Proposal: Marner for Chabot

[cj19]

Leafs trade for Chabot because they would still have offensive weapons upfront in Matthews JT, Nylander, Kapanen & Kadri.

To have two of the best young D in Chabot & Rielly on the Leafs would make the Leafs Stanley cup favourites!

The Sens do this trade to acquire Marner one of the best hockey minds in the NHL- most entertaining player to help put bums in the seats. Marner should be top ten in scoring every year for the next decade barring injury.

Click to read more...

 

[Taluss]

You are about to get absolutely shit on

 

[Toronto makebeleifs]

As polite as I can be from a leaf perspective. No. Never try again.

 

[Morlu]

You are about to get absolutely **** on

LOL value wise it’s probably close.... Both teams pass easily.

 

[Hale The Villain]

Give me a young #1 D over a young #1 RW any day of the week

Sens don't touch this

 

[BB88]

Leafs trade for Chabot because they would still have offensive weapons upfront in Matthews JT, Nylander, Kapanen & Kadri.

To have two of the best young D in Chabot & Rielly on the Leafs would make the Leafs Stanley cup favourites!

The Sens do this trade to acquire Marner one of the best hockey minds in the NHL- most entertaining player to help put bums in the seats. Marner should be top ten in scoring every year for the next decade barring injury.

Given a single thought to Ottawa's defense?

Imagine losing Karlsson& Chabot in few months and not even having a 1st round pick.

 

[Il Mediano]

If this is a troll post , I commend you.

If this is a genuine proposal , I don't know what to say.

 

[Colt55]

As polite as I can be from a leaf perspective. No. Never try again.

So when someone makes an offer for one of your young stud players discussion should never happen. But when you want other teams young studs that fan base is being ridiculous and homers to say no.

This is not specifically directed at you but some of your more eccentric fam base

 

[Jozay]

Neither side does this.

 

[HockeyDBspecialist]

a young future superstarD is worth WAY MORE than a superstar RW.... Talent wise it's fair, but D>Wing

Also, No way Ottawa would make this deal, Chabot is a Futur Norris winner....

 

[93gilmour93]

Chabot is a great young D man but I couldn't move Marner for him. In most cases you make a move of a winger for a top young D man but not in the case of Marner

 

[7even]

Give me a young #1 D over a young #1 RW any day of the week

Sens don't touch this

Give me a guy with 180 games of performance over a guy with 20 games any day of the week


Oops I got baited, wp OP

 

[flamesforcup]

Chabot probably has a little more value than Marner. Sens dont do this because their defense is already bad. Leafs however do it in a heartbeat, ur offense will still be good but u get a great defender. Think of it another way Leafs fans who is more important to ur team Marner or Rielly? Imagine adding another Rielly and Nylander can just take Marners spot. Leafs easily do this.

 

[Taluss]

Chabot probably has a little more value than Marner. Sens dont do this because their defense is already bad. Leafs however do it in a heartbeat, ur offense will still be good but u get a great defender. Think of it another way Leafs fans who is more important to ur team Marner or Rielly? Imagine adding another Rielly and Nylander can just take Marners spot. Leafs easily do this.

Why am I getting baited into this ffs.

I just think Leafs would do this if there was a years worth of his 20 game production at least. As of rn both teams would easily say no I believe.

 

[flamesforcup]

Why am I getting baited into this ffs.

I just think Leafs would do this if there was a years worth of his 20 game production at least. As of rn both teams would easily say no I believe.

If Chabot keeps up this production for a year we are talking Matthews than not Marner

 

[david999]

Marner or Chabot? Which player can demand and likely get $9-10 mill coming out of his ELC?

 

[zar]

Right, from a value perspective, Marner > Chabot.

If Chabot continually performs the way he has started (or even close to it) then it actually favors TML. #1D > #1W

Chabot (6G + 21A) is projecting to finish the season with 4 less points than Marner (6G + 22A)... as a Dman... with way less talent to play with... and only 7 of those points are PP points (Marner has 8 PP points).

What Chabot is doing is quite amazing... and it's 23 games in (not a 10 game sample size)... but it's a bit early to put him on the same level as Marner.

 

[LeafChief]

Yikes...

 

[beowulf]

Give me a young #1 D over a young #1 RW any day of the week

Sens don't touch this

Yep totally agree.

 

[Namikaze Minato]

If Chabot keeps up this production for a year we are talking Matthews than not Marner

Or how abotu you move Monohan for him?

5 #1 defenceman! could you believe that!!!

 

[Cotton]

So when someone makes an offer for one of your young stud players discussion should never happen. But when you want other teams young studs that fan base is being ridiculous and homers to say no.

This is not specifically directed at you but some of your more eccentric fam base

There are several chapters of the Nylander thread, each filled with many garbage proposals for him, nobody is stopping it.

 

[Leaf Fans]

If Chabot keeps up this production for a year we are talking Matthews than not Marner

Sure, this is what will be talked about: Matthews will not be traded for Chabot. Great player though.

 

[flamesforcup]

Or how abotu you move Monohan for him?

5 #1 defenceman! could you believe that!!!

U know u keep saying that old "FoUr #1 dEfEnSeMeN" meme from 3 years ago but literally no one says that. If u want we can talk about the Leagues best offense not being able to win a series. At least we were able to win one with our current core. But i dont wanna derail the thread anymore this is not what the discussion was about

 

[thunder16]

a young future superstarD is worth WAY MORE than a superstar RW.... Talent wise it's fair, but D>Wing

Also, No way Ottawa would make this deal, Chabot is a Futur Norris winner....

Every one is a Psychic.

 

[16thOverallSaveUs]

The only time the leafs would ever move Marner is if their offense was superb and could live without him and they’re defense was horrendous, and also they’d have to be missing the playoffs like 2 years in a row.

I guess what I’m trying to say is Marner is never going to get traded, and if he was gonna get traded it would be for a #1 defensmen who is offensively sound but is too 5 defensively in the NHL; they’d be looking for a Doughty type player, but younger. I don’t know if one of those exists.