ok in lieu of the Seguin or RHN thread, Hall and RHB were both 1st overall picks and both are on the same team, but if the Oilers had the choice between either of the two who would it be?
ok in lieu of the Seguin or RHN thread, Hall and RHB were both 1st overall picks and both are on the same team, but if the Oilers had the choice between either of the two who would it be?
This thread targets Oil fans and every Oil fan is going to pick Hall. He was the more hyped prospect, came in and had an immediate impact, and is exciting as hell to watch. On the flipside, most people havent actually SEEN RNH play. Poll isnt really fair to RNH, and seems like a roundabout way to exhibit that Seguin should > RNH (or maybe im just paranoid)
That said, from what I gather from posts of those who attended the Oilers prospect camp, RNH looks very VERY good. Will be exciting to see how the two develop together in the next 5 years.
Tough call. Hall is the goal scorer, RNH is the playmaker; they will complement each other quite nicely.
Hall might get the nod because his compete level is off the charts. I remember the Memorial Cup where Hall was nailed head first into the end boards in what could have been a serious injury then, later on the same shift he scored a highlight reel goal. They guy has a hunger and drive you don't see in many players.
The reality is, they will both be great.
Hall will catch your eye more because of his incredible speed and tenacity but i honestly believe that RNH will be the better overall player by a hair, there is just something very special about his game the way he can slow down the game and see the whole ice in a way that few can, these types of players tend to succeed very highly at the NHL level.
However, Hall will always be the guy who leads the charge for the Oilers and will be their captain within a few years imo.
If i were to start a franchise, i would take Hall even though i think RNH will be the slightly better overall player if that makes any sense.
This is like comparing Toews (Hall but a LW) and Kane (RNH). Hall screams winner who is tough to play against, create chances on his own, and probably won't put up as many points as RNH.
This is like comparing Toews (Hall but a LW) and Kane (RNH). Hall screams winner who is tough to play against, create chances on his own, and probably won't put up as many points as RNH.
I have trouble watching that it. I thought he broke his face and his back when that happened. To come back and score that nice goal must have sealed the deal for the Oilers. He's the kind of guy that you win cups with.That hit was almost comical in how bad it looked, with Hall not being seriously injured.
This exactly what I think as well. Hall and RNH will be what Toews and Kane are to Chicago, except Hall is more like Toews while RNH is more like Kane. If I had to pick one, I'd pick Hall over RNH but I'm glad that we have both of them along with Ebs and Paajarvi. Now it's time to fix up that D and we should be good to go.