BenchBrawl
Registered User
- Jul 26, 2010
- 30,907
- 13,718
Round 1 list
Players ranked highest overall on this list
Blair Russell at 34th
Odie Cleghorn at 35th
Eddie Oatman at 41st
Bert Russell at 66th
Players ranked lowest overall on this list
Frank McGee at 52nd
Bernie Morris at 68th
Players from our final Top 70 not ranked on this list
Harry Oliver
Carson Cooper
Bouse Hutton
Players unique to this list
none
Round 2 Voting Record
1 | Frank Nighbor |
2 | Cyclone Taylor |
3 | Newsy Lalonde |
4 | Sprague Cleghorn |
5 | Georges Vezina |
6 | Clint Benedict |
7 | Joe Malone |
8 | Cy Denneny |
9 | Russell Bowie |
10 | Eddie Gerard |
11 | Tommy Phillips |
12 | Hugh Lehman |
13 | Hod Stuart |
14 | Mickey MacKay |
15 | Georges Boucher |
16 | Frank Fredrickson |
17 | Babe Dye |
18 | Moose Johnson |
19 | Duke Keats |
20 | Lester Patrick |
21 | Harvey Pulford |
22 | Hap Holmes |
23 | Mike Grant |
24 | Bob McDougall |
25 | Harry Cameron |
26 | Percy Lesueur |
27 | Didier Pitre |
28 | Reg Noble |
29 | Weldy Young |
30 | Frank Foyston |
31 | Jack Walker |
32 | George Hay |
33 | Herb Gardiner |
34 | Blair Russell |
35 | Odie Cleghorn |
36 | Haviland Routh |
37 | Art Duncan |
38 | Ernie Russell |
39 | Art Ross |
40 | Alf Smith |
41 | Eddie Oatman |
42 | Tommy Smith |
43 | Joe Simpson |
44 | Punch Broadbent |
45 | Joe Hall |
46 | Jack Campbell |
47 | Gord Roberts |
48 | Dan Bain |
49 | Frank Patrick |
50 | Harry Hyland |
51 | Dolly Swift |
52 | Frank McGee |
53 | Si Griffis |
54 | Smokey Harris |
55 | Allan Cameron |
56 | Jack Darragh |
57 | Harry Westwick |
58 | Dickie Boon |
59 | Jack Adams |
60 | Tom Paton |
61 | Barney Stanley |
62 | Tommy Dunderdale |
63 | Paddy Moran |
64 | Harry Smith |
65 | Marty Walsh |
66 | Bert Russell |
67 | Graham Drinkwater |
68 | Bernie Morris |
69 | Harry Trihey |
70 | Lloyd Cook |
71 | Jack Armytage |
72 | Bobby Rowe |
73 | Riley Hern |
74 | Herb Jordan |
75 | Dubbie Kerr |
76 | Shirley Davidson |
77 | Jack Marshall |
78 | Hamby Shore |
79 | James Stewart |
80 | Dick Irvin |
Players ranked highest overall on this list
Blair Russell at 34th
Odie Cleghorn at 35th
Eddie Oatman at 41st
Bert Russell at 66th
Players ranked lowest overall on this list
Frank McGee at 52nd
Bernie Morris at 68th
Players from our final Top 70 not ranked on this list
Harry Oliver
Carson Cooper
Bouse Hutton
Players unique to this list
none
Round 2 Voting Record
| Vote 1 | Vote 2 | Vote 3 | Vote 4 | Vote 5 | Vote 6 | Vote 7 | Vote 8 | Vote 9 | Vote 10 | Vote 11 | Vote 12 | Vote 13 | Vote 14 |
| Nighbor | Malone | Lehman | Keats | Grant | Pitre | A. Smith | Walker | Noble | Go. Roberts | L. Cook | Oatman | Oatman | Oatman |
| Taylor | Gerard | H. Stuart | M. Johnson | Pulford | Lesueur | W. Young | Moran | Go.Roberts | Griffis | Oatman | Darragh | Darragh | Darragh |
| Lalonde | Phillips | Cy Denneny | MacKay | H. Cameron | Holmes | Simpson | J. Campbell | Hall | L. Cook | Darragh | Trihey | Boon | J. Adams |
| S. Cleghorn | Benedict | Fredrickson | Grant | Dye | Simpson | Bain | Tom. Smith | Irvin | H. Oliver | Routh | Swift | Trihey | Westwick |
| Bowie | Lehman | MacKay | Pulford | Pitre | E. Russell | Walker | Noble | MacDougall | Duncan | Trihey | Boon | Westwick | Hutton |
| Vezina | H. Stuart | Foyston | L. Patrick | Holmes | Bain | Moran | Go. Roberts | Griffis | Walsh | Broadbent | Westwick | J. Adams | D. Kerr |
| Gerard | Fredrickson | M.Johnson | Foyston | Lesueur | Ross | H. Gardiner | Hall | Dunderdale | Oatman | A. Cameron | J. Adams | D. Kerr | Shir. Davidson |
| Benedict | Cy Denneny | G. Boucher | Holmes | Simpson | Noble | Go. Roberts | Morris | F. Patrick | Darragh | J. Adams | D. Kerr | Stanley | Stanley |
| Malone | MacKay | L. Patrick | McGee | Morris | H. Gardiner | Noble | MacDougall | L.Cook | Routh | Swift | Cooper | Paton | Hern |
| Phillips | M. Johnson | Dye | Dye | Hay | Morris | Tom. Smith | Dunderdale | Duncan | Trihey | E. Russell | Stanley | Hutton | B. Russell |
Last edited:
