Okay. Lets take the 05-06 season, where the devils weren't exactly the strongest team. Or how about this past season, where he won another Vezina, and another 40 win season (He's had 7 40 win seasons. There's consistency.), and had a 2.57 GAA, and a 0.911 save percent.
Heck the guy is 2nd all time for Shutouts.
According to you, Goalies have team stats. I guess that includes Hasek as well. I mean, afterall he had his lone 40 win season with a cup winning wings. A very STACKED wings team.
When you think Devils, you think Brodeur , and for a good reason. He's that good. You don't say now "oh well the devils have a great team in front" they don't. They have a good team, but not a cup contending team.
The thing about Brodeur, it doesn't really matter what team is infront, he's proved that he can do it. He constantly leads his team to the playoffs.
Call me crazy, but the stats and hardware don't lie. Even with the quality team in front. Brodeur is great.
I have to disagree man. I will first post Brodeur's and Roy's stats.
Roy's stats:
1985-86 Montreal Canadiens NHL 47 0 3 4 2651 148 0 1 3.35 23 18 3 1037 0.875
1986-87 Montreal Canadiens NHL 46 0 1 8 2686 131 6 1 2.93 22 16 6 1073 0.891
1987-88 Montreal Canadiens NHL 45 0 2 14 2586 125 0 3 2.90 23 12 9 1123 0.900
1988-89 Montreal Canadiens NHL 48 0 6 2 2744 113 2 4 2.47 33 5 6 1113 0.908
1989-90 Montreal Canadiens NHL 54 0 5 0 3173 134 2 3 2.53 31 16 5 1390 0.912
1990-91 Montreal Canadiens NHL 48 0 2 6 2835 128 3 1 2.71 25 15 6 1234 0.906
1991-92 Montreal Canadiens NHL 67 0 5 4 3935 155 7 5 2.36 36 22 8 1651 0.914
1992-93 Montreal Canadiens NHL 62 0 2 16 3595 192 5 2 3.20 31 25 5 1622 0.894
1993-94 Montreal Canadiens NHL 68 0 1 30 3867 161 4 7 2.50 35 17 11 1795 0.918
1994-95 Montreal Canadiens NHL 43 0 1 20 2566 127 3 1 2.97 17 20 6 1230 0.906
1995-96 Montreal Canadiens NHL 22 0 0 6 1260 62 0 1 2.95 12 9 1 605 0.907
1995-96 Colorado Avalanche NHL 39 0 0 4 2305 103 3 1 2.68 22 15 1 1027 0.909
1996-97 Colorado Avalanche NHL 62 0 1 15 3698 143 3 7 2.32 38 15 7 1718 0.923
1997-98 Colorado Avalanche NHL 65 0 3 39 3835 153 5 4 2.39 31 19 13 1825 0.916
1998-99 Colorado Avalanche NHL 61 0 2 28 3648 139 4 5 2.29 32 19 8 1534 0.917
1999-00 Colorado Avalanche NHL 63 0 3 10 3704 141 5 2 2.28 32 21 8 1640 0.914
2000-01 Colorado Avalanche NHL 62 0 5 10 3585 132 5 4 2.21 40 13 7 1513 0.913
2001-02 Colorado Avalanche NHL 63 0 3 26 3773 122 6 9 1.94 32 23 8 1629 0.925
2002-03 Colorado Avalanche NHL 63 0 0 20 3769 137 3 5 2.18 35 15 13 1586 0.920
Playoffs Roy:
Playoffs
SEASON GP MIN W L GA SO GAA SA Sv% G A PIM
2002-03 7 423 3 4 16 1 2,27 177 .910 0 0 0
2001-02 21 1241 11 10 52 3 2,51 572 .909 0 2 0
2000-01 23 1451 16 7 41 4 1,70 581 .934 0 1 0
1999-00 17 1039 11 6 31 3 1,79 431 .928 0 1 4
1998-99 19 1173 11 8 52 1 2,66 650 .920 0 2 4
1997-98 7 430 3 4 18 0 2,51 191 .906 0 1 0
1996-97 17 1034 10 7 38 3 2,21 559 .932 0 0 12
1995-96 22 1454 16 6 51 3 2,10 649 .921 0 0 0
1993-94 6 375 3 3 16 0 2,56 228 .930 0 0 0
1992-93 20 1293 16 4 46 0 2,13 647 .929 0 1 4
1991-92 11 686 4 7 30 1 2,62 312 .904 0 0 2
1990-91 13 785 7 5 40 0 3,06 394 .898 0 0 2
1989-90 11 641 5 6 26 1 2,43 292 .911 0 1 0
1988-89 19 1206 13 6 42 2 2,09 528 .920 0 2 16
1987-88 8 430 3 4 24 0 3,35 218 .890 0 0 0
1986-87 6 330 4 2 22 0 4,00 173 .873 0 0 0
1985-86 20 1218 15 5 39 1 1,92 506 .923 0 0 10
Brodeur's stats:
1993-1994 Devils 47 2,625 27 11 8 - 105 1,238 3 2.40 .915
1994-1995 Devils 40 2,184 19 11 6 - 89 908 3 2.44 .902
1995-1996 Devils 77 4,433 34 30 12 - 173 1,954 6 2.34 .911
1995-1996 Canada WC-A 3 180 0 1 1 - 9 0 3.00
1996-1997 Devils 67 3,838 37 14 13 - 120 1,633 10 1.88 .927
