Jose Theodore or CuJo?

[SeanMoneyHands]

Who was better?

Click to read more...

 

[rent free]

CuJo was way better. Theodore wrongfully robbed Iginla of the Hart in 2002.

 

[bobholly39]

Theodore's peak season is outstanding. Among the best ever for goalies. but outside of that Cujo take him in the long run.

 

[Weztex]

If the standards for goalies were the same than for forwards, Joseph would be a Hall of Famer.

CuJo was way better. Theodore wrongfully robbed Iginla of the Hart in 2002.

I never understood this assessment.

-The Habs made the playoff with only one player scoring over 45 points and with their captain missing 79 games because of cancer. Theodore posted a gigantic 931SV% and a 2.11 GAA.

-The Flames missed the playoff.

I'm actually surprised the vote was as close as it was.

 

[Nabrules]

Besides 2002, Theodore was just an average starter, easily CJ

 

[clunk]

This can't be a serious poll.

 

[Lebowski]

If the standards for goalies were the same than for forwards, Joseph would be a Hall of Famer.



I never understood this assessment.

-The Habs made the playoff with only one player scoring over 45 points and with their captain missing 79 games because of cancer. Theodore posted a gigantic 931SV% and a 2.11 GAA.

-The Flames missed the playoff.

I'm actually surprised the vote was as close as it was.

No kidding. Looking back at that Habs roster, it's pretty insane they made it to the playoffs.

Even ignoring the playoffs argument for the Hart, I'd give a clear edge to Théodore over Iginla if we're only looking at stats.

 

[rent free]

If the standards for goalies were the same than for forwards, Joseph would be a Hall of Famer.



I never understood this assessment.

-The Habs made the playoff with only one player scoring over 45 points and with their captain missing 79 games because of cancer. Theodore posted a gigantic 931SV% and a 2.11 GAA.

-The Flames missed the playoff.

I'm actually surprised the vote was as close as it was.

iginla led the league in goals and points with over 50 and 90 during the middle of the dead pick era.
theodore had a slightly above average record and the habs were a fringe playoff team. he didn't carry them anywhere far in the regular season. given the context, iginla's season was much more impressive.

 

[ESH]

iginla led the league in goals and points with over 50 and 90 during the middle of the dead pick era.
theodore had a slightly above average record and the habs were a fringe playoff team. he didn't carry them anywhere far in the regular season. given the context, iginla's season was much more impressive.

you might wanna give yourself some more context buddy. Iginla managed to carry the Flames all the way to finishing out of the playoffs.

 

[CanadienShark]

iginla led the league in goals and points with over 50 and 90 during the middle of the dead pick era.
theodore had a slightly above average record and the habs were a fringe playoff team. he didn't carry them anywhere far in the regular season. given the context, iginla's season was much more impressive.

I'm sorry, but what did Iginla lead his team to? If you're going to knock Theodore for not leading his team (he did... His team sucked), then you need to hold Iginla to the same standard. Both had statistically outstanding years. Both had crappy teams.

 

[spiny norman]

The lopsided result arrived quickly.