I’m right with you on all 4 points.
We likely miss the playoffs in 16/17 if we don’t have Larsson back there playing like an elite shutdown dman.
Pulju is looking like a disappointment, but that draft had a big 3, and every other fanbase was envious we got one with the 4th pick.
Lucic was a beast the first year. There was no way of predicting he’d go for Christmas break in 2017, and suddenly lose the ability to put up points when he returned.
And ya. Holland is clearly the better GM. Chia is the guy willing to overpay to get what he wants. Holland is the guy making him overpay.
The biggest issue with Chia was that he couldn't admit fault. (Yes, worse than the overpays...)
In his first year and a half he was actually decent for improving the (RE: MacT's) roster. Even with the massive overpays, the roster was still better.
He overhauled the defence with Sekera, Russell, Larsson, and Benning; and underperforming vets like Ference and Fayne were pushed out.
He even made a few good savvy moves for Maroon, Kassan, Talbot, and Nilsson; bringing in NHL'ers for busts, low picks, or guys who were done.
However when
his guys started to under perform, they weren't held to the same level of accountability as Fayne or Pouliot.
The little moves to improve the roster dried up, as guys like Letestu, Lucic, Caggiula all unquestionably deserved their top 9 spots. Plus a teenage Puljujarvi or Yamamoto would be enough to replace Eberle; so why would more outside help be needed?
If I'm not mistaken, the only pick/prospect for NHL'er trade he made post-Hall (so purely adding to the roster, and not taking someone off it) was the Petrovic trade. Otherwise any trade always involved taking an equivalent (or better) piece off the active roster.
Davidson for DD
Eberle for Strome
Jokinen for Cammy
Strome for Spooner
Caggiula/Garrison for Manning