Discussion in 'Polls - (hockey-related only)' started by GeorgeLeafer12, Oct 24, 2018.
Is Jeff Petry elite?
Uh no. How many elite D-man do you think are in the league?
So your answer is no?
I wouldn’t consider him elite but he has definitely grown to be a damn good D man
LMAO. Um, no. Only in Montreal, where they have almost zero talent, could Petry be called an elite player.
This is more of a vocabulary question
Im sure everyone defines the word elite differently
I don't consider him a top-pairing D-man at this point, no.
Excellent #3 RHD. I'd love to have him on the Leafs but there isn't an HFboards trade that works.
There never is.
High end #3, which is not elite. But he's a damn good player.
High-end #3 or a capable #2. Not elite.
He's not elite(very good though) and he hasn't grown any in Montreal.
He was the same player in Edmonton MacT just couldn't see it on account of being stupid.
#2 or #3 not close to an elite #1 lol
He's an amazing fantasy pick but not elite in a real game haha
Real good though he was a great pickup!
He'd be the Leafs 2nd best dman right now
I'm a fan
No, he's a mid-tier guy pushed to perform above his level.
No. But he was a great acquisition by Montreal. Not often you can pick up a 2 or 3 defenseman like this. He’s really underrated imo.
I think this one is lopsided enough to be closed now.
Separate names with a comma.