If they ever Waive Gelinas , i dont think we'll get that many replies in his thread. I for one wont care to see him claimed by another team , in fact i hope he will .
It wasn't the same for J.Malkin, that move came out of nowhere from the Avs and we are talking about somewhat of a fan favorite .
Gelinas was guilty of some egregious errors and poor overall play prior to being scratched the last couple of games. But I don't think the Avs are in a position to place him on waivers on the off chance that he would be claimed.
The Avs simply do not have enough NHL defenseman at the moment. As bad as Gelinas looked at times in the lineup, I would argue that Tyutin is actually worse. Tyutin is far from an NHL caliber defenseman at the moment. Against Chicago (on the Marian Hossa goal) and yesterday against Minnesota, he was an abject disaster.
On the Hossa goal, he had the angle and it should not have resulted in a partial breakaway. Yesterday, he took two very bad penalties in the first half of the game, had at least one unpressured, awful icing play, and he inexplicably stepped up in the neutral zone on a play that almost led to an odd man rush for the Wild.
At this point, Tyutin lacks NHL caliber skating, NHL caliber puck skills, and he is not compensating by making competent decisions on the ice. If he continues to be in the lineup for the Avs, he likely will make several plays every game (bad penalties, bad play with the puck, poor decision making and positional play) that could result in the Avs losing.
I can understand if the Avs have soured on Gelinas, but they also must realize that they can't have Tyutin in the lineup if he plays like he did the last couple of games. I wonder if they would consider bringing up someone like Siemens shortly as the sixth defenseman. I am not sure what the downside would be considering what we have seen from Gelinas and Tyutin.