Little would likely still be there, they sign the unwanted free agents to this day, they may make a few playoff appearances, later on Buff would've likely signed with the Wild, Ladd might of signed for stupid money, Wheeler would've probably played on Pittsburgh, I don't know but those scenarios would likely happen. Oh, and Evander Kane gets a dumb contract from them and is there to this day. Oddly enough, I think Paul Maurice would get a temporary stint there. Bogosian gets traded in 2012. I think lots would be different. I think it makes Kovalchuk change his mind and sign that stupid contract that was offered to him before getting traded to NJ.
This is what I see them drafting throughout the years (in the first round anyway).
2011: Dougie Hamilton/Sean Couturier
2012: Nail Yakupov/Alex Galchenyuk
2013: Darnell Nurse/Seth Jones
2014: Nikolaj Ehlers/Michael Dal Colle
2015: Noah Hanifin/Timo Meier/Pavel Zacha
2016: Jesse Puljujarvi
But think half of them would leave.