Mid season grades
- Thread starter Skobel24
- Start date
Yung Rotini
6 Summers
Backlund - B+
Baertschi - C
Bollig - C+
Bouma - A-
Brodie - A-
Colborne - B
Diaz - C-
Engelland - C
Ferland - B
Gaudreau - A
Giordano - A+
Glencross - B-
Granlund - B
Hiller - C
Hudler - B+
Jones - C+
Jooris - A-
Knight - C
McGrattan - C
Monahan - B
Ramo - B-
Raymond - C-
Reinhart - B-
Russell - B
Setoguchi - D
Smid - C
Stajan - B-
Wideman - B
Baertschi - C
Bollig - C+
Bouma - A-
Brodie - A-
Colborne - B
Diaz - C-
Engelland - C
Ferland - B
Gaudreau - A
Giordano - A+
Glencross - B-
Granlund - B
Hiller - C
Hudler - B+
Jones - C+
Jooris - A-
Knight - C
McGrattan - C
Monahan - B
Ramo - B-
Raymond - C-
Reinhart - B-
Russell - B
Setoguchi - D
Smid - C
Stajan - B-
Wideman - B
Tkachuky
Registered User
Backlund - B
Baertschi - C
Bollig - C-
Bouma - B+
Brodie - A
Colborne - B-
Diaz - C
Engelland -C
Ferland - C+
Gaudreau - A
Giordano - A+
Glencross - B-
Granlund - B-
Hiller - B
Hudler - A
Jones - C-
Jooris - A
Knight - F for Florida
McGrattan - N/A
Monahan - B+
Ramo - B-
Raymond - B-
Reinhart - C
Russell - B+
Setoguchi - F
Smid - C+
Stajan - C+
Wideman - B+
Baertschi - C
Bollig - C-
Bouma - B+
Brodie - A
Colborne - B-
Diaz - C
Engelland -C
Ferland - C+
Gaudreau - A
Giordano - A+
Glencross - B-
Granlund - B-
Hiller - B
Hudler - A
Jones - C-
Jooris - A
Knight - F for Florida
McGrattan - N/A
Monahan - B+
Ramo - B-
Raymond - B-
Reinhart - C
Russell - B+
Setoguchi - F
Smid - C+
Stajan - C+
Wideman - B+
Backlund: B. He's played well, but was injured for a while. I'm sure this may go up if he stays healthy
Baertschi: D+. He didn't see much icetime, but he still didn't impress me much. He's doing much better in the AHL right now though. Hopefully he'll get another chance later on.
Bollig: D. Didn't meet my expectations, but he's still an upgrade over McGrattan.
Bouma: B+. Incredible defensive game, and he's providing offense. On pace for about 12g 15a.
Brodie: A. I believe he is a legitimate top pairing guy in the league now.
Colborne: B-. I want to see him shoot more. Aside from that, he's been good.
Diaz: D+. I'd rather have Brookbank.
Engelland: C-. Nothing special.
Ferland: C. He showed he can be a pest. Hopefully his offense will improve.
Gaudreau: A. What a gem. Glad to see him shooting more now
Giordano: A++. Nothing left to be said.
Glencross: B+. Frustrating at times, but he plays against top lines, and he does a damn good job of it.
Granlund: C. Had a great start, then kinda disappeared.
Hiller: B-. He has his bad games, but he's been reliable most of the year.
Hudler: A. Calgary needed a top line RW, and Hudler filled that need. Very impressed with him this year.
Jones: B. Another surprise this year. Would like to see a bit more offense from him though.
Jooris: B+. WWJD
Knight: B. He only played two games, and averaged 6 minutes of ice time, but I was impressed by him. He'll have a bright future here...
McGrattan: D-. I love the guy, but I'm glad he's been waived.
Monahan: B+. He's been great defensively, and physically. I hope he starts picking it up a bit in terms of offense though.
Ramo: B-. Capable goalie, unfortunately he's been injured a lot.
Raymond: D-. Aside from that hot start, he's been hot trash.
Reinhart: D. Nothing special.
Russell: B+. Developing into a strong #3. For the love of god, put one in the net soon.
Setoguchi: F. He was a low risk high reward signing. There was no reward.
Smid: D. I haven't been happy with him at all. He looked great last year. Not sure what happened.
Stajan: B. Reliable two way center. Not a fan of him being on the 4th line, but he isn't an upgrade over the guys in the top 9.
Wideman: B+. Big surprise this year. Went from the whipping boy to a strong #3.
