I've been on the Reinhart wagon all year, but like R-Pax, I'm getting to the point of being happy with either. I like a lot of what I hear about SB, but I get worried thinking about the physical skilled forwards and their seemingly higher injury propensity. I'd rather have a slightly lesser player in the lineup for 80 games than a slightly better for 60.
That said, I'm going with Bennett because his game translates better to the wing, imo, and I want him playing with McDavid on the top line while Eichel can center line 2.