HockeyRulez's GM Game #2 Rate a Team

[donghabs98]

]
HockeyRulez's GM Game #2​

This is rate a team

if you want your team to be rated by other GMs post your roster here
Other GM's rating teams please use this format

Team Being Rated

Storng points

Weakness

What is it missing

Overall Grade



example

Team Being Rated


Storng points
Depth at winger

Weakness
Defense and Goaltending

What is it missing
top line winger

Overall Grade
B+

Please be respectful
example

your team sucks
it lacks everything
a big fat F

none of that

also be honest that would help a lot and that is the only way rating a team can work[/CENTER]

Click to read more...

 

[Evgeni Giroux]

FORWARDS
Tyler Ennis ($0.875m) / Ryan Getzlaf ($5.325m) / Drew Stafford ($4.000m)
Thomas Vanek ($7.142m) / Derick Brassard ($3.200m) / Jason Pominville ($5.300m)
Luke Adam ($0.875m) / Jarret Stoll ($3.600m) / Brad Boyes ($4.000m)
Nathan Gerbe ($1.433m) / Paul Gaustad ($2.300m) / Chris Neil ($2.000m)
/ / Patrick Kaleta ($0.907m)

DEFENSEMEN
Robyn Regehr ($4.020m) / Tyler Myers ($5.500m)
Andrej Sekera ($2.750m) / Christian Ehrhoff ($4.000m)
Brayden McNabb ($0.900m) / Mike Weber ($0.950m)

GOALTENDERS
Jhonas Enroth ($0.675m) / Evgeni Nabokov ($0.570m)

CAPGEEK.COM TOTALS (follow @capgeek on Twitter)
(these totals are compiled without the bonus cushion)
SALARY CAP: $64,300,000; CAP PAYROLL: $60,323,690; BONUSES: $297,500
CAP SPACE (21-man roster): $3,976,310

 

[OrangeZebra]

Captain: John Tavares
Asst. Captain: Kyle Okposo
Asst. Captain: Mark Streit

Martin Havlat ($5.000m) / John Tavares ($5.500m) / Corey Perry ($5.325m)
Matt Moulson ($3.133m) / Joshua Bailey ($1.050m) / Kyle Okposo ($2.800m)
Wojtek Wolski ($3.800m) / Frans Nielsen ($0.525m) / Michael Grabner ($3.000m)
Matt Martin ($0.852m) / David Ullstrom ($0.891m) / Brian Rolston ($5.062m)
*Jay Pandolfo ($1.400m)

Mark Streit ($4.100m) / Travis Hamonic ($0.875m)
Andrew MacDonald ($0.550m) / Roman Hamrlik ($3.500m)
Milan Jurcina ($1.600m) / Eric Brewer ($3.850m)
*Steve Staios ($1.600m)
*Mike Mottau ($0.800m)

Al Montoya ($0.601m) / Mathieu Garon ($1.300m)

 

[caps4cup]

Niño Niederreiter-Saku Koivu-Teemu Selanne
Niklas Hagman-Sam Gagner-Cody Hodgson
Magnus Paajarvi-Brayden Schenn-Linus Omark
Justin Abdelkader-Nick Bonino-Matt Beleskey

Lubomir Visnovsky-Luca Sbisa
Francois Beauchemin-Corey Potter
Sheldon Brookbank-Brendan Smith
Nate Guenin

Jonathan Bernier
Nikolai Khabibulin

Scratches - Jason Blake, Rod Pelley, George Parros



Untouchable:
Brayden Schenn
Cody Hodgson
Niño Niederreiter
Jonathan Bernier

Available:
Lubomir Visnovsky
Francois Beauchemin
Nikolai Khabibulin
Accepting offers on everyone except untouchables, but some are harder to get than others.