Baertschi: D+. He didn't see much icetime, but he still didn't impress me much. He's doing much better in the AHL right now though. Hopefully he'll get another chance later on.
Bollig: D. Didn't meet my expectations, but he's still an upgrade over McGrattan.
Bouma: B+. Incredible defensive game, and he's providing offense. On pace for about 12g 15a.
Brodie: A. I believe he is a legitimate top pairing guy in the league now.
Colborne: B-. I want to see him shoot more. Aside from that, he's been good.
Diaz: D+. I'd rather have Brookbank.
Engelland: C-. Nothing special.
Ferland: C. He showed he can be a pest. Hopefully his offense will improve.
Gaudreau: A. What a gem. Glad to see him shooting more now
Giordano: A++. Nothing left to be said.
Glencross: B+. Frustrating at times, but he plays against top lines, and he does a damn good job of it.
Granlund: C. Had a great start, then kinda disappeared.
Hiller: B-. He has his bad games, but he's been reliable most of the year.
Hudler: A. Calgary needed a top line RW, and Hudler filled that need. Very impressed with him this year.
Jones: B. Another surprise this year. Would like to see a bit more offense from him though.
Jooris: B+. WWJD
Knight: B. He only played two games, and averaged 6 minutes of ice time, but I was impressed by him. He'll have a bright future here...
McGrattan: D-. I love the guy, but I'm glad he's been waived.
Monahan: B+. He's been great defensively, and physically. I hope he starts picking it up a bit in terms of offense though.
Ramo: B-. Capable goalie, unfortunately he's been injured a lot.
Raymond: D-. Aside from that hot start, he's been hot trash.
Reinhart: D. Nothing special.
Russell: B+. Developing into a strong #3. For the love of god, put one in the net soon.
Setoguchi: F. He was a low risk high reward signing. There was no reward.
Smid: D. I haven't been happy with him at all. He looked great last year. Not sure what happened.
Stajan: B. Reliable two way center. Not a fan of him being on the 4th line, but he isn't an upgrade over the guys in the top 9.
Wideman: B+. Big surprise this year. Went from the whipping boy to a strong #3.
Lunatik
Registered User
- Oct 12, 2012
- 56,250
- 8,384
It's almost like this thread was meant for the mid season grades or something.
Anglesmith
Setting up the play?
Doesn't matter. I like to think of the hockey season as one of those courses where your final can replace your midterms.
Lunatik
Registered User
- Oct 12, 2012
- 56,250
- 8,384
Lunatik
Registered User
- Oct 12, 2012
- 56,250
- 8,384
Johnny Hoxville
The Return of a Legend
InfinityIggy
Zagidulin's Dad
Backlund - A+++
Baertschi - C+
Bollig - C
Bouma - B+
Brodie - A+
Colborne - B+
Diaz - D
Engelland - C-
Ferland - B
Gaudreau - A+
Giordano - A+
Glencross - B-
Granlund - B-
Hiller - C
Hudler - A
Jones - B+
Jooris - B
Knight - LOL BYYYYYYE
McGrattan -
Monahan - B
Ramo - B-
Raymond - D
Reinhart - C
Russell - B
Setoguchi - F
Smid - D
Stajan - C
Wideman - B
Baertschi - C+
Bollig - C
Bouma - B+
Brodie - A+
Colborne - B+
Diaz - D
Engelland - C-
Ferland - B
Gaudreau - A+
Giordano - A+
Glencross - B-
Granlund - B-
Hiller - C
Hudler - A
Jones - B+
Jooris - B
Knight - LOL BYYYYYYE
McGrattan -
Monahan - B
Ramo - B-
Raymond - D
Reinhart - C
Russell - B
Setoguchi - F
Smid - D
Stajan - C
Wideman - B
Backlund - A
Baertschi - D
Bollig - C+
Bouma - A+
Brodie - A-
Colborne - B+
Diaz - C
Engelland - C+
Ferland - C
Gaudreau - B+
Giordano - A+
Glencross - B
Granlund - B-
Hiller - B+
Hudler - A+
Jones - B
Jooris - B+
