BenchBrawl
Registered User
- Jul 26, 2010
- 30,907
- 13,718
Round 1 list
Players ranked highest overall on this list
Eddie Gerard at 5th
Georges Boucher at 10th
Jack Walker at 23rd
Herb Gardiner at 25th (tied with 2 others)
Si Griffis at 40th
Harry Hyland at 43rd
Harry Smith at 55th
Goldie Prodgers at 57th
Cully Wilson at 59th
Jimmy Gardner at 63rd
Players ranked lowest overall on this list
Georges Vézina at 8th (tied with 1 other)
Art Ross at 60th
Riley Hern at 76th
Smokey Harris at 77th
Players from our final Top 70 not ranked on this list
Tom Paton
Bouse Hutton
Jack Adams
Allan Cameron
Players unique to this list
none
Round 2 Voting Record
1 | Frank Nighbor |
2 | Cyclone Taylor |
3 | Newsy Lalonde |
4 | Sprague Cleghorn |
5 | Eddie Gerard |
6 | Joe Malone |
7 | Russell Bowie |
8 | Georges Vezina |
9 | Clint Benedict |
10 | Georges Boucher |
11 | Cy Denneny |
12 | Tommy Phillips |
13 | Frank Fredrickson |
14 | Mickey MacKay |
15 | Hod Stuart |
16 | Moose Johnson |
17 | Harry Cameron |
18 | Dick Irvin |
19 | Frank Foyston |
20 | Hugh Lehman |
21 | Duke Keats |
22 | Lester Patrick |
23 | Jack Walker |
24 | Didier Pitre |
25 | Herb Gardiner |
26 | Reg Noble |
27 | Hap Holmes |
28 | Tommy Smith |
29 | Babe Dye |
30 | Harvey Pulford |
31 | George Hay |
32 | Bernie Morris |
33 | Harry Oliver |
34 | Jack Marshall |
35 | Tommy Dunderdale |
36 | Ernie Russell |
37 | Weldy Young |
38 | Gord Roberts |
39 | Joe Simpson |
40 | Si Griffis |
41 | Joe Hall |
42 | Alf Smith |
43 | Harry Hyland |
44 | Lloyd Cook |
45 | Dan Bain |
46 | Eddie Oatman |
47 | Jack Darragh |
48 | Frank McGee |
49 | Percy Lesueur |
50 | Mike Grant |
51 | Bob McDougall |
52 | Punch Broadbent |
53 | Bobby Rowe |
54 | Odie Cleghorn |
55 | Harry Smith |
56 | Paddy Moran |
57 | Goldie Prodgers |
58 | Haviland Routh |
59 | Cully Wilson |
60 | Art Ross |
61 | Harry Westwick |
62 | Carson Cooper |
63 | Jimmy Gardner |
64 | Art Duncan |
65 | Marty Walsh |
66 | Blair Russell |
67 | Dolly Swift |
68 | Jack Laviolette |
69 | Graham Drinkwater |
70 | Frank Patrick |
71 | Dickie Boon |
72 | Scotty Davidson |
73 | Jack Campbell |
74 | Rusty Crawford |
75 | Dubbie Kerr |
76 | Riley Hern |
77 | Smokey Harris |
78 | Harry Trihey |
79 | Harry Watson |
80 | Herb Jordan |
Players ranked highest overall on this list
Eddie Gerard at 5th
Georges Boucher at 10th
Jack Walker at 23rd
Herb Gardiner at 25th (tied with 2 others)
Si Griffis at 40th
Harry Hyland at 43rd
Harry Smith at 55th
Goldie Prodgers at 57th
Cully Wilson at 59th
Jimmy Gardner at 63rd
Players ranked lowest overall on this list
Georges Vézina at 8th (tied with 1 other)
Art Ross at 60th
Riley Hern at 76th
Smokey Harris at 77th
Players from our final Top 70 not ranked on this list
Tom Paton
Bouse Hutton
Jack Adams
Allan Cameron
Players unique to this list
none
Round 2 Voting Record
| Vote 1 | Vote 2 | Vote 3 | Vote 4 | Vote 5 | Vote 6 | Vote 7 | Vote 8 | Vote 9 | Vote 10 | Vote 11 | Vote 12 | Vote 13 | Vote 14 |
| Nighbor | Gerard | Fredrickson | H. Cameron | H. Cameron | Walker | Walker | Walker | Irvin | Go. Roberts | J. Marshall | Darragh | Darragh | Darragh |
| Taylor | Malone | H. Cameron | L. Patrick | Foyston | Holmes | W. Young | Moran | Hall | Walsh | Darragh | Oatman | Oatman | Oatman |
| Lalonde | Fredrickson | L. Patrick | MacKay | Walker | Pitre | Simpson | Noble | Noble | H. Oliver | Oatman | O. Cleghorn | Boon | Westwick |
| S. Cleghorn | Benedict | G. Boucher | M. Johnson | Pulford | Hay | Bain | Tom. Smith | MacDougall | J. Marshall | E. Russell | Boon | O. Cleghorn | J. Adams |
| Bowie | Phillips | Lehman | Keats | Pitre | Ross | Noble | Morris | H. Oliver | Griffis | O. Cleghorn | Westwick | Westwick | O. Cleghorn |
| Gerard | L. Patrick | H. Stuart | Foyston | Holmes | Noble | Moran | H. Gardiner | Go.Roberts | Oatman | Hyland | Swift | Hyland | Hyland |
| Malone | G. Boucher | MacKay | Pulford | Hay | Simpson | A. Smith | Hall | J. Marshall | E. Russell | Westwick | Hyland | Hern | Shir. Davidson |
| Vezina | Lehman | M.Johnson | Pitre | Ross | Bain | H. Gardiner | H. Oliver | Dunderdale | Hyland | A. Cameron | Hern | J. Adams | B. Russell |
| Benedict | H. Stuart | Foyston | McGee | Noble | H. Gardiner | Tom. Smith | Go. Roberts | Walsh | Duncan | Broadbent | D. Kerr | Trihey | Hern |
| Phillips | MacKay | Cy Denneny | Hay | Dye | Tom.Smith | Morris | MacDougall | F. Patrick | Darragh | Routh | J. Adams | D. Kerr | Hutton |