Looking for:
Young players
Picks
Prospects

Draft Picks (2012):
Anaheim 1st
NYI 1st
Edmonton 1st
Detroit 1st
Philadelphia 1st
NYI 2nd
Edmonton 2nd
Anaheim 4th


Projected 2012-2013 Roster

Niño Niedderreiter-Brayden Schenn-Cody Hodgson
Magnus Paajarvi-Ryan Strome-Sam Gagner
Linus Omark-Emerson Etem-Kyle Palmieri
Justin Abdelkader-Nick Bonino-Devante Smith-Pelly


Lubomir Visnovsky-Oscar Klefbom
Francois Beauchemin-Corey Potter
Brendan Smith-Luca Sbisa

Jonathan Bernier
Nikolai Khabibulin

 

[Evgeni Giroux]

Captain: John Tavares
Asst. Captain: Kyle Okposo
Asst. Captain: Mark Streit

CAPGEEK.COM CAP CALCULATOR

FORWARDS
Martin Havlat ($5.000m) / John Tavares ($5.500m) / Corey Perry ($5.325m)
Matt Moulson ($3.133m) / Joshua Bailey ($1.050m) / Kyle Okposo ($2.800m)
Wojtek Wolski ($3.800m) / Frans Nielsen ($0.525m) / Michael Grabner ($3.000m)
Matt Martin ($0.852m) / David Ullstrom ($0.891m) / Brian Rolston ($5.062m)
*Jay Pandolfo ($1.400m)

DEFENSEMEN
Mark Streit ($4.100m) / Travis Hamonic ($0.875m)
Andrew MacDonald ($0.550m) / Roman Hamrlik ($3.500m)
Milan Jurcina ($1.600m) / Eric Brewer ($3.850m)
*Steve Staios ($1.600m)
*Mike Mottau ($0.800m)

GOALTENDERS
Al Montoya ($0.601m) / Mathieu Garon ($1.300m)

Looks alot better, need a 2 center a couple d-man and an upgrade in goaltending, looks like you should be in the mix for a playoff spot

 

[OrangeZebra]

FORWARDS
Tyler Ennis ($0.875m) / Ryan Getzlaf ($5.325m) / Drew Stafford ($4.000m)
Thomas Vanek ($7.142m) / Derick Brassard ($3.200m) / Jason Pominville ($5.300m)
Luke Adam ($0.875m) / Jarret Stoll ($3.600m) / Brad Boyes ($4.000m)
Nathan Gerbe ($1.433m) / Paul Gaustad ($2.300m) / Chris Neil ($2.000m)
/ / Patrick Kaleta ($0.907m)

DEFENSEMEN
Robyn Regehr ($4.020m) / Tyler Myers ($5.500m)
Andrej Sekera ($2.750m) / Christian Ehrhoff ($4.000m)
Brayden McNabb ($0.900m) / Mike Weber ($0.950m)

GOALTENDERS
Jhonas Enroth ($0.675m) / Evgeni Nabokov ($0.570m)

CAPGEEK.COM TOTALS (follow @capgeek on Twitter)
(these totals are compiled without the bonus cushion)
SALARY CAP: $64,300,000; CAP PAYROLL: $60,323,690; BONUSES: $297,500
CAP SPACE (21-man roster): $3,976,310

Definitely an improvement in some areas, but not in others.

Offense- A
Defense- A
Goaltending- B-

Team Being Rated: Sabres

Strong points:
-Defense
-1st 2 offensive lines

Weakness:
-Questionable goaltending

What is it missing:
-proven/steady vet goalie (i.e. Niemi, Quick)

Overall Grade: A-

 

[JGardiner51]

Philadelphia Flyers Roster



Captain: Claude Giroux
Assistants: Danny Briere, Kimmo Timmonen, Niklas Kronwall

Roster


Scott Hartnell (4.2M) Claude Giroux (3.75M) Danny Briere (6.5M)
Chris Stewart (2.875M) Ryan Kesler (5M) Matt Read (0.9M)
Darren Helm (0.9125M) Mikhail Grabovski (2.9M) Wayne Simmonds (1.75)
Jody Shelley (1.1M) Max Talbot (1.75) Harry Zolniercyk (0.9M)

Kimmo Timonen (6.333M) Braydon Coburn (4.5M)
Matt Carle (3.437M) Niklas Kronwall (3M)
Carl Gunnarson (1.325M) Ian White (2.875M)