Monahan - B+
Ramo - B-
Raymond - C+
Reinhart - C-
Russell - B
Setoguchi - F
Smid - D+
Stajan - B+
Wideman - B+
Baertschi - D
Bollig - C+
Bouma - A+
Brodie - A-
Colborne - B+
Diaz - C
Engelland - C+
Ferland - C
Gaudreau - B+
Giordano - A+
Glencross - B
Granlund - B-
Hiller - B+
Hudler - A+
Jones - B
Jooris - B+
Monahan - B+
Ramo - B-
Raymond - C+
Reinhart - C-
Russell - B
Setoguchi - F
Smid - D+
Stajan - B+
Wideman - B+
Lunatik
Registered User
- Oct 12, 2012
- 56,250
- 8,384
Taranis
Registered User
Backlund - A
Baertschi - C
Bollig - D
Bouma - C
Brodie - A
Byron - C
Colborne - B
Diaz - D
Engelland - C
Ferland - C
Gaudreau - B
Giordano - A
Glencross - B
Granlund - B
Hiller - B
Hudler - A
Jones - B
Jooris - B
Knight - C
McGrattan - C
Monahan - B
Ramo - B
Raymond - D
Reinhart - C
Russell - C
Setoguchi - D
Smid - D
Stajan - C
Wideman - B
Baertschi - C
Bollig - D
Bouma - C
Brodie - A
Byron - C
Colborne - B
Diaz - D
Engelland - C
Ferland - C
Gaudreau - B
Giordano - A
Glencross - B
Granlund - B
Hiller - B
Hudler - A
Jones - B
Jooris - B
Knight - C
McGrattan - C
Monahan - B
Ramo - B
Raymond - D
Reinhart - C
Russell - C
Setoguchi - D
Smid - D
Stajan - C
Wideman - B
Backlund - A-
Baertschi - D
Bollig - D
Bouma - A
Brodie - A+
Byron - C
Colborne - A-
Diaz - B-
Engelland - C
Ferland - D (not really his fault, though)
Gaudreau - A+
Giordano - A++++
Glencross - B+
Granlund - B+
Hiller - B
Hudler - A+
Jones - B-
Jooris - A
Knight - B (only because he brought in Drew Shore)
McGrattan - D- (again, not his fault)
Monahan - A-
Ortio - A+
Ramo - B+
Raymond - B-
Reinhart - D
Russell - A+
Setoguchi - F
Smid - D+
Stajan - B
Wideman - A
Baertschi - D
Bollig - D
Bouma - A
Brodie - A+
Byron - C
Colborne - A-
Diaz - B-
Engelland - C
Ferland - D (not really his fault, though)
Gaudreau - A+
Giordano - A++++
Glencross - B+
Granlund - B+
Hiller - B
Hudler - A+
Jones - B-
Jooris - A
Knight - B (only because he brought in Drew Shore)
McGrattan - D- (again, not his fault)
Monahan - A-
Ortio - A+
Ramo - B+
Raymond - B-
Reinhart - D
Russell - A+
Setoguchi - F
Smid - D+
Stajan - B
Wideman - A
Johnny Hoxville
The Return of a Legend
Lots of high marks for Backlund, he's been great but he's missed over the half year. Im not sure if that should warrant him getting an A or higher, I think a -B is probably fair.
Taranis
Registered User
Johnny Hoxville
The Return of a Legend
It's hard to dispute his actual play, but from an overall mid season grade I think his GP should be factored in. Admittedly though he's been exceptional.
SmellOfVictory
Registered User
- Jun 3, 2011
- 10,959
- 653
Backlund - N/A (can't rate him for playing injured to start season)
Baertschi - C+
Bollig - F
Bouma - B-
Brodie - A+
Colborne - C
Diaz - C
Engelland - F
Ferland - B+
Gaudreau - A+
Giordano - A+
Glencross - B
Granlund - B-
Hiller - A-
Hudler - A
Jones - C+
Jooris - B+
Knight - C
McGrattan - C
Monahan - A-
Ramo - B
Raymond - C
Reinhart - C
Russell - B-
Setoguchi - F
Smid - D
Stajan - B-
Wideman - B-
I consider C to be barely passable, C+/B- to be decent, and anything above that is good to amazing.
Baertschi - C+
Bollig - F
Bouma - B-
Brodie - A+
Colborne - C
Diaz - C
Engelland - F
Ferland - B+
Gaudreau - A+
Giordano - A+
Glencross - B
Granlund - B-
Hiller - A-
Hudler - A
Jones - C+
Jooris - B+
Knight - C
McGrattan - C
Monahan - A-
Ramo - B
Raymond - C
Reinhart - C
Russell - B-
Setoguchi - F
Smid - D
Stajan - B-
Wideman - B-
I consider C to be barely passable, C+/B- to be decent, and anything above that is good to amazing.
