smokey Thompson]

Trade Value or value to the team?

 

[Ohashi_Jouzu*]

Felt like voting PK and pointing at the dollar signs (*Horatio glasses* joke somewhere), but in terms of game in game out on-ice impact, there's little doubt it's Price. Possibly the best player at his position relative to his peers ("hardest to replace") that we have, too.

 

[kingdok]

Trade Value or value to the team?

Both. Also thinking long term, hence the inclusion of Beaulieu or Scherbak over Desharnais, Emelin and others already on the team.

 

[WhiskeySeven*]

Whose loss would hurt the Habs the most?

I actually think it's Subban's, though I think Price is better at his position than Subban is at his.

I see a glaring lack of our #1 centre on your little list there.

 

[kingdok]

Whose loss would hurt the Habs the most?

I actually think it's Subban's, though I think Price is better at his position than Subban is at his.

I see a glaring lack of our #1 centre on your little list there.

Yeah, I realized I didn't clarify this in the OP so I I'll just ask the question: The league is in trouble! Every teams disolves and a new league appears with 30 new owners. There a draft with all the players available. Who, among former habs (current players or prospects) gets picked first ?

 

[BigDaddyLurch]

...no question...

 

[Price My Man Crush]

...no question...

More like:

Back in the dayz.

 

[Kriss E]

Goalie is the only position in hockey that can take a very average team to a championship. So Price.

 

[Alexdaman]

DD ainec

 

[ZARTONK]

Mister Price.

 

[fufonzo]

At the time of this post, Scherbak is 3rd behind Price and Subban. Small sample size but how on earth Scherbak gets any votes as the team's most valuable player is beyond me.

Edit: I voted Subban over Price because I personally think Subban is less replaceable. Nice to have them both.

 

[Mr. Hab]

Impossible to replace PK Subban vs almost impossible to replace Price:

1. PK Subban
2. Price

3. Plekanec

 

[RJJ]

Price
Subban

Galchenyuk
Patches

Pleks
Eller
Gally

Beaulieu
Sherbak
Tinordi


Markov - down here, all alone but only cause he is really old (for a hockey player)

 

[Galchenioretty]

Price
Subban

Galchenyuk
Patches

Pleks
Eller
Gally

Beaulieu
Sherbak
Tinordi


Markov - down here, all alone but only cause he is really old (for a hockey player)

Pacioretty is closer to the first 2 because of his contract/production, he actually might be pushing Subban in value now that both on their long term deals.

Price
Subban
Pacioretty

Galchenyuk

Gallagher
Plekanec
Eller

 

[Habs 4 Life]

Carey Price AINEC