Ilya Bryzgalov (5.6667M) Corey Schneider (0.9M)

Cap Space: 3.7258M

 

[OrangeZebra]

Niño Niederreiter-Saku Koivu-Teemu Selanne
Niklas Hagman-Sam Gagner-Cody Hodgson
Magnus Paajarvi-Brayden Schenn-Linus Omark
Justin Abdelkader-Nick Bonino-Matt Beleskey

Lubomir Visnovsky-Luca Sbisa
Francois Beauchemin-Corey Potter
Sheldon Brookbank-Brendan Smith
Nate Guenin

Jonathan Bernier
Nikolai Khabibulin

Scratches - Jason Blake, Rod Pelley, George Parros



Untouchable:
Brayden Schenn
Cody Hodgson
Niño Niederreiter
Jonathan Bernier

Available:
Lubomir Visnovsky
Francois Beauchemin
Nikolai Khabibulin
Accepting offers on everyone except untouchables, but some are harder to get than others.

Looking for:
Young players
Picks
Prospects

Draft Picks (2012):
Anaheim 1st
NYI 1st
Edmonton 1st
Detroit 1st
Philadelphia 1st
NYI 2nd
Edmonton 2nd
Anaheim 4th


Projected 2012-2013 Roster

Niño Niedderreiter-Brayden Schenn-Cody Hodgson
Magnus Paajarvi-Ryan Strome-Sam Gagner
Linus Omark-Emerson Etem-Kyle Palmieri
Justin Abdelkader-Nick Bonino-Devante Smith-Pelly


Lubomir Visnovsky-Oscar Klefbom
Francois Beauchemin-Corey Potter
Brendan Smith-Luca Sbisa

Jonathan Bernier
Nikolai Khabibulin

Definitely a top 5 team in 5 or so years if ALL of these prospects reach their full potential


Team Being Rated:

Strong points:
-HUGE prospect depth

Weakness:
-prospect:veteran ratio
-unproven prospects

What is it missing:
-Time for prospects to mature

Overall Grade: B-

Offense: B
Defense: C+
Goaltending: B-

 

[OrangeZebra]

Captain: Claude Giroux
Assistants: Danny Briere, Kimmo Timmonen, Niklas Kronwall

Roster


Scott Hartnell (4.2M) Claude Giroux (3.75M) Danny Briere (6.5M)
Chris Stewart (2.875M) Ryan Kesler (5M) Matt Read (0.9M)
Darren Helm (0.9125M) Mikhail Grabovski (2.9M) Wayne Simmonds (1.75)
Jody Shelley (1.1M) Max Talbot (1.75) Harry Zolniercyk (0.9M)

Kimmo Timonen (6.333M) Braydon Coburn (4.5M)
Matt Carle (3.437M) Niklas Kronwall (3M)
Carl Gunnarson (1.325M) Ian White (2.875M)

Ilya Bryzgalov (5.6667M) Corey Schneider (0.9M)

Cap Space: 3.7258M

Team Being Rated:

Strong points:
-Great Center depth
-Strong goaltending

Weakness:
-Scoring wingers
-Aging stud d-men (Kronwall, Kimmo)

What is it missing:
-young defensemen

Overall Grade: B+

Offense- B+
Defense- B
Goaltending- A

 

[donghabs98]

FORWARDS
Alexander Ovechkin- Nicklas Backstrom- Alexander Semin
Shane Doan- Brooks Laich- Alex Tanguay
Joel Ward- Marcus Johansson- Troy Brouwer
Tim Jackman- Jeff Halpern- Jason Chimera

DEFENSEMEN
Mike Green-Dennis Wideman
John Carlson- Karl Alzner
Brent Clark-Scott Hannan
Dmitri Orlov

GOALTENDERS
Michal Neuvirth
Tomas Vokoun​

 

[JGardiner51]

