HFBoards Top 31 NHL Defenders - #28 Tiebreaker

[LT]

Usual tiebreaker rules here.

Click to read more...

 

[avalancheboi]

If I’m building a team I’m picking the 6’5” 260 pound monster over the 5’9” dman. Other than that I would put them on near similar levels so I like that they are going back to back.

 

[Machinehead]

I wouldn't say it's "AINEC" but there's enough distance between Spurgeon and Byfuglien that the size doesn't come into play. Spurgeon is better.

 

[StoneHands]

Spurgeon. Buff is more dominant when he's on his game but Spurgeon bring a level of consistency that Buff doesn't have.

 

[blinds]

Spurgeon. Buff is more dominant when he's on his game but Spurgeon bring a level of consistency that Buff doesn't have.

Seems like a good way to frame it. Depends on team needs if you need more consistency or a possible game breaker who can occasionally be a liability.

Voting Buff cause the riskier option is more fun. Also there's still value in having that kind of size/strength in a defenseman.

 

[BruinsBtn]

Buff is the best defenseman in the NHL on the nights where he is 100% on. Other nights, he's the worst player on the ice but I gotta give him the nod here.

 

[canuckinfuts]

Buff by a mile