hmm, actually, i'll give this a few shots. going through some of the bloated superteams of the pre-cap, UFA era--
'96 st. louis blues--
corson (actual captain, former oilers captain)
hull (former blues captain, stripped by keenan?)
macinnis (former flames captain-- i think briefly?)
mactavish (former oilers captain)
gretzky (duh)
hawerchuk (former jets captain)
(+ future captain pronger and future flames captain conroy)
or '98 rangers:
leetch (actual captain)
gretzky
lafontaine (former sabres captain)
driver (former devils captain)
keane (former habs captain)
skrudland (former panthers captain)
errey (former sharks captain)
lidster (former canucks captain the year they rotated it between him, linden, and dan quinn)
'04 avs:
sakic (actual captain)
blake (former kings)
kariya (former ducks)
selanne (former ducks when kariya was injured)
gratton (former lightning)
(+ future avs captains foote and hejduk, and future flyers captain forsberg)
'00 stars
hatcher (actual captain)
keane (habs)
carbonneau (habs)
skrudland (panthers)
muller (devils)
nieuwendyk (flames)
hull (blues)
(+ future stars captains modano and morrow, and future devils captain langenbrunner)
'01 blues
pronger (actual captain)
macinnis (former flames captain?)
tkachuk (former jets/coyotes)
turgeon (former islanders)
mellanby (former panthers)
(+ future captain drake, future flames captain conroy and future devils captain salvador)
'04 wings
yzerman (actual captain)
hatcher (stars)
chelios (habs/hawks)
hull (blues)
shanahan (whalers)
whitney (BJs)
(+ future wings captains lidstrom and zetterberg)