I don't see why people are calling out the Oilers for 'doing this' to poor JJ. He started strong and then really didn't do much after that (just like last year).
If he was the only player here to show promise and fade away I'd say you were 100% right. Everyone who gets a chance to make the NHL shows promise. No one on the Oilers reaches their full potential. Guys like Harski and JJ who can dominate shifts should turn into reliable checkers who can play a regular 3rd or 4th line shift.
Guys like Brodziak and Glencross who swim upstream to actually develop here should be recognized for what they actually bring to a team and be retained long-term.
Everything the Oilers have touched has turned to crap here in the last ten years. They don't have a 100th overall draft pick that turned into an impact player on their roster. Their first round picks aren't impact players and their first overalls are at a 66% conversion rate for just becoming decent first line players.
I don't blame any 1 specific player for their own failure. When EVERY SINGLE PLAYER in an organization fails to develop that's a systemic failure, not 100 individual failures. If a high school with 1,000 students only gets 35 kids into universities and 50 of them end up in jail would you send your kid there with a reasonable expectation that they are on the path to success?
I'd want my kid to play for Chi, StL, Det, etc even though those teams have far less room on the current rosters for new players.