I am on some business trip away from my PC, so, I may add some information later.
First of all, congratulations to Markrander87 and Stoneberg, great job guys! I can tell, that I ranked your team very high.
Other thoughts:
Please, pay attention, that it's play-off time now. So, please, don't estimate the teams by their regular season's ability! Off course, I'm biased here, but I don't see any team, that can match our play-off's performers group.
Conveniently enough I think we have a better group of playoff performers.
Namba said:
Let's see. We have:
Toe Blake, who has retro Conn Smythe, when he had two points per game which went untouched until Wayne Gretzky. His other play-offs records are:
Playoff Goals- 6th(1938), 6th (1943), 3rd(1944), 1st(1946)
Playoff Assists- 9th(1941), 10th(1943), 1st (1944), 2nd(1946),1st(1947)
Playoff Points- 9th (1943), 1st(1944), 2nd(1946), 2nd (1947)
Gordie Howe - Pretty much eclipses your top few guys on his own, to be honest.
Play-off Points –
1st(1949), 1st(1952), 1st(1955), 1st(1961), 1st(1963) 1st(1964), 2nd(1956), 4th(1954), 4th(1966), 6th(1951), 8th(1957), 8th(1960), 9th(1953)
Play-off Goals - 1st(1949), 1st(1955), 1st(1964), 2nd(1963), 3rd(1951), 3rd(1961), 4th(1954), 6th(1965), 6th(1966), 7th(1952), 9th(1956), 9th(1957)
Play-off Assists - 1st(1952), 2nd(1955), 2nd(1956), 2nd(1961), 2nd(1963), 2nd(1964), 4th(1953), 4th(1954), 4th(1966), 5th(1960), 7th(1951),7th(1957), 8th(1949)
Certainly would have been good for a few Smythe's had the trophy existed.
Namba said:
Frank Nighbour, who led playoffs in goals once ('20), and twice in assists ('15, '21) and points ('15, '21). In 19 Stanley Cup finals games, Nighbor scored 20p.
Nighbor retired 3rd all time in NHL playoff scoring.
Syd Howe was top 10 in playoff scoring 6 times and retired (many years later than Nighbor) 2nd on the all-time playoff scoring list.
Namba said:
We don't know how Mikhailov would have played in play-offs, but we know that:
a) he was unbelievably stable goal-scorer, who scored against any opponent
b) he was always prized for his hard-working
c) he is known as player, who scored ugly goals
d) he is known as a player, who stepped up big moments.
So, considering, that play-off is all about hard-working and ugly goals, I believe, he will bee good in play-off
I agree Mikhailov would be a good playoff performer, but would he be as good as
Marty Barry was? Barry is praised as a clutch player, twice leading the playoffs in scoring and registering 17 points in 17 games leading Detroit to back to back Stanley Cup wins in 1936-37.
Namba said:
Tom Phillips was Stanley Cup Challenge leading scorer twice
Lester Patrick was a seasoned and accomplished Stanley Cup finalist, winning the Cup twice (06, 07) and playing in the finals 5 more times (04, 08, 14, 18, 26). He was second in scoring in 1907. His Cup final play is heavily praised in various quotes in his linked bio.
Namba said:
Ratelle was 3x Top 9 Playoff Goals(2, 4, 9)
3x Top 9 Playoff Assists(3, 7, 9)
3x Top 7 Playoff Points(4, 5, 7)
Denis Savard was also known for stepping his game up in the playoffs scoring 175 points in 169 playoff games, including 147 points in 120 games between 82-92.
Namba said:
Tikkanen in the postseason was one of the best over an 8-year stretch (almost all of those years post-Getzky) scoring 100 playoff points, scoring 52 goals, one less than Neely and three less than playoff leaders over that 8-year stretch Lemieux and Messier (!!). He also scored four playoff OT goals over that stretch!
Bob Pulford has a retro Conn Smythe (1964), he was a clutch player who was known to elevate his offensive game in the playoffs.
Play-off Points - 3rd(1967), 8th(1959), 9th(1963), 10th(1962), 11th(1960), 11th(1964)
Play-off Goals - 2nd(1962), 3rd(1960), 4th(1964), 7th(1959)
Play-off Assists - 1st(1967), 8th(1963)
Namba said:
Lemaire was four times Top 5 in NHL Playoff points (1st: 1979, 3rd: 1977, 4th: 1973, 5th: 1971)
6x Top 10 in Playoffs Goals (1968 (3), 1971 (6), 1973 (6), 1977 (5), 1978 (8), 1979 (1))
6x Top 10 in Playoffs Assists (1968 (10), 1971 (7), 1973 (4), 1977 (3), 1978 (9), 1979 (3)
He also scored 3 playoff overtime goal in his career and is only one of five players to have scored two game winning clinching Stanley Cup goals.
Not much needs to be said about
Scott Stevens in the playoffs. He might be our second best playoff performer with a Conn Smythe in addition to captaining his team to 3 Stanley Cups.
Namba=[B said:
Middleton[/B] has 100 points in 114 career playoff games, including a monstrous 33 points in 17 games during 82-83.
During his big 1983 run, Middleton set the record for most points in a single playoff series with 19 against Buffalo.
Guy Lapointe shares the Canadiens playoff record of 25 goals by a defenseman with Larry Robinson, as well as being second all time in playoff points by a Habs blueliner.
Namba said:
Walsh was Stanley Cup Scoring Leader with 13 of his team's 20 goals (1911)
- 2nd In Stanley Cup Scoring (1910)
Cooney Weiland led the playoffs in points twice (including a first place finish in assists one year and goals another).
Namba said:
Darragh has two retro Conn Smythe and is known as clutch performer.
Ed Sandford has a retro Smythe (1953) where he led all scorers in the postseason (goals and points). The year prior he was 8th in points, 7th in goals and 10th in assists. A few years earlier he had another 8th in assists.
Namba said:
And don't forget, that despise being comparatively weak regular goalie, Smith is one of the best play-off goaltenders, who has Smythe too.
Jacques Plante has a retro Smythe (1960) and led the playoffs in save percentage 4 times. Oh yes, he also has 6 Cups.
All of that being said, just because it’s ATD playoffs certainly doesn’t mean that only playoff achievements should be used in evaluating teams – and I know that isn't the case, of course. We do like how our team stacks up in terms of playoff performers anyway though.