Toggle sidebar

Most underated and overated players/teams in the Q

PEI Rocket Fan

Registered User
Dec 19, 2012
26
0
Overated
-Alex Saulnier
-Allain Saulnier
-Brandon Hynes
-Olivier Archambault
-Cedrick Henley
-Jean-Sebastien Dea
Underated
-Stephan MacAulay
-Francis Beauvillier
-Darcy Ashley
-Cedric Paquette
-Marc-Olivier Roy
-Sven Andrighetto
-Peter Trainor
TEAMS
Overated
-Quebec
-Drummondville
-Moncton
Underated
-PEI
-Val-d'Or
-Rimouski
Click to read more...
 

Reesor01

Registered User
Jul 24, 2012
165
5
Halifax, NS
I don't know how the Saulniers can be overrated when Allain has 2 70+ point seasons and Alex has 2 80+ point seasons (1 while missing 10 games). They probably won't play higher than the AHL if that, but they are both excellent Q players. There's not really any hype about them either, so if anything they might be underrated.

And this is from a Moose fan. :)
 
Call me Suds

Call me Suds

Registered User
Dec 21, 2012
164
0
Reesor01 said:
I don't know how the Saulniers can be overrated when Allain has 2 70+ point seasons and Alex has 2 80+ point seasons (1 while missing 10 games). They probably won't play higher than the AHL if that, but they are both excellent Q players. There's not really any hype about them either, so if anything they might be underrated.

And this is from a Moose fan. :)
Click to expand...

Agreed.

If you had them listed under "Love to hate" then it'd be more fitting. Those guys have been burning teams for 3 years now and didn't even get drafted to the Q until they were 17 lol
 

lavoy

Registered User
Nov 3, 2011
2,609
0
I don't see how Gillard is over-rated (Strange right? ;)) If anything he doesn't get enough love for what he does.... I know I'll just be a homer on here but no one has watched him enough to fully appreciate the role he's asked to fill IMO...

Overrated
Rouyn
Matt Bissonnette
JS Dea
Zach O'Brien
James Melindy
Alex Dubeau
Max Lagace
Raphael Bussieres

Underrated
Drummondville
Vincent Dunn
Peter Trainor
Matt Boudreau
Laurent Dauphin
Matt Murphy
Raphael Lafontaine
Randy Gazzola
Mathieu Brisebois
 

IHaveNoCreativity

Registered User
May 5, 2012
12,733
534
Somewhere in Quebec.
HalifaxDucks said:
I don't see how Gillard is over-rated (Strange right? ;)) If anything he doesn't get enough love for what he does.... I know I'll just be a homer on here but no one has watched him enough to fully appreciate the role he's asked to fill IMO...

Overrated
Rouyn
Matt Bissonnette
JS Dea
Zach O'Brien
James Melindy
Alex Dubeau
Max Lagace
Raphael Bussieres

Underrated
Drummondville
Vincent Dunn
Peter Trainor
Matt Boudreau
Laurent Dauphin
Matt Murphy
Raphael Lafontaine
Randy Gazzola
Mathieu Brisebois
Click to expand...

Trainor and Dunn were good catches.

Murphy too actually.

I think Gilliard is an average OA Defenceman.
 

lavoy

Registered User
Nov 3, 2011
2,609
0
IHaveNoCreativity said:
Trainor and Dunn were good catches.

Murphy too actually.

I think Gilliard is an average OA Defenceman.
Click to expand...

Gillard* no I ;)

Dunn and Murphy go under the radar because Val-d'Or don't get much attention, and when they do it (deservingly) goes to Mantha.

Trainor has quietly put up one of the best offensive seasons by any player not named Currie, Duffy or Drouin....
 
Raimu

Raimu

That weird Dragon girl
Jan 21, 2006
1,192
5
Halifax, NS
IHaveNoCreativity said:
Overrated:
1:Matthew Bissonette
2:Steve Gilliard
3:Zach O'Brien
4:Robin Gusse
5:Ben Duffy

Underrated:
1:Josh Currie
2:Raphael Bussieres
3:Marc-Olivier Roy
4:Nicklas Sorensen
5:Petr Straka
Click to expand...

I have the exact opposite feeling on Gillard. I think he's criminally underrated.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Ad

Latest posts

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

Top Bottom