Not really - look at what the most recent arenas have cost:
Climate Pledge Arena (2021) - $1.15 bil (yes it was an expensive refit of an old arena)
UBS Arena (2021) - $1 bil
Little Caesars Arena (2017) - $862 mil
Rogers Place (2016) - $483 mil Canadian
I tend to agree with the poster you're replying to, that when you're talking about $600m in upgrades vs $1,000m for an entirely new arena, a whole new place sounds like a better option
Provided you have a good place to put a new arena.
Think of it this way: If your $30,000 car needed $18,000 worth of repairs, would anyone choose repairs over buying a new car? Because "where to put it and what to do with the old one" are simply not factors for that.
The place to put it is the key. Like, in Philadelphia they have a ton of space in the stadium district to just build a new one in the parking lot. So why put $600m into a 30-year old place when you can build a new one for $400m more and get "all new everything."
Obviously, most places don't have the luxury of ample space to put a venue like that.
6 pages of this compared to 6000 threads dedicated to the Coyotes and that’s not as much of an exaggeration as it looks.
The headlines for this are misleading. "Moving the teams out of DC" is technically accurate, but it's like six miles.
The Coyotes moving from Glendale to Tempe was 27 miles, and the Coyotes threads are so huge because a large number of hockey fans WANT the Coyotes to move out of Arizona for another market hundreds of miles away.