Captain: John Tavares
Asst. Captain: Kyle Okposo
Asst. Captain: Mark Streit

Martin Havlat ($5.000m) / John Tavares ($5.500m) / Corey Perry ($5.325m)
Matt Moulson ($3.133m) / Joshua Bailey ($1.050m) / Kyle Okposo ($2.800m)
Wojtek Wolski ($3.800m) / Frans Nielsen ($0.525m) / Michael Grabner ($3.000m)
Matt Martin ($0.852m) / David Ullstrom ($0.891m) / Brian Rolston ($5.062m)
*Jay Pandolfo ($1.400m)

Mark Streit ($4.100m) / Travis Hamonic ($0.875m)
Andrew MacDonald ($0.550m) / Roman Hamrlik ($3.500m)
Milan Jurcina ($1.600m) / Eric Brewer ($3.850m)
*Steve Staios ($1.600m)
*Mike Mottau ($0.800m)

Al Montoya ($0.601m) / Mathieu Garon ($1.300m)

Offense: A- I don't know how well two shoot first stars would be togeather
Defense: B Could use more depth
Goaltending: B- Montoya isn't proven yet neither is Garon

Overall: B/B+ I like how you improved the team. Good Job

 

[donghabs98]

Captain: John Tavares
Asst. Captain: Kyle Okposo
Asst. Captain: Mark Streit

Martin Havlat ($5.000m) / John Tavares ($5.500m) / Corey Perry ($5.325m)
Matt Moulson ($3.133m) / Joshua Bailey ($1.050m) / Kyle Okposo ($2.800m)
Wojtek Wolski ($3.800m) / Frans Nielsen ($0.525m) / Michael Grabner ($3.000m)
Matt Martin ($0.852m) / David Ullstrom ($0.891m) / Brian Rolston ($5.062m)
*Jay Pandolfo ($1.400m)

Mark Streit ($4.100m) / Travis Hamonic ($0.875m)
Andrew MacDonald ($0.550m) / Roman Hamrlik ($3.500m)
Milan Jurcina ($1.600m) / Eric Brewer ($3.850m)
*Steve Staios ($1.600m)
*Mike Mottau ($0.800m)

Al Montoya ($0.601m) / Mathieu Garon ($1.300m)

Team Being Rated
NYI

Storng points

Top 6-very strong

Weakness

goaltending

What is it missing

True number 1 goalie


Offense A
Defense B
Goaltending C
Overall Grade A-

 

[Dr John Carlson]

Burrows--Datsyuk--Franzen
Bertuzzi--Zetterberg--Parenteau
Cleary--Pahlsson--Holmstrom
Miller--Galiardi--Winnik

Lidstrom--Fowler
B.Stuart--Gleason
Ericsson--Meszaros

Howard
Conklin

 

[KarlssonsGroin]

sedin-sedin-raymond
booth-roy-JVR
higgins-malhotra-hansen
lappierre-couturier-kassian

hedman-edler
bieksa-hamhuis
ballard-salo

lulongo
rolston

 

[Evgeni Giroux]

Burrows--Datsyuk--Franzen
Bertuzzi--Zetterberg--Parenteau
Cleary--Pahlsson--Holmstrom
Miller--Galiardi--Winnik

Lidstrom--Fowler
B.Stuart--Gleason
Ericsson--Meszaros

Howard
Conklin

Offense

Great Centers, very average wingers, not great 4th line B


Defence

Easily one of the best A+

Goaltenting B++

 

[JGardiner51]

sedin-sedin-raymond
booth-roy-JVR
higgins-malhotra-hansen
lappierre-couturier-kassian

hedman-edler
bieksa-hamhuis
ballard-salo

lulongo
rolston

Offense:A- Sedins...
Defense: A I like the top pairing
Goaltending: A- If Lou plays the way he can your set

Overall: A Very Solid Roster

 

[caps4cup]

Captain: John Tavares
Asst. Captain: Kyle Okposo
Asst. Captain: Mark Streit

Martin Havlat ($5.000m) / John Tavares ($5.500m) / Corey Perry ($5.325m)
Matt Moulson ($3.133m) / Joshua Bailey ($1.050m) / Kyle Okposo ($2.800m)
Wojtek Wolski ($3.800m) / Frans Nielsen ($0.525m) / Michael Grabner ($3.000m)
Matt Martin ($0.852m) / David Ullstrom ($0.891m) / Brian Rolston ($5.062m)
*Jay Pandolfo ($1.400m)

