Value of: Josh Manson/Hampus Lindholm

[Crazydounut]

If Anaheim is looking to move one possibly both of these players who are both UFA's at the end of their deals and both are still top pairing guys, what would their value be?

(I'm thinking a 1st rounder and likely a top tier prospect or good young player but I am curious to see what the consensus is)

Click to read more...

 

[MMC]

I almost want us to trade Manson at this point just so this topic can stop being discussed. Manson gets moved for a severe overpayment only, and I don't see any scenario in which Lindholm gets moved either.

 

[WhatTheDuck]

Ducks need to lock Lindholm up long term. They've never drafted and developed a better Dman, which speaks to the odds of being able to replicate him any time soon. They have a great group of forward prospects, trading their top defenseman for magic beans is more likely to slow down the retool than ever help.

Manson is beloved by the Ducks, and he's their only right handed defenseman in the entire org signed beyond next season. I'm sure they'll listen to offers but it will take something really intriguing to pry him away.

Anaheim has a great prospect pool and some very good prime age pieces. They don't need to sell everything off for lottery tickets and completely start from scratch in order to get back to competing in the Pacific.

 

[Michael HOMERUNing]

Manson and Rakell for both 1sts and Necas

 

[d0rkwing]

Manson and Rakell for both 1sts and Necas

Done

 

[MMC]

Manson and Rakell for both 1sts and Necas

Gross, no way.

 

[Liferleafer]

I'm staying out of this one.

 

[Zegs2sendhelp]

Idk i think carolina has good assets to get manson if they wanted....

Lindholm likely cost more than a team would want to pay then add to that.

 

[Dr Johnny Fever]

I'm staying out of this one.

O'Dog, is that really you?

 

[Liferleafer]

O'Dog, is that really you?

Dam straight

 

[Dr Johnny Fever]

Dam straight

I knew it had to be either you or your mother. Who else would use that avatar?

 

[Liferleafer]

I knew it had to be either you or your mother. Who else would use that avatar?

Gotta up your self confidence my man.

 

[fmrdh]

Ehlers

 

[shortfuze]

I almost want us to trade Manson at this point just so this topic can stop being discussed. Manson gets moved for a severe overpayment only, and I don't see any scenario in which Lindholm gets moved either.

You could just stop reading the topic. Crazy idea, I know.

 

[d0rkwing]

something around Necas & Priskie for Manson & Rakell?

 

[DarthProbert]

I'm staying out of this one.

Dam straight

Gotta up your self confidence my man.

There's a difference between staying out of it and butting in but not contributing.

Plenty of "value of" Manson and Lindholm if you use the search funtion(HERESY!)

 

[Rec T]

They've never drafted and developed a better Dman, which speaks to the odds of being able to replicate him any time soon.

Just re-emphasizing this point as the Ducks have one of the better scouting depts in the league who have come up with some absolute gems over the years (more than just a 'you'd be really stupid to pass on this guy if he's available' kind of pick).

It's like J.P. Morgan talking about how much his yacht cost - "If you have to ask, you can't afford it..."

Oh, & just who is saying that Anaheim wants to move one or both of them, certainly not Anaheim?

 

[dracom]

something around Necas & Priskie for Manson & Rakell?

gross no.

necas is the minimum return for either one of manson or rakell. priskie is a nice piece, but not enough of an add.

 

[dracom]

Just re-emphasizing this point as the Ducks have one of the better scouting depts in the league who have come up with some absolute gems over the years (more than just a 'you'd be really stupid to pass on this guy if he's available' kind of pick).

It's like J.P. Morgan talking about how much his yacht cost - "If you have to ask, you can't afford it..."

Oh, & just who is saying that Anaheim wants to move one or both of them, certainly not Anaheim?

just other team's fans. it's already been reported that they aren't moving Lindholm or Manson.

 

[Baksfamous112]

From Montreal we could work a deal around Domi + a B level prospect or second round pick or straight up our first round pick if it’s between 6-10 for Lindholm.

 

[Rec T]

just other team's fans. it's already been reported that they aren't moving Lindholm or Manson.

That's what I figured.

And in the interests of fairness, I did glance right past the first word of the OP's post "If" which certainly changed the tone of the sentence.

 

[d0rkwing]

gross no.

necas is the minimum return for either one of manson or rakell. priskie is a nice piece, but not enough of an add.

Hence the “around” part. Lmao this board is something else with how personally y’all take some of these proposals. What if the highest 1st was added from Carolina?

 

[dracom]

From Montreal we could work a deal around Domi + a B level prospect or second round pick or straight up our first round pick if it’s between 6-10 for Lindholm.

don't see a need for Domi; we would have Getz, Henrique, Steel, Grant, Rowney and then Domi as our centers which is just too much plus he's a RFA needing a new contract which I don't think we are in a good position to give him.

Hence the “around” part. Lmao this board is something else with how personally y’all take some of these proposals. What if the highest 1st was added from Carolina?

Funny how took me saying no as a personal affront to you. And no, the 1st doesn't change anything. ducks aren't moving manson unless it's over-payment (this has already been reported) and Rakell is worth that original offer and the 1st on his own, but we also just don't need another center coming back.

 

[405Exit]

I almost want us to trade Manson at this point just so this topic can stop being discussed. Manson gets moved for a severe overpayment only, and I don't see any scenario in which Lindholm gets moved either.

Anaheim is trading everyone. Rakell! Lindholm! And Manson.

The fact I’ve had to endure since my sign up date on here by Ducks fans, and okay with mediocrity is ridiculous. Keeping this player, while trading this player, and going for this player because of this player. Is utter nonsense. It’s been years since they want to categorize it as, “re tool” by the fans on these boards. When do you understand as it’s a REBUILD???

Well guess what? If they were real Duck fans? They would have categorized this a couple years ago correctly.

Everyone is going for picks, and prospects like we should have done in the beginning.

 

[MMC]

Anaheim is trading everyone. Rakell! Lindholm! And Manson.

The fact I’ve had to endure since my sign up date on here by Ducks fans, and okay with mediocrity is ridiculous. Keeping this player, while trading this player, and going for this player because of this player. Is utter nonsense. It’s been years since they want to categorize it as, “re tool” by the fans on these boards. When do you understand as it’s a REBUILD???

Well guess what? If they were real Duck fans? They would have categorized this a couple years ago correctly.

Everyone is going for picks, and prospects like we should have done in the beginning.

Source?