Thornton's career arc so far is eerily similar to that of Steve Yzerman.
maybe if you narrowly look at playoff circumstances they faced
and for Yzerman only a subset of his mid career playoff experiences
see the example of the 87 playoffs which he played great
more defensively than offensively too ive read
for those who oversimplistically bifurcate his career
they are otherwise quite different players
not to mention Thornton isnt in Stevie's class
It was at age 31 that Yzerman fully committed himself to being a two-way player that Scotty Bowman wanted him to be, and Detroit finally did get over the hump.
more like age 29...
Bowman changed the team style
after the early loss in 94
it was first on Yzerman to sell this shift to team D to his teammates
and he made the biggest personal sacrifice on the team to do it
Yzerman was a 2nd or 3rd checking line center in 95 and 96
his wingers at even strength were generally checkers
usually Bob Errey and Doug Brown and Darren McCarty
less so Sheppard and Ciccarelli (at even strength)
he was more deserving of the Selke than Feds those years
a lot larger percentage of his points came on the pp than before
as his even strength points plummeted because of his defensive role
(also due to injuries and age though)
he got his offensive first line job back only in 97
after Feds stopped scoring and Shanny arrived
One thing that should be said is that Yzerman had the luxury of having a dominant force like Fedorov to take some of the burden off him. Thornton gets a bad rap for his past playoffs with the Sharks. Go look at the rosters of the 2006, 2007, and 2008 Sharks. Until two years ago, Thornton was the Sharks' offense. He had crap for wingers and it allowed opposing teams to close on him with a double team knowing that no other forward could do anything unless he set them up. Thornton has had two truly bad playoff series as a Shark. The 2009 first round loss to Anaheim, and last year against Chicago. He has never been a "choker". I'd like to see what any other center in the league could do in the playoffs with the Sharks' supporting cast prior to 2009.
mostly agreed here
the perception of Thornton as a choker is generally overexaggerated
to the worst degree on hfboards but thats not surprising
people judge players by their numbers
and Thornton's stats are skewed by the 04 run where he was hurt
i thought he also played really well in 07 against the Wings
until my man Robert Lang scored that late tying game 4 goal :3
after that the Sharks just deflated Thornton no exception
but if not for clutch Lang Sharks prolly win the series
doubt they beat the Ducks but Thornton certainly looks better