1996-1997 Canada W-Cup 2 60 0 1 0 - 4 0 4.00
1997-1998 Devils 70 4,128 43 17 8 - 130 1,569 10 1.89 .917
1997-1998 Canada Olympics 0 -
1998-1999 Devils 70 4,238 39 21 10 - 162 1,728 4 2.29 .906
1999-2000 Devils 72 4,311 43 20 8 - 161 1,797 6 2.24 .910
2000-2001 Devils 72 4,296 42 17 11 - 166 1,762 9 2.32 .906
2001-2002 Devils 73 4,346 38 26 9 - 156 1,655 4 2.15 .906
2001-2002 Canada Olympics 5 300 4 0 1 - 9 0 1.80
2002-2003 Devils 73 4,374 41 23 9 - 147 1,706 9 2.02 .914
2003-2004 Devils 75 4,554 38 26 11 - 154 1,845 11 2.03 .917
2004-2005 Canada W-Cup 5 300 5 0 0 - 5 129 1 1.00
2004-2005 Canada WC-A 7 419 5 2 0 - 20 218 0 2.87
2005-2006 Devils 73 4,364 43 23 - 7 187 2,105 5 2.57 .911
2005-2006 Canada Olympics 4 239 2 2 - 8 0 2.01
2006-2007 Devils 78 4,696 48 23 - 7 171 2,182 12 2.18 .922
2007-2008 Devils 77 4,635 44 27 - 6 168 2,089 4 2.17 .920
Playoffs Brodeur:
1993-1994 Devils 17 1,170 8 9 38 531 1 1.95 .928
1994-1995 Devils 20 1,221 16 4 34 463 3 1.67 .927
1996-1997 Devils 10 658 5 5 19 268 2 1.73 .929
1997-1998 Devils 6 366 2 4 12 164 0 1.97 .927
1998-1999 Devils 7 424 3 4 20 139 0 2.83 .856
1999-2000 Devils 23 1,450 16 7 39 537 2 1.61 .927
2000-2001 Devils 25 1,504 15 10 52 507 4 2.07 .897
2001-2002 Devils 6 381 2 4 9 145 1 1.42 .938
2002-2003 Devils 24 1,490 16 8 41 622 7 1.65 .934
2003-2004 Devils 5 297 1 4 13 133 0 2.62 .902
2005-2006 Devils 9 532 5 4 20 261 1 2.25 .923
2006-2007 Devils 11 688 5 6 28 332 1 2.44 .916
2007-2008 Devils 5 300 1 4 16 147 0 3.19 .891
Different years, eras affect goalie stats. What I mean is you can't historical stats from different years especially because in later years, the trap system became a lot more developed which inflated goalies's stats. This year about 35 or 40 goalies in the NHL have a .900 save percentage or higher and under a 3.00 GAA. In the past those kind of numbers were unheard of.
In my opinion one of the best indicators of goaltending performance is save percentage and playoff history. The other stats I feel are more team stats. from 1993- 2003 Brodeur only had a better save percentage than Roy in 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 and 1997 - 1998. Brodeur only had a save percentage that was marginally better than Roy in those 3 seasons as well. In quite a few of those other seasons, Roy had a lot higher save percentage than Brodeur.
As for playoff stats. Brodeur only had a better save percentage than Roy in 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 seasons. All the other seasons when both of them participated in the playoffs, Roy had higher numbers and some of those seasons Roy had a much, much higher save percentage.
The save percentage, four Stanley Cups, and four Conn Smyths is why I would rank Roy higher than Brodeur. Another reason is because I feel that Brodeur benefited from a trap system while Roy played for teams with a more open style of play.
Hasek had higher save percentages but did not have the playoff success that Roy and Brodeur have had. I know some will argue that he played on weaker teams so he had less chances to win the cup. That is true, however, I personally feel that in order to be considered the best of this generation, you need the Stanley cups rings + the save percentage stats. I personally place Stanley Cup rings/ Conn Smyths at a higher weight value than statistics. Roy had higher save percentages than Brodeur and more Stanley Cups/ Conn Smyths.
Brodeur has more Stanley cup rings/ Conn Smyths but a lower save percentage than Hasek
All 3 are great goalies but my final ranking would be 1) Roy 2) Brodeur 3) Hasek.