Mark Streit ($4.100m) / Travis Hamonic ($0.875m)
Andrew MacDonald ($0.550m) / Roman Hamrlik ($3.500m)
Milan Jurcina ($1.600m) / Eric Brewer ($3.850m)
*Steve Staios ($1.600m)
*Mike Mottau ($0.800m)

Al Montoya ($0.601m) / Mathieu Garon ($1.300m)

Team Being Rated

NYI

Storng points

Great first line
Great top pair

Weakness

Bottom 4D
Goalie
Depth Forwards

What is it missing

2C
2nd line wing
2 top 4D
#1 goalie


Overall Grade


B+

It looks like I said your team is missing alot but when I say this, I think if you get these pieces you could win a cup. The good thing is you have 3 great forwards and 2 great d to build on and you don't need anything major. I'd also consider moving Perry to the 2nd line for depth purposes.

 

[caps4cup]

FORWARDS
Alexander Ovechkin- Nicklas Backstrom- Alexander Semin
Shane Doan- Brooks Laich- Alex Tanguay
Joel Ward- Marcus Johansson- Troy Brouwer
Tim Jackman- Jeff Halpern- Jason Chimera

DEFENSEMEN
Mike Green-Dennis Wideman
John Carlson- Karl Alzner
Brent Clark-Scott Hannan
Dmitri Orlov

GOALTENDERS
Michal Neuvirth
Tomas Vokoun​

This is what I posted in the chat...

IMO you need a 2C and a top 4 Dman. Also spread out your offense IMO... I'd make the lines:

OV-Backstrom-Brouwer
Tanguay-_____-Doan
Laich-Johansson-Semin
4th line

Also you need a DFD to play with Green, and then make Hannan-Wideman your 3rd pair. You'd then have 3 amazing lines, and 3 great pairs. P.S. Beauchemin would look great with Green

 

[KesselLooksLikeRadar*]

FORWARDS
Colin Wilson ($1.725m) / Jeff Carter ($5.273m) / Patrick Kane ($6.300m)
Martin Erat ($4.500m) / David Legwand ($4.500m) / Craig Smith ($0.715m)
Dustin Penner ($4.250m) / Mike Fisher ($4.200m) / Nick Foligno ($1.200m)
Arron Asham ($0.775m) / Jerred Smithson ($0.800m) / Jordin Tootoo ($1.250m)
/ Matt Halischuk ($0.712m)

DEFENSEMEN
Douglas Murray ($2.500m) / Shea Weber ($7.500m)
Niklas Hjalmarsson ($3.500m) / Jonathon Blum ($0.941m)
Roman Josi ($1.000m) / Kevin Klein ($1.350m)
Bryan McCabe ($0.525m) / Ben Lovejoy ($0.550m

GOALTENDERS
Pekka Rinne ($3.400m) / Anders Lindback ($0.875m)

Prepares for D grades

P.S: Take note when you look at this team, I didn't completely sell away my future. In fact, you could argue I BOLSTERED my future through smart asset management (See Bouillon and Gragnani trades). I didn't want to stray too far from what Nashville does best, and that is have a constant stream of prospects

 

[donghabs98]

This is what I posted in the chat...

IMO you need a 2C and a top 4 Dman. Also spread out your offense IMO... I'd make the lines:

OV-Backstrom-Brouwer
Tanguay-_____-Doan
Laich-Johansson-Semin
4th line

Also you need a DFD to play with Green, and then make Hannan-Wideman your 3rd pair. You'd then have 3 amazing lines, and 3 great pairs. P.S. Beauchemin would look great with Green

and it so has it you have him

 

[Evgeni Giroux]

FORWARDS
Colin Wilson ($1.725m) / Jeff Carter ($5.273m) / Patrick Kane ($6.300m)
Martin Erat ($4.500m) / David Legwand ($4.500m) / Craig Smith ($0.715m)
Dustin Penner ($4.250m) / Mike Fisher ($4.200m) / Nick Foligno ($1.200m)
Arron Asham ($0.775m) / Jerred Smithson ($0.800m) / Jordin Tootoo ($1.250m)
/ Matt Halischuk ($0.712m)

