Jaccob Slavin, Hampus Lindholm or Jacob Trouba

[ookhaab]

How would these three similar, defensive minded dmen rank?

Tableau Public SKATR advanced stats for each.

Click to read more...

 

[HyPnOtiK]

Lindholm
Slavin
Trouba

 

[SHANNYPLAN]

Lindholm

 

[VoluntaryDom]

Lindholm/Slavin

Trouba

...and you all know how high I am on Trouba.

Voted Lindholm.

 

[Morgs]

Lindholm
Slavin
Trouba

All top-20 defenseman, but there's a clear tier (imo) between the three.

 

[Snowman]

Trouba is clearly better than Slavin and very comparable to Lindholm. I took Trouba as he is RHD.

 

[Deam78]

Lindholm

Trouba/Slavin

 

[WhatTheDuck]

Lindholm
Slavin
Trouba

 

[tony d]

Lindholm
Trouba
Slavin

 

[firstemperor]

Lindholm
Trouba/Slavin IMO..hard to choose one or the other, depends on team needs. For the Leafs, I'd lean strongly towards Trouba because of the right shot. But if that weren't a factor, we could probably use Slavin a tad more otherwise.

 

[The Moose is Loose]

Slavin has more offensively, so I'll go with him

 

[780il]

Lindholm
Slavin


Trouba

Lindholm is a freaking stud and severely underrated. Same with Slavin. I actually think Trouba is a bit overrated he isnt really close to these guys imo. Slavin and Lindholm are better defensively and have more offensive upside.

 

[heretik27]

Ohh my, inb4 people show up with Trouba's 5on5 offensive stats.

 

[Paul4587]

Lindholm
Trouba
Slavin

 

[PhilJets]

Trouba


Lindholm Slavin

If he stays a Jet.

If not


Lindholm Slavin


.....


Trouba

 

[zeke]

Slavin for sure.

the only one who gets elite tough usage and He's awesome in it.

lindholm is probably third, as good as his fancy stats are, he plays by far the easiest minutes of this trio.

 

[zeke]

Last 2yrs

Slavin: ES 19:23 (A qoc), .97p60, .60p1/60, 53.7cf% (+2.4), 55.2xgf% (+5.1) / PP 0:46, 2.92p/60, 1.46p1/60 / PK 2:42
Lindholm: ES 18:23 (B+ qoc), .77p/60, .52p1/60, 54.2cf% (+6.4), 55.6xgf% (+8.0) / PP 1:49, 3.25p/60, 2.25p1/60 / PK 2:24
Trouba: ES 19:09 (A- qoc), 1.11p/60, .72p1/60, 50.5cf% (+0.1), 53.1xgf% (+2.0) / PP 1:35 2.33p/60, 1.00p1/60 / PK 2:46

yeah for me this is Slavin easily. toughest minutes, but very good offensive and possession numbers any way.

but on 2nd thought lindholm probably moves past trouba. trouba's minutes are somewhat tougher, but not enough to make up that massive possession difference.

lindholm has the smallest and easiest minutes, and the worst production, but those possession numbers are killer.

funny how all three stink on the PP.

 

[major major]

Last 2yrs

Slavin: ES 19:23 (A qoc), .97p60, .60p1/60, 53.7cf% (+2.4), 55.2xgf% (+5.1) / PP 0:46, 2.92p/60, 1.46p1/60 / PK 2:42
Lindholm: ES 18:23 (B+ qoc), .77p/60, .52p1/60, 54.2cf% (+6.4), 55.6xgf% (+8.0) / PP 1:49, 3.25p/60, 2.25p1/60 / PK 2:24
Trouba: ES 19:09 (A- qoc), 1.11p/60, .72p1/60, 50.5cf% (+0.1), 53.1xgf% (+2.0) / PP 1:35 2.33p/60, 1.00p1/60 / PK 2:46

yeah for me this is Slavin easily. toughest minutes, but very good offensive and possession numbers any way.

but on 2nd thought lindholm probably moves past trouba. trouba's minutes are somewhat tougher, but not enough to make up that massive possession difference.

lindholm has the smallest and easiest minutes, and the worst production, but those possession numbers are killer.

funny how all three stink on the PP.

Can you leave in the QoC numbers? Replacing them with letter grades obscures the variance.

 

[TheDoldrums]

Slavin. He's definitely underrated.

 

[zeke]

Can you leave in the QoC numbers? Replacing them with letter grades obscures the variance.

imo the numbers actually obscure the variance more. it's a big problem with the way QoC is treated and used/ignored imo.

 

[Critical13]

Slavin.

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

Interesting to view this thread today - I would think a remake of this poll would be a blowout for Slavin.

 

[Merrrlin]

Slavin for sure.

the only one who gets elite tough usage and He's awesome in it.

lindholm is probably third, as good as his fancy stats are, he plays by far the easiest minutes of this trio.

zeke nailed it

 

[BHD]

Slavin or Lindholm. Trouba isn’t at their level IMO.

 

[Sidney the Kidney]

Slavin
Lindholm
Trouba

In that order.

Edit: God damn it with people necrobumping old threads.