If goalies are 5/14 categories and you not having a pick in the first three rounds, you've gotta keep both Holtby and Dubnyk. You stand to lose way too much ground in those categories if you enter the draft with only one starter and don't even have a chance to get a second one til round 4 (by which point all the worthwhile exposed ones will be long gone).
What's your minimum starts per week? Maximum starts per night (IE, do you have one active goalie slot or two?) There are two big must-knows, especially with GA (I'm assuming fewer=better) being a category.
THIS
As soon as I saw the category spread and that you can keep 2 goalies, all other thoughts vanished. 35%+ of your categories decided by 2 players, you do not want one of those two players to be a backup goalie or Varlamov
Keep Dubnyk+Holtby and work from there.
Hedman + Klingberg are no brainers.
Benn, Kucherov and Draisaitl are pretty much locks.
Kessel vs Ehlers vs Gaudreau.
Kessel is a creampuff for Peripherals and is the oldest as he is about to turn 30. He just had his best point season since 2013-14 with 70 but lowest goal total at 23. Adds nothing to PIM's, Hits or Blocks. Just posted his lowest SOG since he was 20(not counting lockout half season). On the PP however, he buried the other 2
Gaudreau is also a creampuff for Peripherals. But is turning 24 so he is a consideration. He adds even less to Hits, PIM's and blocks than Kessel and he is not A SOG machine by any stretch. Under new coaching that is less offense oriented and with a season that saw injury, he still managed 18 goals and 61 points. Only 16 PPP.
Ehlers is a huge young up and comer. Age 21, playing alongside other high end talent his own age in Scheifele/Laine. 25 goals and 64 points with over 200 SOG and had more hits and blocks than both others combined(Although it is still not better than average). Only 12 PPP, but the entire Jets roster sucks on the PP. With a coaching change expect this number to rise big.
Other considerations, but not known commodities who could regress. Tkachuk and Granlund
Granlund I am not sold on staying at this level. Outlier year or breakout year? Still not contributing to PIM's or SOG meaningfully, but had decent hits and blocks to go with his 69 points. I would not risk him
Tkachuk. At 18 years old, showed himself to be a good peripheral contributorfor PIM's and hits, but not for SOG or Bks or PPP and had 48 points. I expect him to rise to 60 points at least this season. But risking a keeper spot on him? No. Its possible he can be redrafted in the 4th round
Really I think Ehlers is the guy to go with in that 8th spot. Age, rising superstar playing alongside other rising superstars. Gaudreau would be acceptable too, but I like Laine/Scheifele/Ehlers for years to come more than I like Gaudreau/Monahan/????