Proposal: Islanders-Edmonton

[Ctrain2k]

Counter

Halak 50% retained

For

4th

 

[Beautvillier]

No way do they do that. Hickeys garbage.

I remember there were Islander fans who were mad that Hall got Larsson because they thought they could have got Hall with Hickey.

while hickey is garbage, not a single isles fan thought we were getting taylor hall for him

 

[Starat327]

Once? Even if you hate Eberle , he's still miles better than Ryan Strome.

We could have kept Eberle and had Barzal who everyone seemed to want with that pick plus whoever we wanted with the 2nd. Those trades killed our ability to roll any secondary scoring outside of RNH

If by once you mean twice then yes.

The Reinhart trade was a hose job by NYI and Strome is an anchor compared to Eberle

Y'all should read the thread before responding. It was already acknowledged that I forgot about the Reinhart trade.

 

[Sheva7]

To Islanders---Talbot

To Edmonton---Hickey, Halak, and 2018 1st

Love it lol

Chiarelli wouldn't want the 1st tho. Would rather have Seidenberg lol

 

[Sparksrus3]

Dude its Chia. It would be Talbot for Halak straight up.

Take it easy . Straight up . Come on. You are silly

Talbot and a 2nd for Halak

 

[Jared Dunn]

It was hickey. It was in the r/newyorkislanders post-hall trade thread or somewhere around there. I'm trying to find it but the post is archived.

I don't think you'll find it because I don't think it exists but good luck

 

[The Moose is Loose]

while hickey is garbage, not a single isles fan thought we were getting taylor hall for him

It was hickey. It was on r/newyorkislanders. In the post-hall trade thread or a thread around that time. Im trying to find it but its an archived post and I don't know how to find archived posts.

 

[DingDongCharlie]

It was hickey. It was on r/newyorkislanders. In the post-hall trade thread or a thread around that time. Im trying to find it but its an archived post and I don't know how to find archived posts.

Even if one idiot thought and said that, the main player over and over being discussed was indeed Hamonic.

 

[The Moose is Loose]

Even if one idiot thought and said that, the main player over and over being discussed was indeed Hamonic.

That is true

 

[McSuper]

Counter

Halak 50% retained

For

4th

Halak for Russell straight up

 

[lakai17]

Send the Oil Aho

 

[WeRa]

To Islanders---Talbot

To Edmonton---Hickey, Halak, and 2018 1st

???? Why?