HF Habs: HFHabs 2020 Prospect Rankings #11

[Treb]

1. Alexander Romanov (50.0%) (+4)
2. Cole Caufield (85.4%) (-)
3. Mattias Norlinder (43.9%) (+9)
4. Kaiden Guhle (48.1%) (NA)
5. Cayden Primeau (84.6%) (+1)
6. Ryan Poehling (47.8%) (-5)
7. Jordan Harris (28.9%) (+3)
8. Jan Mysak (41.2%) (NA)
9. Josh Brook (27.5% , Tiebreaker 68.5 %) (-5)
10. Jayden Struble (36.5%, Tiebreaker 56.8%) (-2)

This one should be fast.

If you want to influence who is next to be added, please say who should be added next.

Prospects to be put on voting list (current order):
Khisatmudinov
McNiven
Gorniak
Dichow
Pitlick
Vejdemo
Harvey-Pinard
Gordin
G. Olofsson
Leskinen
Dauphin
LeGuerrier
Demchenko
Verbeek
Alain
Pezzetta
Ruscheinski
Henriksson

2019 ranking: HFHabs 2019 Prospect Rankings

Current awards:
AINEC Award: 2. Cole Caufield (85.4%)
Tough Choice Award: 9. Josh Brook (27.5% , Tie breaker 68.5 %)
Biggest Riser: 3. Mattias Norlinder (+9)
Biggest Faller: 6. Ryan Poehling (-5)/9. Josh Brook (-5)
Jumped The Draft Award: Jan Mysak (+1)
Drafted At The Wrong Spot Award: Luke Tuch (-1?)
Undrafted Star: ?
Late round gem: 5. Cayden Primeau (7th round)
Mike Cichy Trophy: ?

Click to read more...

 

[Roadhouse]

Sean Farrell, again and again. I'll be a believer in his mini-Suzuki set of tools and hint of Gallagher attitude, until he's declared a proven bust if he ever is.

Sorry if I sound like a broken record. We'll see him next year at the WJC, I'm sure.

 

[montreal]

Sorry if I sound like a broken record. We'll see him next year at the WJC, I'm sure.

too old, he turned 19 last month.

 

[26Mats]

Add Arsen

Some are saying Ikonen and Olofsson won't get contracts. Arsen got one. Yet he hasn't been added, while the former two have?

 

[Kudo Shinichi]

Cale Fleury
He played 41 nhl games and looked good for a big part of it

 

[The Great Weal]

Ylonen, but Fleury and Evans should be higher. They are already borderline NHLers and them being 12th and 13th doesn't make much sense.

 

[Treb]

Ylonen, but Fleury and Evans should be higher. They are already borderline NHLers and them being 12th and 13th doesn't make much sense.

Floor vs ceiling.

 

[The Great Weal]

Floor vs ceiling.

Well if we were doing these polls solely based on ceiling, Caufield should be #1 without a doubt. You should take into account both of floor and ceiling.

I also don't think Harris's ceiling is much, if at all, higher than Fleurys. If anything, Brook has shown bigger potential in terms of ceiling than most of these guys, yet he's ranked pretty low.

 

[Treb]

Well if we were doing these polls solely based on ceiling, Caufield should be #1 without a doubt. You should take into account both of floor and ceiling.

I also don't think Harris's ceiling is much, if at all, higher than Fleurys. If anything, Brook has shown bigger potential in terms of ceiling than most of these guys, yet he's ranked pretty low.

I personally have Caufield #1 and Brook #6.

I voted Ylonen. Fleury, Juulsen and Tuch are next for me.

 

[26Mats]

Ylonen, but Fleury and Evans should be higher. They are already borderline NHLers and them being 12th and 13th doesn't make much sense.

I think it speaks to the depth of our prospect pool, though not necessarily the amount of high end prospects we have.

Who do you have them ahead of? We have a really good top 16, 17, or 18, depending on one's perspective.

 

[26Mats]

I personally have Caufield #1 and Brook #6.

I voted Ylonen. Fleury, Juulsen and Tuch are next for me.

That leaves Evan's and Farrell, two prospects I'm high on, 15th and 16th. And that's fine. There are a lot of say currently B level prospects, with either high potential or high probability to be at least NHLers. I see Evan's as highly probable an NHLer and Farrell as having a top 6 ceiling, who could easily bust.

 

[The Great Weal]

I think it speaks to the depth of our prospect pool, though not necessarily the amount of high end prospects we have.

Who do you have them ahead of? We have a really good top 16, 17, or 18, depending on one's perspective.

Depth is good and all, but I think everyone outside of Romanov and Caufield are in a very similar range. Maybe it's just this ordinal measurement that makes it seem like they are ranked below others, when in reality, they are just as good or very close to them.

 

[Vachon23]

Well if we were doing these polls solely based on ceiling, Caufield should be #1 without a doubt. You should take into account both of floor and ceiling.

I also don't think Harris's ceiling is much, if at all, higher than Fleurys. If anything, Brook has shown bigger potential in terms of ceiling than most of these guys, yet he's ranked pretty low.

I agree. I don't think Harris has that much a high celling I don't see him higher then a 3rd pair

 

[Treb]

Depth is good and all, but I think everyone outside of Romanov and Caufield are in a very similar range. Maybe it's just this ordinal measurement that makes it seem like they are ranked below others, when in reality, they are just as good or very close to them.

To me, the groups are 1-2, 3-5, 6-9, 10-18, 19-29, 30-37, 39-40, 41-43, 44-45

 

[Treb]

We need more votes.

 

[WeThreeKings]

It would be strange if it was anyone but Ylonen here

 

[Eegs]

Went with Evans. Add McNiven.

 

[Hfbsux]

Add Gorniak