Toggle sidebar

Confirmed with Link: Marian Gaborik to Columbus for Brassard, J. Moore and Dorsett

Samuel Culper III

Samuel Culper III

Mr. Woodhull...
Jan 15, 2007
13,144
1,099
Texas
Torts to Sather, after the deal:

"That's not what I meant when you came to me with Brassard for Gaborik and I told you I wanted more..."



Edit: But seriously, I like the deal. It's not great; it's got potential to help though. Maybe I shouldn't say I "like" it. I certainly don't love it. But I'm not upset about it either. It could end up paying better dividends than we know. Moore could be really good for us and certainly helps our D by pushing Gilroy/Hamrlik/Eminger out. He's easily better than all of them, and still improving. Brassard. If he does exactly what he did in Columbus he'll be alright but nothing worth getting excited about. Dorsett brings something we really needed to get back. Clowe, if he can rebound will be good. If not, he'll be a glorified Rupp.
 
Zamboner

Zamboner

Juice in his slacks
Feb 7, 2013
2,530
364
NY
Plagiarizing myself from the last thread.

So in conclusion,

We got a 3rd line center, who's skills don't translate to centering a 3rd line.

We got yet another solid left handed defenseman who doesn't create offense.

And we finally got Brandon Prust's replacement, but he can't play until the playoffs. The playoffs that we probably won't make.

For Marian Gaborik.
 
Kwayry

Kwayry

Registered User
Jun 30, 2011
2,974
0
Plano
Torts: On if he believes the Rangers are a better team after the trade deadline: “I have no idea.”
 
tjs252

tjs252

Registered User
Feb 10, 2007
506
0
The worst thing you can say for a trade is that the offer you ended up taking would have been on the table in the foreseeable future, you lost.
 
Tawnos

Tawnos

A guy with a bass
Sep 10, 2004
29,060
10,750
Charlotte, NC
Zamboner said:
Plagiarizing myself from the last thread.

So in conclusion,

We got a 3rd line center, who's skills don't translate to centering a 3rd line.

We got yet another solid left handed defenseman who doesn't create offense.

And we finally got Brandon Prust's replacement, but he can't play until the playoffs. The playoffs that we probably won't make.

For Marian Gaborik.
Click to expand...

Or..

We got a 3rd line center whose skills translate exactly to the kind of 3rd line a team like ours should have.

We got a right D with great upside.

We got a very good bottom 6 grit guy who will undoubtedly help us in the first round of the playoffs when we get there.

For

A scorer who has scored in only 6 games this season.
 
Samuel Culper III

Samuel Culper III

Mr. Woodhull...
Jan 15, 2007
13,144
1,099
Texas
Tawnos said:
Or..

We got a 3rd line center whose skills translate exactly to the kind of 3rd line a team like ours should have.

We got a right D with great upside.

We got a very good bottom 6 grit guy who will undoubtedly help us in the first round of the playoffs when we get there.

For

A scorer who has scored in only 6 games this season.
Click to expand...

Don't try to reason. Optimism about the trade is not allowed.

But really, you're right. We also got cap flexible and shookup a team that needed a shaking. I know Moore can and will PLAY the right sided, but I really wish he was right handed. That would have been real nice.
 

Mr Atoz*

Guest
This is why this team can never win. Trade the future for the past, and when it doesn't work, trade the past for the future. And so on and so on.
 
Kwayry

Kwayry

Registered User
Jun 30, 2011
2,974
0
Plano
Tawnos said:
Or..

We got a 3rd line center whose skills translate exactly to the kind of 3rd line a team like ours should have.

We got a right D with great upside.

We got a very good bottom 6 grit guy who will undoubtedly help us in the first round of the playoffs when we get there.

For

A scorer who has scored in only 6 games this season.
Click to expand...

Moore is a LD.
 
ThisIsMyAlibi

ThisIsMyAlibi

Fantilli&Werenski&Gaudreau&Laine&Johnson&Jiricek
Mar 16, 2010
1,879
1,307
Ohio
Brassards aren't conducive to championship rosters. Inconsistent, paid their market value, and little in the way of leadership. He has physical talent but it never clicked. What you're left with is a guy being paid like a 2/3 C without the skillset to play in the top 6. So he plays grinder lines without grinder attributes.
 
Callafan24

Callafan24

Registered User
Sep 22, 2010
159
37
New York City
Equally compelling perspectives. Might have been able to get more at the draft, but I don't yet feel fleeced by the deal. Time will tell.:)
 
Tawnos

Tawnos

A guy with a bass
Sep 10, 2004
29,060
10,750
Charlotte, NC
MPF24 said:
Don't try to reason. Optimism about the trade is not allowed.

But really, you're right. We also got cap flexible and shookup a team that needed a shaking. I know Moore can and will PLAY the right sided, but I really wish he was right handed. That would have been real nice.
Click to expand...

I'm being driven into optimism by some of the pessimism. In reality, I'm somewhere in between. The only thing that matters to me is wins. Gaborik could score 10 goals over the rest of the year. If we can win consistently again, I don't care.
 

Punxrocknyc19*

Guest
Kwayry said:
Torts: On if he believes the Rangers are a better team after the trade deadline: “I have no idea.â€
Click to expand...

did he really just say that?? he couldnt be positive :help: no wonder why this team showed no emotion
 

MessierIsGod

Registered User
Oct 2, 2010
519
10
Zamboner said:
Plagiarizing myself from the last thread.

So in conclusion,

We got a 3rd line center, who's skills don't translate to centering a 3rd line.

We got yet another solid left handed defenseman who doesn't create offense.

And we finally got Brandon Prust's replacement, but he can't play until the playoffs. The playoffs that we probably won't make.

For Marian Gaborik.
Click to expand...

Agreed..gabby has a better chance of turning around to be the "old" gabby than clowe turning around.

We won't make the playoffs.
 
NYRKING30

NYRKING30

Registered User
Apr 29, 2011
6,208
1,940
NYC
To BroadwayBlue, Either trade him at the draft or by the deadline next year which he would have rebounded. I would have been more satisfied if they traded him straight up for a 1st rouner. I just don't know what to make of this team after this trade. Now we are going to be in the hunt for another goal scorer in the offseason and beyond. If Brassard turns into Kyle Turris 2.0, I'll be satisfied. I wasn't expecting like 2 1sts or anything but probably should have held onto him to at least the draft.
 
Samuel Culper III

Samuel Culper III

Mr. Woodhull...
Jan 15, 2007
13,144
1,099
Texas
ThisIsMyAlibi said:
Brassards aren't conducive to championship rosters. Inconsistent, paid their market value, and little in the way of leadership. He has physical talent but it never clicked. What you're left with is a guy being paid like a 2/3 C without the skillset to play in the top 6. So he plays grinder lines without grinder attributes.
Click to expand...

Brassard, guaranteed gets some minutes with top six linemates as well and sees some PP time. He has the tools to play in the top six; he's just been inconsistent. 40+ points isn't awful and at 25, having only ever played for a CBJ team that's been terrible most years, it's not as if a change of scenery couldn't help him put it together a little bit better. He's a 40+ point guy right now. If he can be a 50+ point guy, how bad is that? Not terrible.
 
Zamboner

Zamboner

Juice in his slacks
Feb 7, 2013
2,530
364
NY
Even if Moore does end up playing the right side well -- We're the 5th best team in GAA. A bottom paired defenseman shouldn't be the highlight of a package for Marian Gaborik. I don't care how bad his numbers are this year.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Ad

Latest posts

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

Top Bottom