DEFENSEMEN
Douglas Murray ($2.500m) / Shea Weber ($7.500m)
Niklas Hjalmarsson ($3.500m) / Jonathon Blum ($0.941m)
Roman Josi ($1.000m) / Kevin Klein ($1.350m)
Bryan McCabe ($0.525m) / Ben Lovejoy ($0.550m

GOALTENDERS
Pekka Rinne ($3.400m) / Anders Lindback ($0.875m)

Prepares for D grades

Rate My team Please

fowards A

Defence B+

Goaltending A

very soild overall team and should be right in the mix

 

[caps4cup]

and it so has it you have him

That's why I said PS but regardless if it's him, a Dman in that mold is what you need for Green. He and Wideman don't make good partners.

 

[donghabs98]

FORWARDS
Colin Wilson ($1.725m) / Jeff Carter ($5.273m) / Patrick Kane ($6.300m)
Martin Erat ($4.500m) / David Legwand ($4.500m) / Craig Smith ($0.715m)
Dustin Penner ($4.250m) / Mike Fisher ($4.200m) / Nick Foligno ($1.200m)
Arron Asham ($0.775m) / Jerred Smithson ($0.800m) / Jordin Tootoo ($1.250m)
/ Matt Halischuk ($0.712m)

DEFENSEMEN
Douglas Murray ($2.500m) / Shea Weber ($7.500m)
Niklas Hjalmarsson ($3.500m) / Jonathon Blum ($0.941m)
Roman Josi ($1.000m) / Kevin Klein ($1.350m)
Bryan McCabe ($0.525m) / Ben Lovejoy ($0.550m

GOALTENDERS
Pekka Rinne ($3.400m) / Anders Lindback ($0.875m)

Prepares for D grades

no a big fat F

Team Being Rated

NSH

Storng points

offense-i love it

Weakness
cant think of any but maybe a C

What is it missing
top line defensemen for weber

Overall Grade

A-

 

[KesselLooksLikeRadar*]

FORWARDS
Tyler Ennis ($0.875m) / Ryan Getzlaf ($5.325m) / Drew Stafford ($4.000m)
Thomas Vanek ($7.142m) / Derick Brassard ($3.200m) / Jason Pominville ($5.300m)
Luke Adam ($0.875m) / Jarret Stoll ($3.600m) / Brad Boyes ($4.000m)
Nathan Gerbe ($1.433m) / Paul Gaustad ($2.300m) / Chris Neil ($2.000m)
/ / Patrick Kaleta ($0.907m)

DEFENSEMEN
Robyn Regehr ($4.020m) / Tyler Myers ($5.500m)
Andrej Sekera ($2.750m) / Christian Ehrhoff ($4.000m)
Brayden McNabb ($0.900m) / Mike Weber ($0.950m)

GOALTENDERS
Jhonas Enroth ($0.675m) / Evgeni Nabokov ($0.570m)

CAPGEEK.COM TOTALS (follow @capgeek on Twitter)
(these totals are compiled without the bonus cushion)
SALARY CAP: $64,300,000; CAP PAYROLL: $60,323,690; BONUSES: $297,500
CAP SPACE (21-man roster): $3,976,310

Strong points

Great centres
Good depth on D

Weakness

Goalie. Goalie. Goalie.
Regehr is not a good match with Myers
First line winger

What is missing
Myers partner
Top line winger
Goalie

Overall
B-. Probably a B once you get a goalie (Perhaps more depending on the quality)

 

[Evgeni Giroux]

Strong points

Great centres
Good depth on D

Weakness

Goalie. Goalie. Goalie.
Regehr is not a good match with Myers
First line winger

What is missing
Myers partner
Top line winger
Goalie

Overall
B-. Probably a B once you get a goalie (Perhaps more depending on the quality)

Vanek, pominville? Agree with rest for the most part