hawksfan50 said:
he also stinks at face-offs at this juncture
So does Joe Thornton. Last night April 10, Joe won five of 22 faceoffs against the Coyotes. I think faceoffs are important, but sometimes too much emphasis can be placed on them, such as when evaluating prospects. There are other skills that are way more important and can have a more significant impact on the game that the ability to win faceoffs. Besides, it's a skill that can be learned.
Back in 1977, the Montreal Canadiens had a chance to draft Mike Bossy, but they were concerned about his defensive shortcomings. So they drafted Mark Napier, who they thought would be a better two-way player. Besides, Napier could fly.
Bossy falls to the Islanders and their scouts tell Arbour about Bossy's weakness. He tells them: "We'll teach him to play defence."
Bossy went on to score 573 goals in 752 games. Napier had a very respectable career that included two 40-goal seasons, but he was no Mike Bossy.
My point: teams will not be that concerned that Staal doesn't seem to be very good on faceoffs. (What are his numbers by the way? I've only seen hearsay on message forums that he's no good)